Comparisons · RRSP and mortgages · 2026 tax year

RRSP vs Paying Down Your Mortgage

The RRSP vs mortgage paydown decision comes down to a guaranteed return against a tax refund plus an uncertain one. Every extra dollar on your mortgage earns exactly your mortgage rate, risk-free and tax-free. Every dollar in an RRSP earns a deduction now, worth $2,075.50 on a $7,000 contribution at $70,000 of Ontario income in 2026, plus whatever the investments return, taxed when you withdraw. Our 10-year comparison shows the RRSP ahead when the refund also goes onto the mortgage and your tax rate falls in retirement, and the mortgage ahead when its rate beats your return and your tax rate stays the same.

Written by a CPASharad Gondaliya, CPA Ontario No. 61040184
CFA charterholder reviewerNeha Gupta, CFA reviews our investing and account pages; each page shows its review status
Figures checkedOctober 28, 2026
Tax computed, not guessed2026 brackets; mortgage rates shown are example rates

At a glance

The short answer. Paying down a mortgage earns your mortgage rate with no risk and no tax. An RRSP earns a tax refund now plus an investment return that is not guaranteed, and the money is taxed when you take it out. The RRSP tends to come out ahead when you put the refund to work and expect a lower tax rate in retirement.

The swing factor is the refund. In 2026, a $7,000 RRSP deduction saves $2,075.50 of tax at $70,000 of taxable income in Ontario and $2,816.20 at $120,000. Applied to the mortgage each year, that refund earns the mortgage rate as well.

When prepaying tends to win. When your mortgage rate is higher than the return you can reasonably expect, when your tax rate in retirement will be as high as today, when the RRSP refund would be spent, or when being debt-free sooner matters more to you than the higher expected return.

Prepayment privileges. Most closed mortgages let you pay extra each year without a penalty, as a lump sum or a higher payment, up to a cap set by the lender. Going over the cap can cost the higher of three months’ interest or an interest rate differential.

The TFSA middle path. A TFSA gives no deduction but keeps the money tax-free and within reach. It beats prepaying only if its return beats your mortgage rate, and it lets you choose later whether to put a lump sum on the mortgage.

RRSP contribution vs mortgage prepayment side by side, 2026
FeatureRRSP contributionMortgage prepayment
ReturnWhatever the investments earn; not guaranteedYour mortgage rate, guaranteed
Tax on the way inDeductible; refund at your marginal rateNone; made from after-tax money
Tax on the returnNone while inside; withdrawals taxed as incomeNone; interest avoided is an after-tax saving
RiskMarket risk on the investmentsNone on the saving itself
Access to the moneyWithdrawals taxed, with 10%, 20% or 30% withheld outside QuebecLocked in the home unless you borrow against it again
Room after you take money outLost, except Home Buyers’ Plan and Lifelong Learning Plan amounts repaidNot applicable
2026 limit18% of 2025 earned income, up to $33,810, plus unused roomSet by your lender’s prepayment privileges
DeadlineMarch 1, 2027 for the 2026 deduction, under CRA’s 60-day rule (CRA usually posts the date in January)Set by your contract, usually yearly
Penalty for going over1% a month on an excess above a $2,000 bufferHigher of three months’ interest or an interest rate differential, plus any fee
Effect on Canada Child BenefitLowers family net income, which can raise the benefitNone
Effect on OAS and GIS laterWithdrawals count as incomeA paid-off home lowers the income you need
Cash flow nowRefund arrives after you fileSame payment, shorter amortization, unless you ask to lower the payment
Interest savedNone directly$13,101 over the life of a $450,000 loan at an example 4.5% from one $7,000 lump sum in year one
Best whenTax rate now is clearly above the rate in retirementMortgage rate is high, or the refund would not be invested

Choose your province and enter your taxable income and a contribution to see the tax an RRSP deduction saves, which is the refund you would put on the mortgage or back into savings.

1. RRSP vs Mortgage Paydown: The Short Answer

Two different kinds of return. Interest on a mortgage for the home you live in is generally not tax-deductible, so every dollar of interest you avoid is a dollar of after-tax money saved. A prepayment therefore earns your mortgage rate, after tax, with certainty. An RRSP contribution earns a deduction at your marginal rate plus an investment return that can be higher or lower than the mortgage rate in any year.

