Calculators · RRSP and TFSA · 2026 tax year

RRSP vs TFSA Calculator

This RRSP vs TFSA calculator shows which account leaves you more money after tax by comparing two numbers: your marginal tax rate today and your marginal rate in the years you withdraw. If today’s rate is higher, the RRSP wins. If the later rate is higher, the TFSA wins. If they match, the two accounts tie to the dollar. For example, an Ontario earner at $130,000 who expects $55,000 of taxable income in retirement ends up $6,861 ahead in the RRSP on $10,000 of pre-tax pay invested for 25 years at an example 5% return. The tables below show 30 income pairs and every province.

Written by a CPASharad Gondaliya, CPA Ontario No. 61040184
CFA charterholder reviewerNeha Gupta, CFA reviews our investing and account pages; each page shows its review status
Figures checkedOctober 28, 2026
Same engine as the calculatorEvery table uses the calculator’s own 2026 tax method for all 13 provinces and territories

At a glance

What the calculator answers. Whether a set amount of pre-tax income is worth more after tax in an RRSP or in a TFSA, and by how many dollars, for your province, your income now, your expected income when you withdraw, the number of years and an example rate of return.

The rule it applies. The RRSP leaves more when your marginal rate now is higher than your marginal rate at withdrawal. The TFSA leaves more when the later rate is higher. When the two rates are equal, the results are equal. The return and the number of years change the size of the gap, never the winner.

What you need. Your province, your 2026 taxable income before the contribution, and an estimate of your taxable income in the years you will draw the money, counting CPP, OAS, any workplace pension and the RRIF minimums your RRSP will force out.

2026 figures behind it. 2026 federal and provincial brackets and basic personal amounts. The 2026 TFSA limit is $7,000. New RRSP room for 2026 is capped at $33,810 or 18% of 2025 earned income, whichever is less. CRA’s 60-day rule makes Monday, March 1, 2027 the last day to contribute for 2026; CRA usually posts the date in January.

What it leaves out. The OAS recovery tax of 15% on 2026 net income above $95,323, reductions to the Guaranteed Income Supplement, the Canada Child Benefit and credits other than the basic personal amounts. Sections 6 and 7 show how to adjust for each one.

Enter your province, your taxable income now and when you expect to withdraw, the pre-tax amount, the years invested and an example return to see which account leaves more after tax and by how much.

$338.64Value of each percentage point of rate gap on $10,000 over 25 years at an example 5%
$6,861RRSP advantage at $130,000 now and $55,000 later in Ontario (example)
$7,0002026 TFSA dollar limit
$33,8102026 RRSP dollar limit

1. How to Use the RRSP vs TFSA Calculator

Province or territory. Pick the province or territory where you live on December 31. The calculator uses that province’s 2026 brackets for both rates. If you expect to retire somewhere else, read the later rate for that province from the reference table in section 4 and compare it with the rate now that the calculator shows.

Taxable income now. Enter this year’s taxable income before the RRSP contribution you are thinking about: salary, self-employment profit, rental income and other taxable amounts, after deductions you already claim. The calculator turns it into your marginal rate on the next $100 of income. That is the rate a TFSA saver pays on the money before it goes in.

Expected taxable income when you withdraw. This is the input that decides the answer, so take a few minutes over it. Total the taxable income you expect in a typical retirement year, measured at current prices. Count CPP and OAS, a workplace pension if you will have one, any part-time or rental income, and the RRIF minimum withdrawals your RRSP will eventually require. Because the calculator uses 2026 brackets, today’s prices keep the two rates on the same scale. If you are unsure, please run it three times: at your best guess, $15,000 higher and $15,000 lower.

Pre-tax amount, years and return. The pre-tax amount is the salary you set aside before tax. In the RRSP all of it is invested, because the deduction gives back the tax. In the TFSA you pay the tax first and invest the rest. The years and the yearly return are example assumptions, not forecasts, and both accounts get the same return.

Reading the result. The headline names the account that leaves more and the gap in dollars, or says the result is the same in both. Four lines follow: your marginal rate now, your marginal rate at withdrawal, the RRSP’s after-tax value and the TFSA’s after-tax value. For the full tax picture in any year, our income tax calculator shows every bracket, and every tool we publish is listed on the calculators hub.

