Wealthsimple Direct Indexing Review
WealthScale is independent and not affiliated with Wealthsimple.
Wealthsimple direct indexing, live since November 5, 2026, lets you own the individual stocks in an index instead of an ETF, inside a personal non-registered Trade account, with automatic tax-loss harvesting. Wealthsimple’s product page lists four indexes: U.S. Market and Canadian Market at 0.10% a year, and U.S. Innovation and Global Markets at 0.15%, each from $1,000. An older Wealthsimple help article still quotes a single 0.15% fee, and its Automated Investing help article gives a $3,000 minimum for Global Markets, so we show both versions. TFSAs, RRSPs, FHSAs, joint and corporate accounts are not supported yet. Direct indexing has no WealthScale score of its own, so we give it no rating.
At a glance
What it is. Wealthsimple direct indexing puts the individual stocks of an index into your non-registered self-directed account instead of one ETF. In Wealthsimple’s words, “You’ll hold the individual stocks in the index instead of an ETF.” It went live on November 5, 2026, and you can add it to an existing account without opening a new one or moving money.
Indexes and fees. The product page lists four direct indexes: U.S. Market and Canadian Market at 0.10% a year, and U.S. Innovation and Global Markets at 0.15% a year, with automated tax-loss harvesting included. A Wealthsimple help article still says “We charge a service fee of 0.15%” and describes only two indexes. No benchmark index is named on the product page.
Minimums. $1,000 for each direct index on the product page. Wealthsimple’s Automated Investing help article says $1,000 per direct index and $3,000 for the Global Markets index.
Accounts and tiers. Personal non-registered Trade accounts only. Wealthsimple says “TFSAs, RRSPs, FHSAs, joint and corporate accounts aren’t supported yet.” It publishes no tier rule, so Core, Premium and Generation clients appear to pay the same fee.
Tax-loss harvesting. When a stock falls, Wealthsimple sells it to realize the loss and buys a similar stock. Its help article says harvesting and rebalancing run on deposits or withdrawals, when the account loses 5% or more of its value, and otherwise monthly. Wealthsimple has not described how it applies the superficial loss rule.
Wealthsimple’s estimate. Wealthsimple says direct indexing “can boost after-tax returns by up to 0.5% a year” in a non-registered account and adds that results “aren’t guaranteed.” This is Wealthsimple’s own estimate. WealthScale has not verified it.
1. Wealthsimple Direct Indexing Review: Our Verdict, and Why There Is No Score
The short version. A direct index replaces one fund with the stocks that fund would hold. Because each stock is a separate holding with its own cost, a stock that falls can be sold at a loss even while the index as a whole is up. Wealthsimple automates that selling, buys a similar stock in its place, and charges 0.10% or 0.15% a year for the service on its product page. The result is a capital loss you can claim, while your market exposure stays roughly where it was.
Who gets the most from it. The losses are worth most to an investor who already realizes capital gains in a non-registered account, from selling other shares, a fund or a rental property, and who would otherwise pay tax on those gains this year. An investor with no gains still banks the losses, because net capital losses can be carried back three years or forward with no time limit, but the tax saving waits until a gain shows up.
Why we give no rating. WealthScale scores online brokers and robo-advisors under a published method, and we have not built a score for direct indexing products. So this review shows no star rating and no score for direct indexing, and we say so rather than borrow a number. The platform it runs on, Wealthsimple’s self-directed Trade platform, is scored as a broker: Wealthsimple is 4.2 / 5, rank 5 of 13 online brokers in our ranking as of November 9, 2026. Our broker rating methodology explains that score, and our how we make money page explains why no provider can pay for a ranking.
| Your situation | Fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Non-registered account, realizes capital gains most years | Strongest fit | Harvested losses can offset this year’s gains right away |
| Non-registered account, no gains to offset yet | Possible fit | Losses carry forward; the saving comes later |
| Money held in a TFSA, RRSP or FHSA | Not available | Wealthsimple does not support these accounts for direct indexing yet |
| Joint or corporate non-registered account | Not available | Not supported yet, per Wealthsimple |
| Less than $1,000 to put in one index | Not available | Below the published minimum |
| Wants to leave certain companies out | Not yet | Wealthsimple lists exclusions as “Coming soon” |
What would change our view. Four things would make this product easier to judge: a named benchmark for each index, so tracking can be measured; one consistent fee and minimum across Wealthsimple’s pages; a published description of how harvesting respects the superficial loss rule; and registered-account support. Until then, the honest description is a low-fee, automated tool for a narrow group of taxable investors. Our editorial standards explain how we handle figures that a provider’s own pages disagree on.
