Accounts · Order of saving

TFSA, RRSP or FHSA: Which Account to Fill First

Which account to invest in first depends on three facts: whether you will buy a first home, whether your employer matches contributions, and how your tax rate today compares with your rate in retirement. For most Canadians the order is an emergency fund, then any employer match, then the FHSA if you are an eligible first-time buyer, then the RRSP when your rate is high now or the TFSA when it is low. In Ontario, a $5,000 RRSP deduction saves 22.05% at $50,000 of income, 29.65% at $90,000 and 43.41% at $150,000. Parents add $2,500 a year per child to an RESP to collect the $500 grant.

Written by a CPASharad Gondaliya, CPA Ontario No. 61040184
CFA charterholder reviewerNeha Gupta, CFA reviews our investing and account pages; each page shows its review status
Figures checkedOctober 28, 2026
Computed with 2026 bracketsEvery comparison uses the same tax engine as our calculators

At a glance

The usual order. Build an emergency fund, take any employer match in full, fill the FHSA if you are an eligible first-time buyer, then choose between the RRSP and the TFSA by comparing your tax rate now with your expected rate later. Parents add an RESP for the federal grant. This is a general rule, not personal advice.

FHSA first for buyers. The FHSA is the only account with a deduction going in and a tax-free, never-repaid withdrawal for a first home. Room is $8,000 a year and $40,000 for life, and it starts only once you open the account.

TFSA or RRSP first. The RRSP wins when your marginal rate today is higher than the rate your withdrawals will face. The TFSA wins when today’s rate is the same or lower, or when you may need the money before retirement.

The 2026 rates that decide it in Ontario. A $5,000 RRSP deduction is worth $1,102.50 at $50,000 of income, $1,482.50 at $90,000 and $2,170.48 at $150,000, based on 2026 federal and Ontario brackets.

What can flip the answer. RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count as income for the OAS recovery tax, which takes 15% of net income above $95,323 (2026 income), and for the Guaranteed Income Supplement. TFSA withdrawals are not taxable and count for neither.

Grants for parents. Each $2,500 put into a child’s RESP in a year draws a $500 Canada Education Savings Grant (20%), and a child can collect up to $7,200 of that grant over their lifetime.

$8,000FHSA room each year, $40,000 for life
$7,0002026 TFSA dollar limit
$33,8102026 RRSP dollar limit, or 18% of 2025 earned income if less
$500Yearly CESG per child on $2,500 of RESP contributions

Answer a few questions about your goal, timing and income, and the tool below shows which registered accounts fit and in what order to consider them. It gives general information, not a recommendation.

1. Which Account to Invest in First: The Short Answer

One rule, applied in order. Put each dollar where it earns the most after tax, starting with the returns that are certain. A grant or an employer match is certain the moment the money goes in. A tax refund is certain too. A higher return from markets is not. That is why the order starts with free money and tax savings, and only then turns to which account suits your investments.

The general order. For a typical working Canadian, the sequence that follows from that rule is:

  1. An emergency fund in savings, often inside a TFSA, and any high-interest debt paid down.
  2. Enough in a group RRSP or pension plan to collect the full employer match, if there is one.
  3. The FHSA, up to $8,000 a year, if you are an eligible first-time home buyer.
  4. An RESP, $2,500 a year per child, if you have children and want to save for their education.
  5. The RRSP if your marginal rate now is clearly higher than you expect in retirement; otherwise the TFSA.
  6. The other of the RRSP and TFSA, then a non-registered account.

Why the FHSA comes before the RRSP and TFSA. It combines the best feature of each: a deduction on the way in, like the RRSP, and a tax-free withdrawal on the way out, like the TFSA, for a qualifying first-home purchase. Should the home never happen, the balance can go to your RRSP without eating into RRSP room, provided your FHSA has no excess amount.

Why the order is not fixed. A student with low income, a high earner with a workplace pension and a parent of three face different numbers. The decision table in section 2 and the computed Ontario comparisons in section 7 show how the order shifts. Our TFSA vs RRSP comparison goes deeper on those two accounts alone, and our table of registered accounts compared sets out every account’s rules side by side.

2. The Decision Table: Income, Home Plans and Employer Match

Read across your row. Find the line that best describes you. The rates in the table are 2026 combined federal and Ontario marginal rates on ordinary income, computed with our tax engine; other provinces differ, and our page of marginal tax rates by province lists them.