2. The Rules and the Formula Behind the Numbers

The formula. Call the pre-tax amount A and the growth factor G, where G is one plus the return, multiplied by itself once for each year. The calculator then works out two values. RRSP after tax = A x G x (1 – rate at withdrawal). TFSA after tax = A x (1 – rate now) x G. The gap between them is A x G x (rate now – rate at withdrawal).

Why growth never picks the winner. G appears in both values, so it cannot change which one is larger. It only scales the gap. On $10,000 over 25 years at an example 5%, G is 3.3864 and the money grows to $33,863.55 ($10,000 x 3.3864), so every percentage point of difference between the two rates is worth $338.64 ($33,863.55 x 1%).

The formula worked through for one hypothetical saver in Ontario
PieceValueHow it is found
Pre-tax amount (A)$10,000Entered
Growth factor (G), 25 years at 5%3.38641.05 multiplied by itself 25 times
Marginal rate now, at $130,00043.41%Tax on the next $100 of income
Marginal rate at withdrawal, at $55,00023.15%Tax on the next $100 of income
RRSP value before tax$33,863.55A x G
Tax on the RRSP withdrawal$7,839.41$33,863.55 x 23.15%
RRSP after tax$26,024.14$33,863.55 x 76.85%
TFSA contribution after tax now$5,659.04$10,000 x 56.59%
TFSA after tax$19,163.52$5,659.04 x 3.3864
Gap in favour of the RRSP$6,860.62$26,024.14 minus $19,163.52

How the marginal rate is measured. For each income you enter, the calculator works out total 2026 tax at that income and at $100 more, then divides the difference by $100. Total tax includes federal and provincial brackets, the federal and provincial basic personal amounts, the Ontario surtax and Ontario Health Premium, the Ontario and B.C. low-income tax reductions and the 16.5% Quebec abatement on federal tax. It leaves out CPP and EI credits, the age amount, the pension income amount and other credits.

2026 figures that frame an RRSP or TFSA decision
Rule2026 figure
TFSA dollar limit$7,000
Total TFSA room since 2009, if eligible every year and never used$109,000
RRSP deduction limitThe lesser of $33,810 and 18% of 2025 earned income, minus any pension adjustment, plus room carried forward
RRSP dollar limit already published for 2027$35,390
Last day to contribute to an RRSP for 2026March 1, 2027, the 60th day of 2027 under CRA’s rule (CRA usually posts the date in January)
2026 return filing and balance due dateApril 30, 2027
OAS recovery tax15% of 2026 net income above $95,323
GIS income cut-off, single pensioner, October to December 2026$23,112

The room limits matter too. The calculator does not check whether you have room. A TFSA over-contribution is taxed at 1% a month with no buffer, and an RRSP excess above a $2,000 buffer is taxed at the same rate. Our TFSA limit and RRSP contribution limit pages show how to find your figures.

3. Worked Examples: Three Income Pairs

This example is hypothetical. Three Ontario residents each set aside $10,000 of pre-tax pay, invested for 25 years at an example 5% return, which turns $10,000 into $33,863.55. Rates are the calculator’s 2026 marginal rates.

  1. Priya earns $55,000 and expects $40,000 in retirement. Her rate now is 23.15% and her rate later is 19.05%. The RRSP holds $33,863.55 and keeps $27,412.54 after tax ($33,863.55 x 80.95%). The TFSA receives $7,685.00 ($10,000 x 76.85%) and grows to $26,024.14. The RRSP is ahead by $1,388.41, which is 4.10 points x $338.64.
  2. Marcus earns $130,000 and expects $55,000 in retirement. His rate falls from 43.41% to 23.15%, a gap of 20.26 points. The RRSP keeps $26,024.14 after tax and the TFSA, funded with $5,659.04, grows to $19,163.52. The RRSP is ahead by $6,860.62 ($26,024.14 – $19,163.52).
  3. Leah earns $45,000 and expects $75,000 in retirement from a workplace pension, CPP and OAS. Her rate rises from 19.05% to 29.65%. The RRSP keeps $23,823.01 ($33,863.55 x 70.35%). The TFSA receives $8,095.00 and grows to $27,412.54. The TFSA is ahead by $3,589.54 ($27,412.54 – $23,823.01).
Three income pairs in Ontario: $10,000 pre-tax, 25 years, example 5% return (hypothetical)
SaverIncome nowIncome laterRate nowRate laterRRSP after taxTFSA after taxResult
Priya$55,000$40,00023.15%19.05%$27,413$26,024RRSP by $1,388
Marcus$130,000$55,00043.41%23.15%$26,024$19,164RRSP by $6,861
Leah$45,000$75,00019.05%29.65%$23,823$27,413TFSA by $3,590