2. Direct Indexing in Canada: How It Differs From Holding an Index ETF
One fund or hundreds of shares. When you buy an index ETF, you own units of one fund, and the fund owns the stocks. With a direct index, you own the stocks yourself, in the same rough weights the index uses. Our guide to index investing in Canada covers why tracking an index is a low-cost way to invest, and what an ETF is explains how fund units work.
Each stock has its own cost. With an ETF, you have one adjusted cost base for the units. With a direct index, every stock has its own adjusted cost base. The CRA’s average-cost method groups identical properties, which it describes as property where “each property in the group is the same as all the others,” so shares of a company you already hold in another non-registered account are averaged together with the shares the index buys. Our adjusted cost base guide and ACB calculator show how that works.
Where the fee comes from. An ETF’s management expense ratio is taken inside the fund, so you never see a bill. Wealthsimple’s direct indexing fee is calculated daily and paid monthly from your account, and the stocks themselves carry no MER. The exception is the Global Markets index, which also holds international and emerging markets ETFs that charge their own MERs. Our MER explainer shows how fund fees are measured.
Why losses become possible. An index can rise in a year when a fifth of its companies fall. An ETF holder cannot use those individual declines, because the units have one price. A direct index holder can sell the falling stocks, claim the losses, and keep the rest. That is the whole case for the product.
| Feature | Index ETF | Wealthsimple direct index |
|---|---|---|
| What you own | Units of one fund | The individual stocks in the index |
| Yearly cost | The ETF’s MER; $0 Wealthsimple commission on listed securities | 0.10% or 0.15% a year on the product page; Global Markets adds the MERs of its ETFs |
| Adjusted cost base | One ACB for the units | One ACB for each stock |
| Tax-loss harvesting | Only if the whole ETF is below your cost | Automatic, stock by stock |
| Accounts at Wealthsimple | Any Trade account, including TFSA, RRSP and FHSA | Personal non-registered Trade accounts only |
| Minimum | The price of one unit, or a fraction where offered | $1,000 per index ($3,000 for Global Markets in one help article) |
| Main tax slips | T3 for ETF trust income, plus T5008 on sales | T5 for dividends of $50 or more, plus T5008 on every sale |
| Foreign property reporting | For Form T1135 the CRA counts a fund, not its holdings; a Canadian fund is not on its list | US shares held directly are specified foreign property for Form T1135 |
| Leaving companies out | Not possible | “Coming soon,” per Wealthsimple |
3. The Four Wealthsimple Direct Indexes
What the product page lists. On November 9, 2026, Wealthsimple’s direct indexing page named four indexes: U.S. Market, Canadian Market, U.S. Innovation and Global Markets. It named no benchmark index for any of them, so we cannot tell you which published index each one follows. We describe them only as Wealthsimple does, and none of this is a recommendation of any index.
What the older help article says. A Wealthsimple help article on opening a direct indexing portfolio still describes two indexes, a Canadian index and a US index, each tied to a named benchmark, and a single 0.15% fee. The article appears to be older than the product page. Because the two pages disagree, we treat the number of indexes, the fee and the benchmark as unsettled, show both versions, and name no benchmark until Wealthsimple confirms one.
| Index | Fee (product page) | Minimum (product page) | Minimum (Automated Investing help) | Benchmark named |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| U.S. Market | 0.10% a year | $1,000 | $1,000 | None named |
| Canadian Market | 0.10% a year | $1,000 | $1,000 | None named |
| U.S. Innovation | 0.15% a year | $1,000 | $1,000 | None named |
| Global Markets | 0.15% a year, plus the MERs of the international and emerging markets ETFs it holds | $1,000 | $3,000 | None named |
Every stock, for now. Wealthsimple says “For now, you’ll hold every stock in the index.” The option to choose companies to leave out is labelled “Coming soon,” with no date. The account rebalances automatically, so you do not pick weights yourself.