Which account to fill first, by situation (general rules, Ontario rates for 2026)
Your situationFill firstThenWhy
No emergency savings yetSavings in a TFSAThe rest of this tableTax-free access; withdrawals are added back to room the next January 1
Employer matches group RRSP or pension contributionsEnough to get the full matchFHSA, RRSP or TFSA by the rows belowThe match is money you do not get otherwise
Eligible first-time buyer, any incomeFHSA, $8,000 a yearRRSP or TFSA by incomeDeduction in, tax-free out for the home, never repaid
Income near $50,000, no home plansTFSARRSP when income risesAn RRSP deduction saves 22.05% on $5,000, close to the rate on many retirement incomes
Income near $90,000, no home plansRRSP if retirement income will be lower; TFSA if similarThe other oneAn RRSP deduction saves 29.65%
Income near $150,000, no home plansRRSPTFSAAn RRSP deduction saves 43.41% on $5,000, well above most retirement rates
Parent of a child under 18RESP, $2,500 a year per childThe rows aboveA 20% grant, $500 a year per child
Expect a much higher income in a year or twoContribute to the RRSP now and deduct later, or use the TFSA nowRRSP deductions in the higher-income yearUndeducted RRSP contributions can be deducted in a later year
Retirement income likely above $95,323 in 2026 termsTFSA alongside the RRSPRRSP up to a planned levelRRSP and RRIF withdrawals add to the OAS recovery tax
Retirement income likely low enough for the GISTFSARRSP only with careRRSP and RRIF withdrawals reduce GIS; TFSA withdrawals do not count

Home plans change everything. If there is a realistic chance you will buy a first home in the next 15 years, the FHSA row applies before the income rows. You can always move unused FHSA savings to an RRSP later, which is why opening one early carries little downside for an eligible person.

Employer match beats almost everything. If your employer adds money when you contribute, the match is the first registered dollar to collect after your emergency fund, because nothing else on the list adds an immediate amount on top of your own money.

Income alone is a starting point. The income rows assume an average retirement. If you already know you will have a large workplace pension, or almost none, the computed comparisons in section 7 show how that shifts the RRSP and TFSA rows.

3. Before Any Account: Emergency Fund and Costly Debt

Why the emergency fund comes first. Money for a job loss, a car repair or a family emergency has to be available quickly without a tax bill. If it is not there, the first emergency forces you to pull money out of an account that was built for something else, often at the worst time.

How big. There is no official figure. Planners usually count it in months of essential spending, and the right number depends on job security, dependants and other sources of help. This example is hypothetical: with essential costs of $3,200 a month, three months is $9,600 ($3,200 x 3) and six months is $19,200 ($3,200 x 6).

Where to keep it. A TFSA savings account or cashable GIC suits an emergency fund well. You pay no tax on the interest or on taking money out, and every dollar withdrawn becomes new room the following January 1. At a CDIC member, eligible deposits held in your TFSA have their own $100,000 of coverage. Our list of the best high-interest savings accounts shows dated rates.

Why not the RRSP. An RRSP withdrawal is taxed as income. Outside Quebec, the institution keeps back 10% of a withdrawal of $5,000 or less, 20% of one over $5,000 up to $15,000 and 30% of anything larger, and your return settles the final tax. Emergencies also tend to arrive in years when you are still earning, so the withdrawal is taxed at your working rate. Our RRSP withdrawal calculator shows the cost.

Why not the FHSA. A withdrawal that is not for a qualifying home is taxable in full, and FHSA room does not come back after a withdrawal. Money in an FHSA should be money you can leave there until you buy or transfer it to an RRSP.

Costly debt. Paying off a credit card or other high-interest balance is a guaranteed return equal to the interest rate you stop paying. When that rate is higher than any return you can reasonably expect from investing, clearing the debt usually comes before investing more. A mortgage is different, and our comparison of RRSP vs paying down your mortgage covers it.

4. Employer Match First

How a match works. Some employers add money to a group RRSP, a deferred profit sharing plan or a pension when you contribute. The formula is set by the plan, often a percentage of your contribution up to a share of your salary. Wealthsimple’s group savings program, for example, offers a group RRSP, group TFSA, group FHSA and DPSP, and lets employers match contributions.

What a match is worth. This example is hypothetical. A plan matches 50% of what you contribute, up to 4% of salary. On a $90,000 salary, you put in $3,600 ($90,000 x 4%) and your employer adds $1,800 ($3,600 x 50%). That is a 50% addition on day one, before any tax refund or investment return.

A hypothetical 50% match on contributions up to 4% of salary
SalaryYour contribution at 4%Employer match at 50%Total going in each year
$50,000$2,000$1,000$3,000
$90,000$3,600$1,800$5,400
$150,000$6,000$3,000$9,000

Read the plan’s rules. Plans can require a waiting period before you can join, set vesting rules for the employer’s money, or limit withdrawals while you work there. Please read your plan booklet, because those terms decide how much of the match you keep if you leave. Our guide to the group RRSP and employer matching covers the usual terms.

How the match is taxed. An employer’s contribution to your group RRSP is a taxable benefit, reported on your T4, and it counts as an RRSP contribution you can deduct within your room. An employer’s contribution to a registered pension plan is not a taxable benefit. For 2026, the DPSP limit is $17,695 and the money purchase pension limit is $35,390.

It uses RRSP room. Group RRSP contributions count against your RRSP deduction limit, just like contributions to your own RRSP. Pension plan and DPSP credits reduce next year’s RRSP room through the pension adjustment. If you plan to use your own RRSP too, check your room on your latest notice of assessment first.