What the three cases show. Priya’s small rate gap gives a small edge, and section 7 shows it shrinks further once the exact tax saving on her deduction is used. Marcus has the classic RRSP profile: a high rate while working and a modest retirement income. Leah’s pension will keep her later income above her working income, so every RRSP dollar would be taxed at a higher rate than the one it saved.

Same rate, same result. Enter equal incomes now and later and the calculator shows no gap. At $75,000 in both years in Ontario, each account ends with $23,823.01 ($10,000 x 70.35% x 3.3864). The tie depends on the whole pre-tax $10,000 going into the RRSP, refund included; section 5 explains why.

Time and return only scale the gap. The table below runs Marcus’s pair over three periods and three example returns. The RRSP wins in every cell because his rate falls by 20.26 points. Only the size of the win changes.

RRSP advantage for Marcus by years and example return ($10,000 pre-tax, hypothetical)
Years investedAt 3% a yearAt 5% a yearAt 7% a year
10$2,723$3,300$3,985
25$4,242$6,861$10,996
40$6,609$14,263$30,338

Before you rely on one run, test your retirement income at a higher and a lower figure in the calculator.

4. Reference Tables: Who Comes Out Ahead at Each Income

The Ontario grid. Each cell is the RRSP’s after-tax value minus the TFSA’s for $10,000 of pre-tax income over 25 years at an example 5%, using the calculator’s method. A positive figure means the RRSP leaves more; a negative figure means the TFSA does; $0 is a tie. Read across from your income now to your expected income later.

RRSP minus TFSA in Ontario, 2026 brackets (rate at each income in brackets)
Income nowLater $40,000 (19.05%)Later $55,000 (23.15%)Later $75,000 (29.65%)Later $100,000 (31.48%)Later $120,000 (43.41%)
$45,000 (19.05%)$0-$1,388-$3,590-$4,209-$8,249
$55,000 (23.15%)$1,388$0-$2,201-$2,821-$6,861
$75,000 (29.65%)$3,590$2,201$0-$620-$4,659
$100,000 (31.48%)$4,209$2,821$620$0-$4,040
$130,000 (43.41%)$8,249$6,861$4,659$4,040$0
$175,000 (44.97%)$8,777$7,389$5,188$4,568$528

Reading the grid. Below the diagonal the RRSP wins; above it the TFSA wins. The later figures leave out the OAS recovery tax, so for a retiree receiving OAS the $100,000 and $120,000 columns overstate the RRSP. Section 6 adjusts them.

Every province for one pair. The same $10,000 for someone at $130,000 now and $55,000 later, sorted by the size of the RRSP’s lead. Provinces with a steep climb in rates between the two incomes, such as Ontario, show the widest gap.

$130,000 now and $55,000 later: $10,000 pre-tax, 25 years, example 5% (hypothetical)
Province or territoryRate nowRate laterRRSP after taxTFSA after taxRRSP ahead by
Ontario43.41%23.15%$26,024$19,164$6,861
Nunavut35.00%18.00%$27,768$22,011$5,757
Manitoba43.40%26.75%$24,805$19,167$5,638
British Columbia38.29%21.70%$26,515$20,897$5,618
Yukon36.90%20.40%$26,955$21,368$5,587
Prince Edward Island43.62%27.47%$24,561$19,092$5,469
Northwest Territories38.20%22.60%$26,210$20,928$5,283
Quebec45.71%30.69%$23,471$18,385$5,086
Nova Scotia43.50%28.95%$24,060$19,133$4,927
Alberta36.00%22.00%$26,414$21,673$4,741
New Brunswick42.00%28.00%$24,382$19,641$4,741
Newfoundland and Labrador41.80%28.50%$24,212$19,709$4,504
Saskatchewan38.50%26.50%$24,890$20,826$4,064

The rates the calculator uses. These are the 2026 marginal rates on the next $100 of ordinary income at six incomes. Search or sort the table to find your province, then compare the rate at your income now with the rate at your expected retirement income.