What is live and what is not. Direct indexing was one of the 12 releases Wealthsimple announced at its November 5, 2026 event, and one of four that its release labels “available now.” The table separates the parts that were live on November 9, 2026 from the parts Wealthsimple has only described.
| Feature | Status | Wealthsimple’s wording |
|---|---|---|
| Direct index in an existing non-registered self-directed account | Live since November 5, 2026 | “available now” |
| Converting an existing ETF | Live | “convert an existing ETF in a few taps” |
| Automated tax-loss harvesting | Live | Included in the fee |
| Leaving out companies you choose | Not live | “Coming soon” |
| TFSA, RRSP, FHSA, joint and corporate accounts | Not supported | “aren’t supported yet” |
Other November 5 announcements. Several other products shown that day, including the Wealthsimple Pro trading platform, perpetual futures and the Penny AI assistant, were not live on November 9, 2026. None of them changes how direct indexing works today. Our Wealthsimple Trade review covers the self-directed platform that direct indexing sits on.
4. Wealthsimple Direct Index Fee, Minimums, Tiers and Accounts
The fee. On the product page, U.S. Market and Canadian Market cost 0.10% a year and U.S. Innovation and Global Markets cost 0.15% a year, with automated tax-loss harvesting included. The fee is calculated daily and paid monthly. The older help article’s single figure is 0.15%. If you plan around the higher figure, the product page can only make your cost lower.
What it costs in dollars. The table shows the first-year fee at four balances, before any growth. For comparison, it includes Wealthsimple’s separate Automated Investing service, which charges 0.25% a year, capped at $250 per account per year once the balance reaches $100,000. Automated Investing’s help article says it can also hold direct indexes, and that tax-loss harvesting is available only within direct indexing in non-registered accounts.
| Balance | Direct index at 0.10% | Direct index at 0.15% | Automated Investing at 0.25%, $250 cap |
|---|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | $10 | $15 | $25 |
| $50,000 | $50 | $75 | $125 |
| $100,000 | $100 | $150 | $250 |
| $250,000 | $250 | $375 | $250 |
Trading costs. Wealthsimple’s fee schedule lists $0 commission on listed US and Canadian securities, $0 for outgoing transfers and $0 to close an account. So the many small trades that harvesting and rebalancing create do not carry a commission. Our Wealthsimple fees guide lists every other charge by product.
Minimums. $1,000 for each index on the product page; $3,000 for Global Markets in the Automated Investing help article. Please confirm the Global Markets minimum with Wealthsimple before you fund that index.
Tiers. Wealthsimple publishes no tier rule for direct indexing. Premium starts at $100,000 in assets and Generation at $500,000, and those tiers lower the managed investing fee, but nothing on the direct indexing page says the 0.10% or 0.15% changes by tier. Our Core vs Premium vs Generation comparison shows what each tier does change.
Accounts. Personal non-registered Trade accounts only. That rules out TFSAs, RRSPs, FHSAs, joint accounts and corporate accounts for now. Our guide to non-registered investment accounts explains how income and gains are taxed in this account type.
5. Wealthsimple Direct Index Fee vs an Index ETF Over 10 and 25 Years
Comparing like with like. An index ETF held in a Wealthsimple Trade account costs its MER and no commission. A direct index costs Wealthsimple’s fee and no MER, except inside Global Markets. So the fair test is the direct indexing fee against the MER of the ETF you would otherwise hold. We do not name any ETF. Instead, the table uses example fee levels of 0.05% and 0.25% on either side of Wealthsimple’s two published fees.
The fee impact calculator below shows how two yearly fees change the value of the same investment over any number of years, with optional monthly contributions.