What usually tips it toward the RRSP. A marginal rate now that is clearly higher than your expected rate in retirement, a plan to use the refund well, a long time until you need the money, an employer match on a group RRSP, and a mortgage rate below the return you can reasonably expect from a diversified portfolio.

What usually tips it toward the mortgage. A high mortgage rate, a modest income where the deduction is worth less, a retirement income that will be taxed at a similar rate, a habit of spending refunds, a renewal coming up at a higher rate, or simply wanting the security of owning your home outright.

It is rarely all or nothing. Many households do both: contribute to the RRSP and put the refund on the mortgage. Section 4 shows that this split often beats prepaying alone, and section 10 shows how to add a TFSA.

What this page does not do. It uses example mortgage rates and an example investment return to show the arithmetic. It does not forecast rates or returns and does not recommend any investment. The rates you see from lenders change, and our prime rate page explains how variable rates move. Our mortgages hub covers the rules of borrowing.

2. How Each Option Works

A mortgage prepayment. When you pay extra principal, your balance falls, and so does the interest charged on every later payment. If your regular payment stays the same, more of each payment goes to principal and the mortgage ends sooner. The saving compounds at your mortgage rate for as long as the balance would otherwise have been there.

How mortgage interest compounds. In Canada, fixed-rate mortgage rates are by convention quoted with interest compounded half-yearly, not in advance, which the Interest Act allows. An example 4.5% quoted rate works out to an effective yearly rate of 4.5506%, so that is the return a prepayment earns. Our mortgage payment calculator uses the same compounding.

An RRSP contribution. A contribution within your room is deducted from income. Your 2026 limit starts from 18% of what you earned in 2025, capped at $33,810, then drops by any pension adjustment and grows by room left over from earlier years. Counting 60 days into 2027, the window for 2026 contributions closes on Monday, March 1, 2027, a date CRA normally announces each January. The deduction cuts your tax at your marginal rate. The money then grows without yearly tax, and every withdrawal is taxed as income. Our RRSP guide explains the rules.

Why the comparison is not simply rate vs return. The RRSP side has three moving parts: the refund now, the investment return and the tax rate at withdrawal. The mortgage side has one: the rate. Comparing an example 4.5% mortgage rate with an example 5% return ignores the refund, which can be worth 30 cents or more per dollar contributed.

What the refund does. If you put the refund on the mortgage, you get both: the tax-deferred investment and a smaller prepayment. That combination is the fair comparison with prepaying the whole amount, because the out-of-pocket cost is the same.

3. Tax Now vs Tax Later: Your RRSP Refund at Two Incomes

What a $7,000 contribution saves. We use $7,000 a year, the same as the 2026 TFSA limit, so the TFSA comparison later uses the same money. The tax saved is tax on your income minus tax on that income less $7,000, using 2026 Ontario and federal brackets, the basic personal amounts, the Ontario surtax and the Ontario Health Premium.

Tax saved by a $7,000 RRSP deduction in Ontario, 2026
Taxable incomeTax savedSaving per dollarNet cost of the contributionMarginal rate at that income
$70,000$2,075.5029.65%$4,924.5029.65%
$120,000$2,816.2040.23%$4,183.8043.41%

Why the high earner saves less than the marginal rate. At $120,000, the first $2,955 of the deduction is saved at 43.41%, but the rest pulls income back below the $117,045 federal bracket edge, where the rate is lower. The average saving is 40.23%. The refund calculator above shows the same effect at any income.

The later rate. RRSP money is taxed when withdrawn. In the comparisons below we assume withdrawals in retirement are taxed at 23.15%, the 2026 Ontario marginal rate at $55,000 of taxable income, and we also show the case where the later rate equals the saving rate now. Our marginal tax rates page lists rates in every province.

When the refund arrives. A lump-sum contribution produces a refund after you file; for 2026 the filing and balance due date is April 30, 2027. If you contribute through a workplace group RRSP, the tax relief usually comes through lower withholding on each pay instead. For simplicity, the comparison assumes the refund reaches the mortgage at the same time as the contribution, which slightly flatters the RRSP side.