2026 combined marginal rates used by the calculator
Province or territory$40,000$55,000$75,000$100,000$130,000$175,000
Alberta22.00%22.00%30.50%30.50%36.00%38.00%
British Columbia23.16%21.70%28.20%28.20%38.29%40.70%
Manitoba24.80%26.75%33.25%37.90%43.40%43.40%
New Brunswick23.40%28.00%34.50%34.50%42.00%42.00%
Newfoundland and Labrador22.70%28.50%35.00%36.30%41.80%43.80%
Northwest Territories19.90%22.60%29.10%29.10%38.20%40.05%
Nova Scotia28.95%28.95%37.17%38.00%43.50%47.00%
Nunavut18.00%18.00%27.50%27.50%35.00%35.00%
Ontario19.05%23.15%29.65%31.48%43.41%44.97%
Prince Edward Island27.47%27.47%37.10%37.10%43.62%45.00%
Quebec25.69%30.69%36.12%36.12%45.71%47.46%
Saskatchewan24.50%26.50%33.00%33.00%38.50%40.50%
Yukon20.40%20.40%29.50%29.50%36.90%36.90%

Odd-looking rates. B.C. is higher at $40,000 than at $55,000 because its low-income tax reduction shrinks in that range. Rates also jump in narrow bands, for example where the Ontario Health Premium steps up. Our marginal tax rates by province page shows every bracket edge, and the Ontario tax brackets page explains the surtax.

5. Reinvesting the Refund: The Assumption That Makes the RRSP Work

What the calculator assumes. The RRSP result assumes the whole pre-tax amount goes into the RRSP. In real life most people contribute from take-home pay and get the tax back as a refund months later. Whether the refund is invested decides whether the RRSP matches the calculator.

Marcus’s $10,000 of pre-tax pay four ways: 25 years at an example 5% (hypothetical)
ApproachPut inRefundValue after 25 yearsAfter tax at 23.15%Compared with the TFSA
A. TFSA$5,659.04None$19,163.52$19,163.52Baseline
B. RRSP, full pre-tax amount$10,000.00Covers the tax$33,863.55$26,024.14$6,860.62 ahead
C. RRSP, refund spent$5,659.04$2,456.57 spent$19,163.52$14,727.16$4,436.36 behind
D. RRSP, refund into a TFSA$5,659.04$2,456.57 to a TFSA$19,163.52 plus $8,318.81$23,045.97$3,882.45 ahead

Approach B is the calculator’s case. Marcus contributes $10,000 and the deduction saves $4,340.96 of tax, so his own money in the plan is only $5,659.04, the same as the TFSA saver. He needs the full $10,000 at contribution time, from savings or a payroll plan, and the refund then replaces the savings he used.

Approach C loses to the TFSA. Contributing $5,659.04 and spending the $2,456.57 refund ($5,659.04 x 43.41%) leaves a smaller pre-tax pot that is still taxed at 23.15% on the way out. The RRSP then trails the TFSA by $4,436.36, even with a much lower tax rate in retirement.

Approach D is the usual middle path. Putting the refund in a TFSA keeps it invested and tax-free. D falls short of B because the refund itself gets no deduction, but it beats the TFSA alone by $3,882.45. Contributing the refund to the RRSP again the following year moves the result closer to B.

Getting the refund sooner. When an employer deducts RRSP contributions from your pay, it can usually withhold less income tax on each cheque, so the saving reaches you through the year instead of in one refund. For a lump sum, the refund comes after you file. For 2026, the 60-day rule puts the last contribution day at March 1, 2027, and the return is due April 30, 2027; our RRSP deadline page lists the dates. Use the calculator below to see the exact tax a contribution saves at your income.

From refund to rate. Divide the tax saved by the contribution to get your average saving per dollar. If that figure is clearly below your marginal rate, the deduction crosses a bracket, and the next section shows what that does to the comparison. Our RRSP tax refund calculator page has tables at many incomes.

6. OAS Recovery Tax and GIS: What the Calculator Leaves Out

Why benefits matter. RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count as income for Old Age Security and the Guaranteed Income Supplement. TFSA withdrawals do not. A withdrawal that triggers a benefit reduction is taxed twice over: once by the brackets and again by the lost benefit. The calculator shows only the first, so please add the second yourself.