The numbers. This example is hypothetical. It assumes $100,000 invested once, no further contributions, and an example return of 6% a year before fees, grown monthly at the return minus the fee, the same method the calculator uses. These are assumptions, not forecasts.
| Yearly fee | What it represents | After 10 years | After 25 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.05% | Example low-cost index ETF MER | $181,037 | $440,978 |
| 0.10% | Direct index: U.S. Market or Canadian Market (product page) | $180,138 | $435,527 |
| 0.15% | Direct index: U.S. Innovation or Global Markets; help article figure | $179,244 | $430,143 |
| 0.25% | Example higher-cost index ETF MER | $177,469 | $419,573 |
Reading the gaps. Against an example 0.05% ETF, a 0.10% direct index costs $898 over 10 years and $5,451 over 25 years; a 0.15% direct index costs $1,793 and $10,835. Against an example 0.25% ETF, a 0.10% direct index comes out ahead by $2,669 over 10 years and $15,954 over 25 years. Differences are worked from unrounded balances, as the calculator does, so one may differ by $1 from subtracting the rounded figures.
What the fee buys. The extra fee is certain; the tax benefit is not. A direct index only beats a cheaper ETF after tax if harvested losses save more tax, in present-value terms, than the fee gap costs. That depends on how volatile the stocks are, whether you have gains to offset, your marginal rate now and later, and how long you hold. Our investment fee calculator runs the same comparison across brokers and funds.
6. Wealthsimple Tax-Loss Harvesting: How the Automation Works
What Wealthsimple does. The product page describes it in one line: “When one drops, we sell it to realize the loss and buy a similar stock, so your market exposure stays about the same.” The help article adds the timing: harvesting and rebalancing run when you deposit or withdraw, when the account loses 5% or more of its value, and otherwise monthly. You do not choose which lots to sell.
What a harvested loss is worth. A sale below your adjusted cost base creates a capital loss. Half of it, the 2026 inclusion rate of one half, is an allowable capital loss that first offsets taxable capital gains in the same year. Any unused net capital loss can be carried back three years or forward with no time limit, but only against taxable capital gains, never against salary or interest. Our capital losses guide covers the carry-back request.
Why it is mostly a deferral. The replacement stock is bought at today’s lower price, so its cost base is lower than the stock it replaced. If it later recovers and you sell, the gain is larger by about the loss you claimed. Harvesting moves tax to a later year rather than erasing it. The deferral is still worth something: money kept invested longer, a possibly lower tax rate in retirement, and gains that may never be realized during your life if you donate shares. A gift of listed shares to a qualified donee carries an inclusion rate of zero on the gain, as our guide to donating shares explains.
Wealthsimple’s “up to 0.5%” figure. Wealthsimple’s release says that “In a non-registered account, direct indexing can boost after-tax returns by up to 0.5% a year” and that “On a $200,000 portfolio, that’s nearly $20,000 more after 10 years.” Its product page adds: “Results depend on your personal tax situation and market conditions and aren’t guaranteed.” We present this only as Wealthsimple’s own estimate. It is a best case, “up to,” not an average, and WealthScale has not verified it.
When harvesting does little. In a steadily rising market there are fewer losses to harvest. Once most stocks in the account sit well above their cost, harvesting slows down, a pattern that is common to direct indexing in general rather than specific to Wealthsimple. Our tax-loss harvesting guide covers doing it by hand in any account.
7. Wealthsimple Direct Indexing and the Superficial Loss Rule
The rule. The CRA denies a capital loss when you, or a person affiliated with you, buy identical property in the 30 calendar days before or the 30 calendar days after the sale, and that property is still owned on the 30th day after the sale. Affiliated persons include your spouse or common-law partner. The denied loss can usually be added to the adjusted cost base of the substituted property, so it is postponed rather than lost. Our superficial loss rule guide covers every case.
What Wealthsimple says. Wealthsimple’s learn article, updated September 15, 2026, warns that the CRA may deny a loss if the same or identical property is bought within 30 calendar days before or after the sale. Its harvesting buys “a similar stock,” not the same one. What it has not published is how its system checks the 61-day window, for example whether it avoids rebuying a harvested stock for 30 days. We list that as not published.