Parents get an extra boost. An RRSP deduction lowers adjusted family net income, which sets the Canada Child Benefit. Under the July 2026 to June 2027 formula, a family with two children above $82,847 loses 5.7% of each extra dollar, so a $7,000 deduction there is worth $399 a year more in benefit ($7,000 x 5.7%); with one child the rate is 3.2%, or $224. A mortgage prepayment does nothing for the benefit. CRA has not yet set the thresholds for the July 2027 benefit year, which uses 2026 income, so take these amounts as estimates; see our Canada Child Benefit guide.

4. The 10-Year Comparison at Three Mortgage Rates and Two Incomes

The set-up. This example is hypothetical. An Ontario homeowner has $7,000 of after-tax savings at the end of each year for 10 years and a mortgage large enough that every prepayment fits within the lender’s privileges. Mortgage rates of 3.5%, 4.5% and 5.5% are example rates, not current or best rates. Inside the RRSP the money is assumed to grow at an example 5% a year, purely to show the arithmetic. Income and 2026 tax rules are held constant.

The three strategies. Prepay: $7,000 a year goes on the mortgage. RRSP plus refund: $7,000 a year goes into the RRSP and the refund goes on the mortgage. The value of each is measured after 10 years: for the mortgage, how much lower the balance is; for the RRSP, its value after tax at withdrawal.

After 10 years at $70,000 of income: refund $2,075.50 a year (hypothetical, example rates; totals and gaps are worked out before rounding)
Example mortgage ratePrepay: balance lower byRRSP after tax at 23.15%Refunds on the mortgageRRSP plus refund totalRRSP route ahead by
3.5%$82,236$67,663$24,383$92,046$9,810
4.5%$86,220$67,663$25,564$93,227$7,007
5.5%$90,447$67,663$26,818$94,480$4,033
After 10 years at $120,000 of income: refund $2,816.20 a year (hypothetical, example rates; totals and gaps are worked out before rounding)
Example mortgage ratePrepay: balance lower byRRSP after tax at 23.15%Refunds on the mortgageRRSP plus refund totalRRSP route ahead by
3.5%$82,236$67,663$33,085$100,747$18,511
4.5%$86,220$67,663$34,688$102,350$16,130
5.5%$90,447$67,663$36,388$104,051$13,604

How the figures were built. Ten yearly deposits of $7,000 at 5% grow to $88,045.25, which is $67,662.77 after tax at 23.15%. Prepayments grow at the mortgage’s effective yearly rate: 3.5306%, 4.5506% or 5.5756%. At the 4.5% example rate, ten $7,000 prepayments leave the balance $86,220.34 lower after 10 years, and ten refunds of $2,075.50 leave it $25,564.33 lower.

What changes if your tax rate does not fall. If RRSP withdrawals are taxed at the same rate the deduction saved, the RRSP’s advantage comes only from its return beating the mortgage rate. At $70,000, the RRSP plus refund route is then ahead by $4,087 at the 3.5% example rate and $1,284 at 4.5%, and behind by $1,690 at 5.5%. At $120,000, it is ahead by $3,472 and $1,091, and behind by $1,436.

RRSP plus refund minus prepay after 10 years, by retirement tax rate (hypothetical)
Income and later rateExample rate 3.5%Example rate 4.5%Example rate 5.5%
$70,000, later rate 23.15%$9,810$7,007$4,033
$70,000, later rate 29.65% (same as now)$4,087$1,284-$1,690
$120,000, later rate 23.15%$18,511$16,130$13,604
$120,000, later rate 40.23% (same as now)$3,472$1,091-$1,436

What if returns disappoint or surprise. At the 4.5% example rate, if the RRSP earned 3% a year instead of 5%, the RRSP route at $70,000 would still lead by $1,014; at 7% it would lead by $13,670. At $120,000 the leads would be $10,137 and $22,793. A fall in tax rate at retirement is a strong cushion; a steady tax rate leaves the RRSP depending on its return.