The OAS adjustment. The recovery tax takes back 15 cents of OAS for every dollar of 2026 net income over $95,323. Service Canada estimates that nothing is left at $155,320 for pensioners aged 65 to 74, or at $161,320 for those 75 and older. If your later income will fall in that band, add 15 points to the later rate the calculator shows. Above the top of the band there is no OAS left to lose, so the extra 15 points stop.

Marcus at $130,000 now: the later rate with and without OAS recovery ($10,000 pre-tax, 25 years, 5%, aged 65 to 74, hypothetical)
Income laterBracket rate laterOAS recoveryRate including recoveryRRSP after taxTFSA after taxBetter account
$55,00023.15%None23.15%$26,024$19,164RRSP by $6,861
$80,00029.65%None29.65%$23,823$19,164RRSP by $4,659
$100,00031.48%15%46.48%$18,124$19,164TFSA by $1,040
$120,00043.41%15%58.41%$14,084$19,164TFSA by $5,080
$165,00044.97%None, OAS already fully recovered44.97%$18,635$19,164TFSA by $528

What the table shows. Without the recovery tax, the calculator would call the $100,000 case a $4,040 win for the RRSP. With it, the TFSA leads by $1,040. A retiree headed for that band can often do better by drawing RRSP money earlier, before OAS starts, or by splitting eligible pension income with a spouse. Our OAS clawback guide and the retirement withdrawal order page cover both.

The GIS problem. The Guaranteed Income Supplement is paid to lower-income OAS pensioners and is reduced as other income rises. For October to December 2026, the single maximum is $1,138.90 a month and the supplement stops at $23,112 of income. GIS is based on the previous year’s income, and TFSA withdrawals are not counted.

A GIS example. This example is hypothetical. Rosa earns $45,000 now (19.05%) and expects about $15,000 of income as a single retiree. Her bracket rate later is 0%, so the calculator shows the RRSP ahead: $33,863.55 against $27,412.54 in the TFSA. But GIS is lost on each RRSP dollar she draws. Across the whole range, the $13,666.80 yearly maximum ($1,138.90 x 12) disappears over $23,112 of income, an average of about 59 cents per dollar ($13,666.80 ÷ $23,112). At that average loss, her RRSP would be worth about $13,840 to her, and the TFSA would be ahead by about $13,573. Service Canada sets the exact reduction, but the direction is clear: for anyone likely to receive GIS, the TFSA usually wins. See our Guaranteed Income Supplement guide.

7. When the Two-Rate Model Needs Adjusting

A deduction that crosses a bracket. The calculator applies your rate on the next $100 to the whole amount. A large deduction can pull income down into a lower bracket, so the real saving is smaller. Priya’s $10,000 deduction at $55,000 saves $2,100.47 (21.00%), not 23.15%, because it reaches below the $53,891 Ontario bracket edge. With that exact saving, her TFSA would receive $7,899.53 and grow to $26,750.62, cutting the RRSP’s lead from $1,388.41 to $661.92 ($27,412.54 – $26,750.62). The fix: use the refund calculator above for the exact saving and compare its rate with your later rate.

A deduction that gains from a step. The reverse also happens. A $7,000 deduction from $75,000 in Ontario saves $2,225.50 (31.79%), above the 29.65% marginal rate, because it also removes $150 of Ontario Health Premium.

A withdrawal that crosses a bracket. The calculator taxes the whole RRSP at one later rate, which assumes the money comes out in pieces small enough to stay in that bracket. If Marcus took all $33,863.55 in one year on top of $55,000, the tax would be $9,961.55 (29.42%). Spread over five years it would be $8,895.57 (26.27%), and over ten years $7,839.41 (23.15%), the rate the calculator used. Our RRSP withdrawal calculator and RRIF calculator help plan the pace.

Things that favour the RRSP but are not in the formula. An employer match on a group RRSP is an immediate return; see our group RRSP guide. For parents, an RRSP deduction lowers adjusted family net income, and under the July 2026 to June 2027 formula a family with two children above $82,847 loses 5.7% of each extra dollar of Canada Child Benefit, so a $10,000 deduction there adds $570 a year of benefit on top of the tax saved. The thresholds for the benefit year that uses 2026 income are not out yet, so treat that figure as a guide. On the investment side, the Canada-US tax treaty spares US-listed dividends held directly in an RRSP from US withholding tax, while the same dividends in a TFSA usually lose 15%.