What the automation cannot see. The rule looks at purchases by you and by affiliated persons, not just in one account. Wealthsimple’s harvesting runs inside the direct index, so a purchase of the same stock elsewhere is outside its view:
- the same company bought in another of your non-registered accounts, at Wealthsimple or another broker;
- the same company bought in your TFSA or RRSP, where there is no cost base that counts for tax to add a denied loss to;
- your spouse’s or common-law partner’s purchases of the same company;
- dividend reinvestment or pre-authorized purchases of that company anywhere.
A dated example. This example is hypothetical. If a stock is harvested on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, the window runs from Sunday, October 18, 2026 to Thursday, December 17, 2026, 61 days in all. A purchase of the identical shares in any of those accounts in that window, still held on December 17, would make the loss superficial.
The superficial loss checker below tests a sale date and your purchases against the 61-day window and shows how much of the loss is denied.
8. A Harvested Loss in Ontario and British Columbia
The setup. This example is hypothetical. A person has $110,000 of taxable salary in 2026 and sells shares held elsewhere for a $12,000 capital gain. During the year, their Wealthsimple direct index harvests $5,000 of capital losses. We compare the two provinces with our shared 2026 tax engine, the same one the capital gains calculator uses, and show tax to the cent.
The arithmetic. Without harvesting, the taxable capital gain is ($12,000 x 50% = $6,000). With harvesting, the net gain is ($12,000 − $5,000 = $7,000) and the taxable gain is ($7,000 x 50% = $3,500), so taxable income falls by ($6,000 − $3,500 = $2,500).
| Item | Ontario | British Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Total tax with the $12,000 gain, no harvesting | $26,923.85 | $25,240.92 |
| Total tax with $5,000 of harvested losses | $25,976.11 | $24,459.62 |
| Tax saved this year | $947.74 | $781.30 |
| Tax on the gain alone, no harvesting | $2,201.87 | $1,866.30 |
| Tax on the gain alone, with harvesting | $1,254.13 | $1,085.00 |
What it means. In this case each dollar of harvested loss saved about 19 cents of tax in Ontario and about 16 cents in British Columbia this year, because the two provinces tax the top slice of this income at different rates. Our Ontario tax brackets and British Columbia tax brackets pages show where those rates change, and marginal tax rates by province lists the rate on capital gains at every income.
The deferral, in numbers. The replacement stocks now carry a cost base about $5,000 lower. If they recover and are sold years later, when this Ontario resident has $60,000 of other income in retirement, the extra $2,500 of taxable gain costs $741.25 at 2026 rates. The saving now was $947.74, so the permanent gain from harvesting in this case is ($947.74 − $741.25 = $206.49), plus whatever the deferred tax earned while it stayed invested. If the later gain is taxed at the same rate as today, the permanent gain shrinks toward zero.
With no gains to offset. If the person had no other gains in 2026, the $5,000 loss would become a net capital loss with an allowable part of $2,500, carried forward to use against a future taxable capital gain. Nothing is saved in 2026.
The capital gains tax calculator below works out the tax on any gain in your province, with net capital losses carried forward.
Our capital gains tax calculator page and capital gains tax guide explain the inputs in more detail.
Want to see whether a 0.10% or 0.15% fee is worth it for your balance and timeline?
9. Converting an Existing ETF to a Wealthsimple Direct Index: The Tax Effect
What Wealthsimple has said. The November 5, 2026 release says clients can “set up direct indexing or convert an existing ETF in a few taps,” and the conversion is live. Wealthsimple’s product pages and help articles do not describe how the conversion works or what it means for tax. Its Automated Investing help article says holdings moved in that are not in the target portfolio “may be sold automatically, without notice.”
Why a sale matters. If a conversion is carried out by selling your ETF units and buying the stocks, the sale is a disposition in a non-registered account. A sale above your adjusted cost base is a capital gain, half of which is taxable in the year of the sale. That holds even though the money never leaves your account. This is general information reviewed by a CPA, not advice on your return; please ask Wealthsimple exactly how your conversion is processed before you start it.