Match first, even when the TFSA would win. At $50,000 of income, the computed comparison in section 7 shows the TFSA and RRSP are close. A 50% match ends that debate for the matched amount: no tax difference between the accounts comes close to it.

See your own RRSP refund at any income in any province before you decide how much to put where.

5. FHSA or RRSP First for First-Time Buyers

The FHSA first. For an eligible first-time buyer, the FHSA usually comes before both the RRSP and the TFSA. You deduct what you put in, nothing is taxed while it grows, and the qualifying withdrawal for your first home is neither taxed nor repaid. The RRSP’s Home Buyers’ Plan lets you borrow up to $60,000 from your RRSP for a home, but it must be paid back over 15 years.

Who can open one. Four tests apply when you open it. You are resident in Canada. You have reached 18, or 19 where that is the age of majority. You are 71 or younger on December 31 of the opening year. And you are a first-time buyer, meaning that neither earlier this year nor in any of the four previous calendar years did you live in a home that you or your current spouse or common-law partner owned. Our page on FHSA eligibility covers each test.

The same pre-tax dollars in three accounts. This example is hypothetical. A first-time buyer sets aside $8,000 of pre-tax income each year for 5 years, earning an assumed 4% a year, and buys a home with a qualifying withdrawal. In the FHSA, the full $8,000 goes in and the deduction returns the tax. In a TFSA, tax is paid first and only the rest goes in. Each $8,000 grows to $9,733.22 after 5 years ($8,000 x 1.04 to the power of 5).

$8,000 of pre-tax income saved for a first home for 5 years at an assumed 4%, Ontario, 2026 rates
IncomeTax saved by an $8,000 FHSA deductionValue from the FHSA after 5 years, tax-freeAmount left for a TFSA after taxValue from the TFSA after 5 years, tax-freeFHSA advantage
$50,000$1,674.00$9,733.22$6,326.00$7,696.55$2,036.67
$90,000$2,372.00$9,733.22$5,628.00$6,847.32$2,885.90
$150,000$3,472.77$9,733.22$4,527.23$5,508.07$4,225.15

The FHSA column assumes the deduction is claimed against income taxed at the same rates. The TFSA column assumes the tax on the $8,000 is paid first. Figures use 2026 federal and Ontario brackets, the Ontario surtax and the Ontario Health Premium.

Open it early, even with a small deposit. FHSA room starts only in the year you open your first FHSA, at $8,000 a year. Skipped room is kept, but never more than $8,000 of it, so a single year’s contributions top out at $16,000. Opening in 2026 with $0 still starts the clock on room. The calculator below shows your room and the latest year your account can stay open.

The fallback if you never buy. Your FHSA balance can be moved straight into your RRSP or RRIF; the move defers tax and leaves your RRSP room untouched, so long as no excess FHSA amount exists. That is why, for an eligible person, the FHSA is close to an RRSP with an extra option attached. Our pages on the FHSA, the FHSA contribution limit and the FHSA to RRSP transfer cover the rules, and our FHSA vs RRSP comparison sets the two side by side.

Adding the Home Buyers’ Plan. The FHSA and the Home Buyers’ Plan can both fund one home, provided you meet each plan’s conditions at each withdrawal. Spending the FHSA money first and taking only the rest from the RRSP leaves the smallest balance to repay. Our page on using the FHSA and Home Buyers’ Plan together works through the timing.

6. TFSA or RRSP First: The Tax Rate Test

The rule. When the same pre-tax dollars go into each account and earn the same return, the RRSP leaves you with more after tax if your rate when you contribute is higher than your rate when you withdraw. The TFSA leaves you with more if your rate later is higher. If the two rates are equal, they come out the same.

Why that is true. An RRSP gives you a deduction now and taxes everything later. A TFSA taxes the money now and nothing later. Growth multiplies both the same way, so the only difference is the tax rate applied at each end. A 30% rate now and 20% later favours the RRSP; 20% now and 30% later favours the TFSA.

Your rate now. Your rate now is the tax you save on the dollars you deduct, which can cross a bracket line. The table shows the 2026 refund on a $5,000 RRSP contribution for an Ontario resident at three incomes.

2026 tax saved by a $5,000 RRSP deduction, Ontario resident
Income before the deduction2026 tax before the deductionTax saved by $5,000Rate savedMarginal rate at that income
$50,000$7,165.78$1,102.5022.05%19.05%
$90,000$18,462.25$1,482.5029.65%29.65%
$150,000$41,625.64$2,170.4843.41%44.97%

At $50,000 the saving is above the marginal rate because the deduction also lowers the Ontario Health Premium. At $150,000 it is below, because the $5,000 falls in the band under $150,000, where the Ontario rate is lower.