Things that favour the TFSA but are not in the formula. Money taken from a TFSA becomes new room the following January 1, but an RRSP withdrawal gives no room back. By December 31 of the year you turn 71, an RRSP has to be cashed out, used to buy an annuity or moved to a RRIF, and a RRIF then forces out a minimum each year, starting at 5.28% of the balance at age 71 and rising with age. And a spouse or common-law partner named as TFSA successor holder simply becomes the new holder, and the account keeps its tax-free status.

8. What to Do With Your Result

A clear RRSP win. If the RRSP wins at your best guess and at a retirement income $15,000 higher, the deduction is likely worth taking. Plan where the refund will go before you contribute, and check that the contribution fits your room on your notice of assessment.

A clear TFSA win. If the TFSA wins in every run, the RRSP deduction is worth less to you than the flexibility you would give up. You can still build RRSP room by filing returns and use it later in a higher-income year; our guide to unused RRSP room explains how it carries forward.

A close result. A gap of a few hundred dollars over decades is inside the error of any retirement income estimate. Many people split new savings between both accounts, or favour the TFSA for money they may need sooner. Our page on which account to invest in first sets out a general order, and RRSP vs paying down your mortgage covers homeowners weighing a third option.

Check the goal too. The calculator assumes retirement savings. For a first home, a child’s education or flexible savings, another account may fit better. Answer five questions below to see which registered accounts are built for your goal, as general information.

Then compare where to open it. Costs differ widely between providers. Our rankings of the best TFSA accounts and best RRSP accounts are ordered by a published score, and our full TFSA vs RRSP comparison covers the rules of each account side by side.

8 Ways to Get More From an RRSP vs TFSA Comparison

1. Test three retirement incomes

The later income is a guess, so run the calculator at your best estimate and at $15,000 above and below it. If the same account wins all three times, the answer is firm enough to act on; if it flips, consider splitting.

2. Use the exact saving for big deductions

For a contribution large enough to cross a bracket, take the saving from the refund calculator and divide it by the contribution. Compare that rate, not the marginal rate, with your later rate.

3. Add 15 points in the OAS band

If your retirement income will sit between $95,323 and the full-recovery level, add 15 points to the later rate. That one change reverses many results that look like RRSP wins.

4. Plan the refund before you contribute

Decide in advance whether the refund goes back into the RRSP, into a TFSA or onto debt. A refund that is spent turns an RRSP win into a loss against the TFSA.

5. Hold the deduction for a higher year

RRSP contributions can be deducted in a later year. If your income will rise, contributing now and deducting later can raise the rate now that the calculator compares.

6. Draw RRSP money in low-income years

Withdrawals in the years between retirement and the start of CPP and OAS can be taxed at low rates and shrink the RRIF minimums that would otherwise push later income up.

7. Count the match separately

An employer match is a return on top of the tax result. Contributions that earn a match usually come first, whatever the calculator shows for unmatched money.

8. Re-run it every spring

Raises, a new pension plan, children or a move to another province change both rates. A quick check before each RRSP deadline keeps your split current.

RRSP vs TFSA Calculator FAQ

How does an RRSP vs TFSA calculator work?

It compares the same pre-tax dollars in each account. In the RRSP, the whole amount is invested and taxed at your later rate when withdrawn. In the TFSA, tax is paid first at today’s rate and nothing is taxed later. Our calculator measures both rates with 2026 federal and provincial brackets for your province and shows which account leaves more after tax.

Which is better if my tax rate is the same in retirement?

Neither. When your marginal rate now equals your marginal rate at withdrawal, the RRSP and the TFSA leave exactly the same after-tax amount, as long as the RRSP saver invests the full pre-tax amount, including the refund. At $75,000 in Ontario both now and later, $10,000 of pre-tax pay becomes $23,823.01 in each account after 25 years at an example 5%.

Does the rate of return change whether the RRSP or TFSA wins?

No. The growth factor multiplies both results, so it only changes the size of the gap. For a saver whose rate falls from 43.41% to 23.15%, the RRSP’s lead on $10,000 is $3,300 after 10 years at 5% and $14,263 after 40 years. The account with the lower tax rate on the money wins at any return.