Not sure what rate you will pay in retirement? Test the RRSP against a TFSA with your own two rates first.

5. Break-Even Returns: What the RRSP Has to Earn

The question in one number. For each case, we solved for the yearly RRSP return at which the RRSP plus refund route exactly matches prepaying after 10 years. If you expect to earn more than this return, the RRSP route comes out ahead in this model; if less, prepaying does.

RRSP return needed to match prepaying after 10 years (hypothetical, example mortgage rates)
Income and later rateExample rate 3.5%Example rate 4.5%Example rate 5.5%
$70,000, later rate 23.15%1.61%2.64%3.68%
$70,000, later rate same as now3.53%4.55%5.58%
$120,000, later rate 23.15%-2.02%-0.96%0.11%
$120,000, later rate same as now3.53%4.55%5.58%

The pattern. When the later tax rate equals the rate saved now, the RRSP has to earn the mortgage’s effective rate, no more and no less: 3.53%, 4.55% or 5.58%. That is the pure investment test. Each point the tax rate falls in retirement lowers the hurdle.

The high-income case. At $120,000, the deduction saves 40.23% and the money is assumed to be taxed at 23.15% later. That 17-point drop is worth so much that, in this model, the RRSP route would match prepaying even with a slightly negative return at the 3.5% and 4.5% example rates. In practice that cushion depends entirely on the retirement rate turning out lower, so please test a higher later rate before relying on it.

The modest-income case. At $70,000 with a 29.65% saving, the cushion is smaller. If retirement income will be high, from a workplace pension for example, the RRSP needs a return close to the mortgage rate to break even, and prepaying becomes the steadier choice.

A word on expected returns. No one knows future returns, and a diversified portfolio can lose money over ten-year spans. A prepayment’s return is known the day you make it. The break-even table tells you what you need to believe about returns for the RRSP to win; it does not tell you what will happen.

6. Prepayment Privileges, Penalties and Your Mortgage Contract

What a prepayment privilege is. It is the amount you can put toward your mortgage on top of your regular payments without a penalty. It usually takes the form of a set percentage increase to your regular payment, or lump sums up to a limit. Most lenders cap the amount each year, and unused amounts typically do not carry over. An open mortgage allows prepayment without a penalty at any time.

Going over the limit. Paying more than your privileges allow on a closed mortgage, or paying it off early, usually costs the higher of three months’ interest on the remaining balance or the interest rate differential (IRD), plus any administration fee. The IRD usually applies if your mortgage rate is higher than the current rate and you signed less than five years ago. In the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada’s own example, a $200,000 balance at 6% with 36 months left and a 4% current posted rate gives three months’ interest of $3,000 and an IRD of $12,000, so the penalty is $12,000.

Terms longer than five years. Under the Interest Act, for a mortgage not payable until more than five years after its date, after five years the borrower can pay it off with three months’ further interest in lieu of notice, with some exceptions. Our mortgage penalty calculator works through both penalty methods.

What a prepayment does to your mortgage. This example is hypothetical. A $450,000 mortgage with 20% or more down, so no default insurance, amortized over 25 years with monthly payments. The rates are example rates.

$450,000 over 25 years, monthly payments, example rates (hypothetical)
Example rateMonthly paymentInterest over 25 yearsOne $7,000 lump sum after year 1: interest savedPaid off sooner by$7,000 a year for 10 years: interest savedPaid off sooner by
3.5%$2,246.72$224,015$8,9557 months$57,52556 months
4.5%$2,490.63$297,188$13,1018 months$80,25460 months
5.5%$2,746.76$374,029$18,2669 months$106,31364 months

Reading the table. At the 4.5% example rate, ten yearly $7,000 lump sums cut total interest by $80,254 and end the mortgage five years early. The balance after 10 years is $240,261.83 instead of $326,482.17, which is the $86,220.34 used for the prepay strategy in section 4. A higher regular payment works too: adding $200 a month at 4.5% saves $42,531 of interest and ends the mortgage 38 months early.

Enter a price, a down payment, an example rate, the amortization and a payment frequency to see your payment, the interest over your term and the balance at renewal; try a shorter amortization to see what paying more each month would do.