Your rate later. Your rate in retirement depends on your other retirement income: CPP, OAS, a workplace pension and the size of your RRSP or RRIF withdrawals. A larger pension pushes each RRSP dollar into a higher bracket. Our retirement calculator estimates that income from your savings and benefits.

The calculator below runs the comparison with your own rates now and later, so you can test the rule on your numbers before choosing.

Flexibility counts too. The rate test assumes you leave the money until retirement. TFSA money can come out at any time without tax and goes back into your room the next year. RRSP money taken out early is taxed at your working rate, with tax withheld when it is paid out. If there is a real chance you will need the money before retirement, that tips the balance toward the TFSA. Our RRSP vs TFSA calculator models both.

7. Computed Comparisons at $50,000, $90,000 and $150,000 in Ontario

The assumptions. This example is hypothetical, and every figure below rests on these stated assumptions:

  • Each saver puts $5,000 of pre-tax income toward retirement this year.
  • The RRSP route deposits the full $5,000 and the deduction removes the tax. The TFSA route pays the tax first and deposits what is left.
  • Both accounts earn an assumed 5% a year for 25 years, so each dollar grows by a factor of 3.38635 (1.05 to the power of 25).
  • Retirement income before any RRSP withdrawal, from CPP, OAS and any pension, is $25,000 for the $50,000 earner, $40,000 for the $90,000 earner and $70,000 for the $150,000 earner.
  • RRSP money comes out in slices of $10,000 a year on top of that income, and each slice is taxed at the rate computed for it.
  • 2026 federal and Ontario brackets apply in retirement, in 2026 dollars. The OAS recovery tax and GIS are left out here and covered in section 8.
$5,000 of pre-tax income saved for 25 years at an assumed 5%: RRSP vs TFSA, Ontario, 2026 rates
Income nowRate saved nowRetirement income before RRSP withdrawalsRate on each $10,000 withdrawnRRSP after taxTFSA after taxRRSP ahead by
$50,00022.05%$25,00019.05%$13,706.27$13,198.32$507.95
$90,00029.65%$40,00020.55%$13,452.30$11,911.50$1,540.80
$150,00043.41%$70,00031.15%$11,657.53$9,581.76$2,075.77

How each figure is built. For the $90,000 earner: the RRSP grows to $16,931.77 ($5,000 x 3.38635), and tax of 20.55% leaves $13,452.30. The TFSA route pays $1,482.50 of tax first, deposits $3,517.50, and grows to $11,911.50 ($3,517.50 x 3.38635), with no tax to pay. The RRSP is ahead by $1,540.80.

What the results say. Under these assumptions the RRSP comes out ahead at all three incomes, but by very different margins. At $50,000 the lead is $507.95, about 3.8% of the TFSA result, and it depends on a modest retirement income. At $150,000 the lead is $2,075.77, about 21.7% more, because the deduction now is worth far more than the tax later.

When retirement income is higher than assumed. The second table keeps each saver’s TFSA result and changes only the retirement income. A bigger pension, or large RRIF withdrawals, raises the rate on RRSP money.

Which route leaves more, by retirement income before RRSP withdrawals (same assumptions)
Retirement income before RRSP withdrawalsRate on each $10,000 withdrawnRRSP after tax$50,000 earner (TFSA $13,198.32)$90,000 earner (TFSA $11,911.50)$150,000 earner (TFSA $9,581.76)
$25,00019.05%$13,706.27RRSPRRSPRRSP
$40,00020.55%$13,452.30RRSPRRSPRRSP
$55,00027.36%$12,299.23TFSARRSPRRSP
$70,00031.15%$11,657.53TFSATFSARRSP
$90,00030.58%$11,753.52TFSATFSARRSP

The lesson. Among the retirement incomes tested, the TFSA wins for the $50,000 earner from $55,000 of retirement income, and for the $90,000 earner from $70,000. At $150,000, the RRSP stays ahead at every retirement income shown. Please treat these as illustrations of the rule, not forecasts: tax brackets, benefits and your own income will all change.

Run the same test with your income, your province and your expected retirement income.

8. What Changes the Answer

The OAS recovery tax. Once you receive Old Age Security, 15% of your net income above $95,323 (2026 income) is repaid, until the pension is fully recovered at an estimated $155,320 for ages 65 to 74. RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count in that income; TFSA withdrawals are not taxable and do not. This example is hypothetical: a 65-to-74-year-old whose income, OAS included, is $90,000 draws $10,000 more from a RRIF. The repayment is $701.55 (($100,000 minus $95,323) x 15%). After the repayment is deducted, the extra income tax is $3,032.72, which includes the shrinking federal age amount (Ontario’s own age credit is left out), for a total cost of $3,734.27 ($701.55 + $3,032.72), or 37.34% of the withdrawal. Our page on the OAS clawback has the full rules.

The Guaranteed Income Supplement. GIS is paid to low-income OAS recipients and is based on the previous year’s income. For October to December 2026, the maximum for a single person is $1,138.90 a month, and it stops once income reaches $23,112. RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count as income and reduce GIS, while TFSA withdrawals do not. For anyone likely to qualify, an RRSP can lose part of its value to GIS reductions on top of tax. Our GIS guide explains how the amount is set.