What income should I enter for retirement?

Enter your expected yearly taxable income in the years you will withdraw, measured at today’s prices: CPP, OAS, workplace pensions, rental and part-time income, plus the RRIF minimums your RRSP will produce. Then run the calculator again at $15,000 higher and lower. If the winner stays the same in all three runs, the result is a sound basis for a general decision.

Why does the calculator assume I invest the whole refund?

Because that is the only fair comparison. The RRSP deduction returns the tax a TFSA saver pays up front. If you contribute from take-home pay and spend the refund, your RRSP holds less than the calculator assumes. In our example at $130,000 now and $55,000 later, spending the refund turns a $6,860.62 RRSP lead into a $4,436.36 shortfall.

Does the calculator include the OAS clawback or GIS?

No. It uses income tax only. For 2026 income, OAS is reduced by 15% of net income above $95,323, so add 15 points to your later rate if your retirement income will fall in that band. GIS stops at $23,112 of income for a single pensioner from October to December 2026, and RRSP withdrawals reduce it while TFSA withdrawals do not.

How accurate is the marginal rate the calculator uses?

It is your 2026 rate on the next $100 of ordinary income, including basic personal amounts, the Ontario surtax and Health Premium, the Ontario and B.C. tax reductions and the Quebec abatement. A large deduction can cross a bracket, so the real saving can be lower. A $10,000 deduction at $55,000 in Ontario saves 21.00%, not the 23.15% marginal rate.

Should I contribute to an RRSP or a TFSA at $55,000 of income?

It depends on your later income. In Ontario, $55,000 carries a 23.15% marginal rate. If you expect about $40,000 of retirement income, taxed at 19.05%, the RRSP leads by a small margin on $10,000 over 25 years. If a pension will lift your later income to $75,000, the TFSA leads. The calculator runs your own figures; this is general information.

Does the RRSP vs TFSA calculator work in Quebec?

Yes. Choose Quebec and the calculator uses Quebec’s provincial brackets and basic personal amount, plus federal tax reduced by the 16.5% Quebec abatement. At $130,000 now and $55,000 later, the rates are 45.71% and 30.69%, and the RRSP leads by $5,086 on $10,000 over 25 years at an example 5%.

What are the 2026 RRSP and TFSA limits?

The 2026 TFSA limit is $7,000, and someone eligible every year since 2009 who has never contributed has $109,000 of room. For RRSPs, 2026 adds room equal to 18% of your 2025 earned income to a maximum of $33,810, minus any pension adjustment, on top of room you have not used. Under CRA’s 60-day rule, contributions for 2026 are due by March 1, 2027, and the 2027 RRSP dollar limit is $35,390.

Can I use the calculator for a group RRSP with an employer match?

Yes for the tax part, but add the match yourself. The calculator compares the tax effect only. A match is an extra return paid into your RRSP that a TFSA cannot offer, so contributions that earn the full match usually come out ahead whatever the two rates are. Our group RRSP guide explains how workplace plans work.

How does WealthScale keep the calculator and tables accurate?

The calculator and every table on this page use the same 2026 federal and provincial brackets, basic personal amounts, surtaxes and reductions, checked against Canada Revenue Agency publications on October 28, 2026, with benefit figures from Service Canada publications. Static tables were produced with the calculator’s own method. Our editorial standards explain how we check and date each figure.

Run the RRSP vs TFSA calculator with your own two rates, then read the full rules of each account before you decide.

Figures on this page were checked against Canada Revenue Agency publications on October 28, 2026, and the OAS, GIS and Canada Child Benefit figures against Service Canada and CRA benefit publications the same day. We update this page when a figure changes.

Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad Gondaliya, CPA
Sharad Gondaliya, CPAWriter and tax reviewerCPA Ontario No. 61040184

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

  • Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
  • Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
  • Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
  • Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Read Sharad’s profile and verify his credentials

Neha Gupta, CFA, Financial Reviewer at WealthScale
Neha Gupta, CFAFinancial ReviewerCFA charterholder

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.

  • CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
  • Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
  • In financial markets since December 2005
  • More than 2,600 published investment articles

Read Neha’s profile and verify her credentials

General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.