Accelerated payments. Accelerated biweekly or weekly payments add the equivalent of one extra monthly payment each year, a built-in prepayment many lenders offer. Our fixed vs variable mortgage page and the mortgage renewal guide cover how the contract terms differ.

7. Risk, Cash Flow and Access to Your Money

The certainty of a prepayment. A prepayment’s return cannot fall, and it cannot be lost in a market drop. For someone who would worry about an RRSP falling 20% in a bad year, that certainty has real value beyond the arithmetic.

The catch: money in the house is hard to reach. Once you prepay, you cannot simply take the money back. Getting it out means refinancing or a home equity line of credit, which is new borrowing, and federally regulated lenders are expected to stress-test most new mortgage borrowers at the higher of 5.25% or the contract rate plus 2%. If you lose your job, a lower balance does not reduce the payment you owe each month unless the lender agrees. Our mortgage stress test guide explains the qualifying rule.

The catch on the RRSP side. RRSP money is reachable, but at a cost. Outside Quebec, the issuer withholds 10% on withdrawals up to $5,000, 20% over $5,000 up to $15,000 and 30% above that; the full amount is added to your income; and the room is lost for good. Our RRSP withdrawal calculator shows the true cost.

Keep an emergency fund first. Because both options lock money away in different ways, a cash reserve in a savings account or TFSA should usually come first. Our high-interest savings accounts page compares dated rates.

Cash flow at renewal. A prepayment lowers the balance you renew at. If rates are higher at renewal, a smaller balance softens the rise in payment. That benefit is real but depends on rates you cannot know in advance, which is why the comparison above does not count it.

Behaviour matters. The RRSP route only works if the refund is used well. If a refund tends to become a holiday, the arithmetic favours prepaying, because the refund-spent RRSP keeps less than either strategy in section 4.

8. The TFSA Middle Path: Prepay Mortgage vs TFSA

How a TFSA fits. There is no deduction for a TFSA contribution. In exchange, nothing earned inside is taxed, nothing taken out is taxed, and whatever you take out is added to your room again the following January 1. The 2026 TFSA limit is $7,000. Compared with prepaying, a TFSA keeps your money reachable and lets you decide later whether to put a lump sum on the mortgage.

$7,000 a year for 10 years: TFSA at an example 5% vs prepaying (hypothetical, example rates)
Example mortgage ratePrepay: balance lower byTFSA value, tax-freeTFSA ahead by
3.5%$82,236$88,045$5,809
4.5%$86,220$88,045$1,825
5.5%$90,447$88,045-$2,402

The TFSA rule is simple. With no tax on either side, the TFSA wins only when its return beats the mortgage’s effective rate. At the 4.5% example rate, a 3% TFSA return would leave it $5,973 behind prepaying, and a 7% return $10,495 ahead. Unlike the RRSP, the TFSA has no refund cushion.

Why it is still a useful middle path. The TFSA keeps an exit open. If rates rise at renewal, the TFSA can fund a lump-sum prepayment then. If you lose your income, the TFSA can cover payments without tax. If you need the money for something else, it is there.

RRSP or TFSA for the money you do not prepay. If you decide to invest rather than prepay, the choice between the RRSP and the TFSA follows the tax-rate test. Enter your income now and your expected income in retirement below to see which leaves more after tax.

Read more. Our TFSA vs RRSP comparison covers the rules of each, and TFSA withdrawal rules explains when room comes back. To compare where to open either account, our best TFSA accounts ranking follows our published rating methodology, and how WealthScale makes money explains why scores never depend on payment.

9. Special Cases

Home Buyers’ Plan repayments. If you withdrew from your RRSP under the Home Buyers’ Plan, you repay it over 15 years; for first withdrawals from 2026 to 2028, repayment starts in the fifth year after the withdrawal. Any shortfall in a year is added to your income as RRSP income. Missing a repayment adds tax, so repayments usually come before extra mortgage prepayments. See our Home Buyers’ Plan guide.

An employer match. If your employer matches group RRSP contributions, the match is an immediate return that no prepayment can equal. Contributions that earn the full match usually come first; our group RRSP guide explains how plans work.