The Canada Child Benefit. An RRSP or FHSA deduction lowers your adjusted family net income, which can raise your CCB. For July 2026 to June 2027, a one-child family’s benefit is reduced by 7% of income over $38,237 and by 3.2% of income over $82,847; for two children the rates are 13.5% and 5.7%. This example is hypothetical: a two-child family with income above $82,847 that still receives CCB could see up to $285 more a year from a $5,000 deduction ($5,000 x 5.7%), using those rates. Our CCB calculator shows your figure.

A workplace pension. A pension adjustment reduces next year’s RRSP room, and a good pension raises your retirement income, which raises the rate on RRSP withdrawals. People with a strong defined benefit pension often find the TFSA rows of the decision table fit better than their income alone suggests.

A spouse with a lower income. A spousal RRSP lets the higher earner take the deduction while the lower earner reports the withdrawals, which can lower the couple’s tax later. The catch is timing: a withdrawal is generally taxed back to the contributor if any spousal contribution was made that year or in the two years before. Our spousal RRSP guide covers the rule.

Your province. All figures on this page use Ontario rates. Other provinces have different brackets, so the rates now and later shift. Our Ontario tax brackets page and the other province pages list each one.

US dividends. US-listed shares held directly in an RRSP are exempt from US dividend withholding; in a TFSA, FHSA or RESP, 15% is withheld and cannot be recovered. If you plan to hold US dividend payers, that adds a small point in the RRSP’s favour for those holdings. Our page on what you can hold in a TFSA covers the detail.

9. Where the RESP Fits for Parents

A grant no other account pays. On the first $2,500 a family puts into a child’s RESP each year, the federal government adds 20%, or $500, through the Canada Education Savings Grant, until the child has received $7,200. Families with lower incomes get an additional CESG on the first $500 contributed each year. Contributions are not deductible, but growth is sheltered until it is paid out for school.

Yearly CESG on $2,500 of RESP contributions per child, 2026 thresholds
Adjusted family net income in 2026Basic CESGAdditional CESGTotal CESG a yearGrant as a share of $2,500
Under $58,523$500$100$60024%
From $58,523 up to $117,045$500$50$55022%
Above $117,045$500$0$50020%

Where it sits in the order. For money you plan to spend on a child’s education, the RESP usually comes before the TFSA, because the grant is added on top of tax-free growth. It does not replace your own FHSA or retirement saving: those are for different goals. One way to combine them is to put $2,500 a year per child into the RESP and use the rest of the budget for the order in section 1.

Catching up. Grant room a child does not use is kept for later, and in a catch-up year the CESG can reach $1,000. Contributions after the end of the year the child turns 17 attract no CESG. Our page on the RESP contribution limit works out a best contribution plan from birth and from age 8.

The Canada Learning Bond. Children in low-income families born in 2004 or later can receive up to $2,000 from the Canada Learning Bond with no contribution at all, as long as an RESP is opened for them. Our Canada Learning Bond guide lists the income thresholds.

More on RESPs. For plan types and withdrawals, see our RESP guide; to compare where to open one, see our ranking of the best RESP providers.

10. The Order of Investing Accounts by Life Stage

The same rule, different numbers. The order changes as income, goals and family change. The table sets out a typical sequence at each stage. It is general information and assumes no unusual tax situation.

A typical order of investing accounts in Canada by life stage
Life stageFirstSecondThirdNotes
Student or first job, lower incomeEmergency fund in a TFSAFHSA if eligible and a home is likelyTFSARRSP contributions can wait, or be made now and deducted in a higher-income year
Renter planning to buy within 10 yearsEmergency fund and any employer matchFHSA, $8,000 a yearTFSA for the rest of the down paymentThe RRSP Home Buyers’ Plan can top up, but must be repaid
Parent with young childrenEmployer matchRESP, $2,500 a year per childFHSA if eligible, then RRSP or TFSA by rateAn RRSP deduction can also raise the CCB
Higher earner without a pensionEmployer match if anyRRSPTFSAThe 2026 RRSP dollar limit is $33,810
Higher earner with a strong pensionPension contributionsTFSARRSP with the room left after the pension adjustmentRetirement income may be high, so RRSP withdrawals face a higher rate
Self-employedEmergency fund and tax savings for the balance dueRRSP or TFSA by rateFHSA if eligible2026 returns are due June 15, 2027, but any balance owing is due April 30, 2027
Newcomer to CanadaEmergency fund in a TFSAFHSA if eligibleRRSP once Canadian earned income builds roomTFSA room starts the day you become resident, with the full limit for that year
Within 10 years of retirementTFSA if retirement income will be highRRSP if there will be low-income years before CPP and OAS startNon-registeredWatch the OAS recovery threshold and GIS

Students and new graduates. A low income makes an RRSP deduction worth little now. Contributions can still be made and the deduction carried forward to a year when income is higher, but the TFSA keeps money accessible. If a first home is likely, opening an FHSA early starts room building even if you contribute little.