Close to retirement. Entering retirement mortgage-free lowers the income you need, which can reduce the RRSP or RRIF withdrawals you must take, and so the tax and any OAS recovery on them. For 2026 income, OAS is reduced by 15% of net income above $95,323. A prepayment in your last working years can therefore help in two ways. Our retirement planning hub and OAS clawback guide cover the details.

A low income now. If your marginal rate is low, the refund is small, and the RRSP’s main advantage shrinks. A prepayment or a TFSA often fits better, while you build RRSP room by filing returns to use when your income rises.

A variable-rate mortgage. With a variable rate, the return on a prepayment moves with the rate. When rates rise, prepaying earns more; when they fall, less. Our Bank of Canada rate page explains what drives the changes.

Borrowing to contribute. Taking a loan to make an RRSP contribution adds interest cost and is a different decision. Our RRSP loans page covers it.

10. Using All Three Together

The common split. Contribute to the RRSP, put the refund on the mortgage, and keep an emergency fund in a TFSA or savings account. The RRSP gets the deduction while your rate is high, the mortgage shrinks each year with no new money, and the TFSA keeps cash within reach.

Why the split works. In section 4, the RRSP plus refund route led prepaying in every case where the retirement rate was lower than today’s. It still pays down the mortgage, only more slowly: at $70,000 and the 4.5% example rate, ten refunds leave the balance $25,564 lower after 10 years.

Adjust as rates change. If your mortgage renews at a much higher rate, tilt new savings toward prepaying. If your income rises into a higher bracket, the RRSP refund grows. Revisiting the split once a year, before the RRSP deadline and before any prepayment window, keeps it current.

Mind the limits. RRSP room is 18% of last year’s earned income up to the dollar limit; TFSA room is $7,000 for 2026 plus unused room; mortgage prepayments are capped by your lender. Plan the year so no contribution or prepayment goes over its limit. Our which account to invest in first page sets out a general order across accounts.

11. Order of Priority: RRSP or Mortgage Prepayment First

A general order. These steps are general information built on the arithmetic above. Debts, pensions, benefits and how you feel about risk can change the order.

  1. Clear high-interest debt. Card and consumer debt usually costs far more than any mortgage rate.
  2. Build an emergency fund. Keep several months of essential costs in a savings account or TFSA.
  3. Take any employer RRSP match. A match is an immediate return a prepayment cannot equal.
  4. Keep up any Home Buyers’ Plan repayments. A missed repayment is added to your income.
  5. Compare your two tax rates. If your rate now is clearly above your expected retirement rate, contribute to the RRSP and put the refund on the mortgage.
  6. Compare your mortgage rate with a realistic return. If the effective mortgage rate is above the return you expect, or your tax rate will not fall, lean toward prepaying.
  7. Use the TFSA for flexibility. Money that may be needed before retirement, or saved for a lump-sum prepayment at renewal, fits a TFSA.

Check once a year. A review before the RRSP deadline, which the 60-day rule puts at March 1, 2027 for 2026 contributions, keeps the plan aligned with your income and your mortgage rate.

12. Common Mistakes

Comparing the mortgage rate with the return and ignoring the refund. The refund is worth 29.65 cents per dollar at $70,000 in Ontario in 2026. Leaving it out understates the RRSP.

Spending the refund. The RRSP route depends on the refund being invested or put on the mortgage. Spent, it turns a likely RRSP win into a likely loss.

Using the quoted mortgage rate as the return. Because mortgage interest compounds half-yearly, an example 4.5% rate is an effective 4.5506% a year. The difference is small but real.

Prepaying above your privileges. A prepayment over the cap on a closed mortgage can cost the higher of three months’ interest or the IRD. Check the contract first.

Prepaying with no emergency fund. Money in the house is hard to reach, and the stress test applies if you later need to borrow it back.

Assuming a lower tax rate in retirement. A workplace pension, CPP, OAS and RRIF minimums can keep retirement income high. Test the case where your rate does not fall.

Forgetting the Canada Child Benefit. For parents, an RRSP deduction can raise the benefit, which a prepayment cannot.

10 Strategies for RRSP or Mortgage Prepayment

1. Put every RRSP refund on the mortgage

Contributing to the RRSP and applying the refund to the mortgage captures the deduction and still shrinks the debt. In our example it beat prepaying whenever the retirement tax rate was lower than today’s.

2. Use the full yearly privilege when rates are high

When your mortgage rate is above the return you expect, each prepayment earns that rate with certainty. Using the yearly lump-sum privilege, which usually does not carry over, makes the most of it.

3. Time the RRSP for high-income years

Contribute and deduct in years when your marginal rate is high, such as after a raise or bonus, and lean toward prepaying in lower-income years.

4. Keep a TFSA for the renewal date

Saving in a TFSA through the term keeps money available for a lump-sum payment at renewal or for an emergency, without locking it in the house early.

5. Switch to accelerated payments

Accelerated biweekly or weekly payments add the equivalent of one monthly payment a year with no change in habit.

6. Count the CCB if you have children

For parents with family net income above $82,847 and two children, each $1,000 of RRSP deduction raises the benefit by $57 under the current formula.

7. Test a higher retirement income

Run the comparison with your retirement tax rate equal to today’s. If the RRSP still wins, the case does not rest on a guess about the future.

8. Pay off the mortgage before retirement

A mortgage-free retirement lowers the income you need from RRSP and RRIF withdrawals, which can cut tax and keep income under the OAS threshold.

9. Do not borrow back what you prepaid without a plan

Refinancing or a home equity line means passing the stress test and paying interest again. Keep liquid savings so you do not need to.

10. Revisit the split every year

Rates, income and family change. A yearly check before the RRSP deadline keeps the balance between the RRSP, the TFSA and the mortgage right.

Illustrative Example: Two Households, One Mortgage Rate

This example is hypothetical. Two Ontario households each have a mortgage at an example 4.5% rate and $7,000 a year to save for 10 years. The RRSP earns an example 5% a year, and retirement withdrawals are taxed at 23.15%. These are assumptions to show the arithmetic, not forecasts.

  1. Household A earns $70,000 and prepays $7,000 a year. After 10 years its mortgage balance is $86,220.34 lower than it would have been.
  2. Household B also earns $70,000 but contributes $7,000 a year to an RRSP. Each contribution saves $2,075.50 of tax, which goes on the mortgage. After 10 years the RRSP holds $88,045.25, worth $67,662.77 after tax at 23.15% ($88,045.25 x 76.85%), and the refunds have lowered the mortgage by $25,564.33.
  3. Household B’s total. $67,662.77 + $25,564.33 = $93,227.10, which is $7,006.76 more than Household A ($93,227.10 – $86,220.34).
  4. If B’s retirement rate turned out to be 29.65%, the same as today. The RRSP would be worth $61,939.83 after tax ($88,045.25 x 70.35%), and B’s total would be $87,504.16, still $1,283.82 ahead.
  5. If B had spent the refunds. B would have only the $67,662.77 after-tax RRSP, $18,557.57 behind Household A ($86,220.34 – $67,662.77).

The refund decides the outcome. Household B came out ahead only because the refund went to work. Run your own figures with the refund calculator and the mortgage calculator above.

RRSP vs Mortgage Paydown FAQ

Is it better to put money in an RRSP or pay down the mortgage?

It depends on your tax rates, your mortgage rate and what you do with the refund. In our hypothetical 10-year example in Ontario, contributing to an RRSP and putting the refund on the mortgage beat prepaying at all three example rates when the retirement tax rate was lower than today’s. When the tax rate stayed the same, prepaying won at the 5.5% example rate.

Should I pay off my mortgage or invest in Canada?

Paying off the mortgage earns your mortgage rate with certainty and no tax. Investing can earn more, but it is not guaranteed. In an RRSP the deduction adds a refund, and in a TFSA growth is tax-free. Many people do both: invest in registered accounts, put any refund on the mortgage, and keep an emergency fund. This is general information, not advice for your situation.

What return does an RRSP need to beat paying down a mortgage?