Self-employed people. There is no employer match, and income can swing from year to year. Keeping money aside for the tax balance comes before investing. In a high-income year, the RRSP deduction is worth more; in a low one, the TFSA.

Newcomers. A newcomer’s TFSA room begins on the day residency starts, and the arrival year still brings that year’s whole limit, not a part of it. RRSP room depends on earned income in Canada in the previous year, so it starts small. Our page on the TFSA for newcomers and non-residents covers the rules.

11. 2026 Room and Deadlines for Each Account

Plan the year in order. Each account has its own limit and deadline, and two of them close on December 31. The table sets out what you can put in for 2026 and by when.

2026 contribution room and deadlines
Account2026 roomDeadline for 2026Unused roomTax treatment
TFSA$7,000 new room on January 1, 2026, plus unused room and last year’s withdrawalsNo deadlineCarries forward indefinitelyNo deduction; tax-free growth and withdrawals
RRSP18% of 2025 earned income, up to $33,810, less any pension adjustment, plus unused roomMarch 1, 2027 under the 60-day ruleCarries forwardDeductible; withdrawals taxed as income
FHSA$8,000, plus up to $8,000 carried forward; $40,000 for lifeDecember 31, 2026; no 60-day periodCarries forward, capped at $8,000Deductible; qualifying home withdrawal tax-free
RESP$50,000 lifetime per child; CESG on the first $2,500 each yearDecember 31, 2026 for the 2026 grantGrant room carries forward; up to $1,000 of CESG a yearNot deductible; grants and growth taxable when paid out

The RRSP deadline. RRSP contributions count for 2026 if they are made by the 60th day of 2027. Under that rule, contributions made from January 1 to Monday, March 1, 2027 can be deducted on your 2026 return; the CRA usually posts the date each January. Most people file their 2026 return by April 30, 2027, the usual date. If you or your spouse or partner is self-employed, the filing deadline is June 15, 2027, but any balance owing is still due April 30, 2027. Our page on the RRSP deadline covers the dates and our page on unused RRSP room covers carry-forward.

The FHSA deadline. FHSA contributions count only for the calendar year in which they are made. A contribution in January 2027 cannot be deducted on your 2026 return, though it can be deducted in 2027 or a later year.

Over-contributions. Each account taxes an excess. The TFSA and FHSA charge 1% a month on the excess, the RRSP charges 1% a month on amounts above your limit plus a $2,000 cushion, and an RESP charges each subscriber 1% a month on their share of an excess. Please add up contributions across every institution before each deposit. Our page on the TFSA contribution room shows how to work out yours.

12. Common Mistakes When Choosing an Order

Skipping the employer match. Leaving a match unclaimed to fill a TFSA gives up money that no tax difference can replace.

Waiting to open an FHSA. Room starts only when the account is opened, and carry-forward is capped at $8,000, so the years before opening cannot be caught up. Reaching the $40,000 lifetime limit takes at least five years from the year you open, so a late start means a later home or less FHSA money for it.

Using an RRSP as an emergency fund. Early withdrawals are taxed at your working rate, with 10%, 20% or 30% withheld outside Quebec. A TFSA holds the same money with no tax to get it out.

Choosing by habit, not by rate. At $50,000 of Ontario income the RRSP’s lead in section 7 is $507.95 on $5,000, and it disappears if retirement income reaches $55,000. At $150,000, the lead is $2,075.77. The same account is not the right first choice for both.

Spending the RRSP refund. The comparison in section 7 assumes the RRSP saver ends up with the full deduction working for them. If the refund is spent, the RRSP saver has saved less than the TFSA saver from the same pre-tax income. Putting the refund into the TFSA or next year’s RRSP keeps the comparison fair.

Forgetting the RESP grant years. CESG stops after the year the child turns 17, and catching up is limited to $1,000 of grant a year. Starting late can cap what a child receives.

Ignoring retirement benefits. RRSP and RRIF withdrawals can trigger the OAS recovery tax or cut GIS. Someone likely to face either may be better served by putting more in the TFSA.

What You Need to Set Your Order and What You Get

What you need

  • Your latest notice of assessment, which shows your RRSP deduction limit
  • Your TFSA room, checked against your own records at every institution
  • Your employer’s plan booklet, if there is a group RRSP, DPSP or pension
  • Your answer to whether you will buy a first home, and roughly when
  • Your 2026 income and a realistic guess at your retirement income
  • The ages of any children you are saving for
  • Your monthly essential costs, to size an emergency fund
  • A list of any high-interest debt and its rate

What you get

  • Every employer dollar the plan offers
  • A deduction and a tax-free withdrawal for a first home through the FHSA
  • A 20% grant on up to $2,500 a year per child through the RESP
  • Tax saved now on RRSP contributions when your rate is high
  • Tax-free growth and access through the TFSA when your rate is low
  • Less exposure to the OAS recovery tax and GIS reductions later
  • An emergency fund that does not force a taxable withdrawal
  • A clear order to follow each year as room renews

How to Set Your Order, Step by Step

  1. Size and fund your emergency savings. Count your essential monthly costs, choose a number of months, and hold that amount in a TFSA savings account or cashable GIC.
  2. Clear costly debt. Pay off balances whose interest rate is higher than any return you can reasonably expect.
  3. Claim the full employer match. Contribute at least enough to your workplace plan to receive every matched dollar.
  4. Open an FHSA if you are eligible. Open it before December 31 to get that year’s $8,000 of room, and contribute what you can.
  5. Fund the RESP for each child. $2,500 a year per child collects the full basic CESG of $500.
  6. Compare your rates now and later. Use the TFSA vs RRSP tool to pick the RRSP or the TFSA for your next dollars.
  7. Repeat each January. New TFSA, FHSA and RESP grant room arrives each year, and RRSP room is set by last year’s earned income.

10 Strategies for Filling Your Accounts in the Right Order

1. Take certain returns first

An employer match and a government grant are known the day you contribute. Market returns are not. Collecting the certain amounts before choosing between the TFSA and RRSP adds the most with the least risk.

2. Open the FHSA this year

FHSA room starts only when the account opens. Opening by December 31 gives you 2026’s $8,000 of room, even if you deposit little now, and it can move to your RRSP later if you never buy.

3. Contribute now, deduct later

RRSP and FHSA contributions can be deducted in a later year. In a low-income year, contribute and carry the deduction to a year when your marginal rate is higher.

4. Reinvest the refund

Putting your RRSP or FHSA refund into your TFSA or next year’s contribution keeps all the tax saved working for you. A refund spent on everyday costs shrinks the RRSP’s lead.

5. Keep the emergency fund in a TFSA

Tax-free interest, tax-free access and room that returns the next January 1 make the TFSA a better emergency account than an RRSP or FHSA, where early withdrawals are taxed.

6. Use the RRSP in peak years

Bonuses, overtime and peak career years push your marginal rate up. Those are the years when each RRSP dollar saves the most, as the 43.41% saving at $150,000 shows.

7. Plan around OAS

If your retirement income will be close to the $95,323 recovery threshold, a larger TFSA balance gives you tax-free income that does not count, which keeps more of your OAS.

8. Draw the FHSA before the HBP

For a first home, FHSA money never has to be repaid, while Home Buyers’ Plan money must go back over 15 years. Using the FHSA first keeps repayments as small as possible.

9. Put $2,500 a year in each child’s RESP

That amount collects the full $500 basic CESG each year. Keep it up for 14 years, add $1,000 in year 15, and the child reaches the $7,200 lifetime grant on $36,000 of contributions.

10. Revisit the order when life changes

A new job with a pension, a home purchase, a child or a move to another province changes your rates and goals. Please rerun the decision table after each one.

Illustrative Example: Jordan Sets an Order

This example is hypothetical. Jordan is 29, rents in Ontario and earns $72,000. Jordan has never owned a home, hopes to buy in 2030, has $3,200 of essential costs a month, and has a group RRSP at work that matches 50% of contributions up to 3% of salary. The 4% yearly return is an assumption for illustration, not a forecast.

  1. Emergency fund. Three months of essential costs is $9,600 ($3,200 x 3), held in a TFSA savings account.
  2. Employer match. Jordan contributes 3% of salary, $2,160 ($72,000 x 3%), and the employer adds $1,080 ($2,160 x 50%).
  3. FHSA. Jordan opens an FHSA before December 31, 2026 and contributes $8,000 in each of 2026, 2027, 2028, 2029 and 2030, which is $40,000 ($8,000 x 5), the lifetime limit.
  4. Growth. Assuming each deposit goes in on January 1 and earns 4% credited on December 31, the account reaches $45,063.80 at the end of 2030.
  5. Tax saved in 2026. Deducting the $2,160 group RRSP contribution and the $8,000 FHSA contribution, $10,160 in total, saves an estimated $3,012.44 of 2026 tax at Jordan’s income.
  6. The refund’s job. Jordan puts the refund into the TFSA, on top of the emergency fund, as extra down payment money that can come out tax-free at any time.
  7. Buying. In 2030, a qualifying FHSA withdrawal of $45,063.80 goes to the down payment tax-free and is never repaid. If more is needed, Jordan can add a Home Buyers’ Plan withdrawal from the RRSP.
  8. After the home. With the FHSA closed, Jordan’s next dollars go to the RRSP or TFSA, using the rate test in section 6.

Questions About Which Account to Fill First

Which account should I invest in first in Canada?