If your tax rate in retirement equals the rate the deduction saved, the RRSP needs to earn the mortgage’s effective rate, such as 4.55% for an example 4.5% quoted rate. If your rate falls in retirement, the hurdle drops. In our example at $70,000 with a later rate of 23.15%, the RRSP needed only 2.64% a year to match prepaying at a 4.5% example rate.

Should I use my RRSP refund to pay down my mortgage?

Putting the refund on the mortgage is one of the most effective ways to combine the two. You keep the tax-deferred RRSP and still shrink the debt. In our example at $70,000 and a 4.5% example rate, ten refunds of $2,075.50 lowered the balance by $25,564 after 10 years. Spending the refund is what makes the RRSP route lose.

Is paying down a mortgage a guaranteed return?

Yes. Each extra dollar of principal saves interest at your mortgage rate for as long as that balance would have remained, and because interest on a home you live in is generally not deductible, the saving is after tax. The return cannot fall in a market drop. The trade-off is that the money is hard to get back without refinancing or borrowing.

What are mortgage prepayment privileges?

They are the amounts you can pay on top of your regular payments without a penalty. Most lenders allow a set percentage increase to your regular payment or lump sums up to a limit, cap the total each year and do not carry unused amounts forward. An open mortgage allows prepayment without a penalty. Your contract sets the exact terms.

What happens if I prepay more than my privileges allow?

On a closed mortgage, paying more than the privilege allows usually triggers a penalty: the higher of three months’ interest on the remaining balance or the interest rate differential, plus any administration fee. In the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada’s example, a $200,000 balance at 6% with 36 months left and a 4% current posted rate gives a $12,000 penalty.

Is a TFSA better than prepaying a mortgage?

Only if its return beats your mortgage’s effective rate, because neither side is taxed. At a 4.5% example rate, $7,000 a year in a TFSA earning an example 5% leads prepaying by $1,825 after 10 years; at 3% it trails by $5,973. The TFSA’s advantage is flexibility: the money stays within reach and can fund a prepayment later.

Does the answer change at a higher income?

Yes. A higher income usually means a bigger refund. In Ontario, a $7,000 deduction saves $2,816.20 at $120,000 against $2,075.50 at $70,000. If retirement income will be much lower, that larger refund makes the RRSP route harder to beat. If retirement income will be high too, the advantage narrows to whether the return beats the mortgage rate.

Can I take money back out of my mortgage if I need it?

Not directly. To reach money you have prepaid, you would usually need to refinance or open a home equity line of credit. That is new borrowing, and federally regulated lenders are expected to stress-test most new mortgage borrowers at the higher of 5.25% or the contract rate plus 2%. That is why an emergency fund should come before large prepayments.

Should I pay down my mortgage before retirement?

Many people aim to. Retiring mortgage-free lowers the income you need, which can reduce RRSP or RRIF withdrawals and the tax on them. For 2026 income, OAS is reduced by 15% of net income above $95,323, so lower withdrawals can also protect OAS. Prepaying in the last working years can be especially useful if your retirement tax rate will not be lower.

How does WealthScale work out these comparisons?

Tax figures use 2026 federal and Ontario brackets, basic personal amounts, the surtax and the Health Premium, checked against Canada Revenue Agency publications. Mortgage figures use half-yearly compounding and Financial Consumer Agency of Canada rules. Mortgage rates and returns are labelled examples. Our editorial standards explain how we compute and date every figure.

Run the RRSP vs mortgage paydown numbers with your own income and rate, then compare where to hold your RRSP.

Figures on this page were checked against Canada Revenue Agency, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada and OSFI publications on October 28, 2026. We update this page when a figure changes.

Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad Gondaliya, CPA
Sharad Gondaliya, CPAWriter and tax reviewerCPA Ontario No. 61040184

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

  • Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
  • Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
  • Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
  • Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Read Sharad’s profile and verify his credentials

Neha Gupta, CFA, Financial Reviewer at WealthScale
Neha Gupta, CFAFinancial ReviewerCFA charterholder

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.

  • CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
  • Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
  • In financial markets since December 2005
  • More than 2,600 published investment articles

Read Neha’s profile and verify her credentials

General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.