For most people the order is an emergency fund, then any employer match, then the FHSA if you are an eligible first-time buyer, then an RESP for children, then the RRSP or TFSA depending on your tax rate now and in retirement. The RRSP wins when today’s rate is higher than the rate your withdrawals will face. This is general information, not personal advice.

Should I fill my TFSA or RRSP first?

Compare your tax rate now with your expected rate in retirement. If today’s rate is clearly higher, the RRSP usually leaves more after tax; if it is the same or lower, the TFSA does. In Ontario, a $5,000 RRSP deduction saves 22.05% at $50,000 of income, 29.65% at $90,000 and 43.41% at $150,000, based on 2026 rates.

Is the FHSA better than the RRSP for a first home?

For an eligible first-time buyer, usually yes. Each plan gives a deduction going in. The difference is on the way out: FHSA money used in a qualifying withdrawal is never taxed and never paid back, while RRSP money taken under the Home Buyers’ Plan has to go back in over 15 years. You can use both for the same home if you meet each set of conditions, so many buyers fill the FHSA first and top up from the RRSP.

Should I open an FHSA if I am not sure I will buy a home?

If you are eligible, opening one early costs little. Room of $8,000 a year starts only when the account is opened, and carry-forward is capped at $8,000. Without a purchase, the money is not stranded: a direct transfer to your RRSP or RRIF uses no RRSP room, provided there is no excess FHSA amount.

Does an employer match change which account comes first?

Yes. A match is money you get only by contributing, so it usually comes right after an emergency fund. In a hypothetical plan that matches 50% of contributions up to 4% of a $90,000 salary, contributing $3,600 brings in $1,800 more. Check your plan booklet for waiting periods and vesting rules before counting on the employer’s share.

At what income is the RRSP better than the TFSA?

There is no single income, because the answer depends on your retirement income too. In our Ontario comparison, using 2026 rates and a 5% assumed return, the RRSP led at $50,000 of income when retirement income was $40,000 or less, and the TFSA led from $55,000. At $90,000 the TFSA led from $70,000 of retirement income. At $150,000 the RRSP led at every retirement income tested.

Should my emergency fund be in a TFSA?

A TFSA savings account or cashable GIC suits an emergency fund. The interest is tax-free, money can come out whenever you need it with no tax, and the withdrawal turns back into room at the start of the next year. An RRSP withdrawal is taxed as income with 10%, 20% or 30% withheld outside Quebec, and a non-qualifying FHSA withdrawal is taxable in full.

Where does an RESP fit in the order?

For money meant for a child’s education, the RESP usually comes before the TFSA because of the grant. The federal grant is 20% of the first $2,500 a year, which is $500, up to $7,200 per child. Lower and middle-income families, with 2026 adjusted family net income below $117,045, receive a top-up on the first $500 of each year’s contributions as well.

Can I contribute to an RRSP now and claim the deduction later?

Yes. RRSP contributions you make but do not deduct can be deducted in a later year. That lets a person with a low income this year contribute now, so the money starts growing sheltered, and claim the deduction in a year when their marginal rate is higher. FHSA contributions can also be deducted in a later year, even after the account closes.

How do OAS and GIS affect the TFSA vs RRSP choice?

RRSP and RRIF withdrawals count as income for the OAS recovery tax, which takes 15% of net income above $95,323 (2026 income), and they reduce the Guaranteed Income Supplement. TFSA withdrawals are not taxable, so they count for neither. People likely to face the recovery tax or to qualify for GIS often lean toward the TFSA.

What is the RRSP deadline for the 2026 tax year?

Under the 60-day rule, RRSP contributions made by Monday, March 1, 2027, the 60th day after December 31, 2026, can be deducted on your 2026 return; the CRA usually posts the date in January. The FHSA has no such period: 2026 FHSA contributions must be made by December 31, 2026. Self-employed people and their spouses or partners can file by June 15, 2027, but any balance owing is due April 30, 2027.

What comes after the TFSA, RRSP and FHSA are full?

A non-registered account. It has no contribution limit, but its interest and dividends are taxed in the year they are paid, and gains are taxed when you sell. Canadian dividends get the dividend tax credit, and only part of a capital gain is taxed, so holdings that pay those types of income suit a taxable account better than interest-paying ones. How we check rules like these is set out in our editorial standards.

Set your order, check your room in each account, then compare where to open the ones you need.

Figures on this page were checked against Canada Revenue Agency, Employment and Social Development Canada and Service Canada publications and provincial tax legislation on October 28, 2026. We update this page when a figure changes.

Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad Gondaliya, CPA
Sharad Gondaliya, CPAWriter and tax reviewerCPA Ontario No. 61040184

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

  • Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
  • Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
  • Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
  • Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Read Sharad’s profile and verify his credentials

Neha Gupta, CFA, Financial Reviewer at WealthScale
Neha Gupta, CFAFinancial ReviewerCFA charterholder

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.

  • CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
  • Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
  • In financial markets since December 2005
  • More than 2,600 published investment articles

Read Neha’s profile and verify her credentials

General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.