A worked number. This example is hypothetical. An ETF position worth $60,000 has an adjusted cost base of $42,000, and its owner has $85,000 of other taxable income in 2026. A sale realizes a ($60,000 − $42,000 = $18,000) capital gain, of which ($18,000 x 50% = $9,000) is taxable. Our 2026 tax engine puts the extra tax at $2,668.50 in Ontario and $2,538.00 in British Columbia.
| Item | Ontario | British Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Capital gain realized | $18,000 | $18,000 |
| Taxable capital gain (50%) | $9,000 | $9,000 |
| Extra tax at $85,000 of other income | $2,668.50 | $2,538.00 |
| Extra tax as a share of the gain | 14.8% | 14.1% |
When the ETF is below cost. A sale below cost creates a capital loss instead, which can be useful. The loss would be superficial if you or an affiliated person bought back the same ETF within 30 days before or after the sale and still held it at the end of that period, so stop any pre-authorized purchases of that ETF in all accounts first.
Ways to manage the bill. A conversion can make more sense for ETF lots with small gains or with losses. Other general approaches: converting in a year with lower income; using net capital losses carried forward from earlier years; leaving the old ETF in place and putting only new money into the direct index; or splitting a conversion across December and January so the gain falls in two tax years. Our TFSA vs non-registered account comparison covers where gains are taxed in the first place.
10. Tracking Difference: How Close a Direct Index Stays to Its Index
What tracking difference is. Tracking difference is the gap between an investment’s return and the return of the index it follows, over a set period. Every index ETF has one, mostly from its MER, trading costs and cash. A direct index has one too, and it can be larger, because the account deliberately departs from the index each time it harvests a loss.
Where a direct index can drift. Four things move a direct index away from its index. The replacement after a harvest is “a similar stock,” not the same one, so for a while the account holds a company the index weights differently. Small balances cannot hold every company in exact weights. Cash from dividends and deposits waits until the next rebalance. And the yearly fee comes off the return, just as an MER does.
What you can measure today. Wealthsimple’s product page names no benchmark for its four direct indexes, so there is no published index to measure tracking difference against yet. The older help article named benchmarks for two indexes, but the newer page does not repeat them. Until a benchmark is published, the only fair comparison is your account’s return against a broad index ETF covering the same market, over a full year or more.
Why some drift comes with the product. Holding a slightly different set of companies after a harvest is the price of capturing the loss. Whether the drift is small next to the tax value of the loss depends on how closely each replacement moves with the stock it replaced, and a period of unusual moves in one sector can widen it.
What to watch. Over time, compare three things: your account’s return before tax, the return of a broad ETF on the same market, and the harvested losses you can see on your T5008 slip and trade confirmations. A direct index that lags by more than its fee every year without producing losses is not doing its job.
11. Tax Slips and Reporting: T5008, T5, T3 and T1135
T5008 for every sale. Each harvesting sale and each rebalancing sale is a disposition. Wealthsimple issues the T5008 (with an RL-18 for Quebec residents) for non-registered accounts; for the 2025 tax year it went out on March 2, 2026. Box 21 shows proceeds and box 20 shows cost or book value, which may or may not match your adjusted cost base. You must adjust box 20 where needed when you report each sale on Schedule 3. Our T5008 slip guide covers the boxes.
T5 for dividends. Dividends from stocks held directly arrive on a T5 (and an RL-3 in Quebec). Wealthsimple’s 2025 tax-year guide says no slip is issued for less than $50, “but you still need to report it on your return.” Our T5 slip guide explains each box. Wealthsimple has not said which international and emerging markets ETFs the Global Markets index holds; income from any that are Canadian ETF trusts would come on a T3, which Wealthsimple issued on March 31, 2026 for the 2025 tax year; our T3 slip guide covers it.
2026 dates. Wealthsimple’s slip-dates article still covers the 2025 tax year, so its 2026 tax-year dates have not been published. The T5008 is due by the last day of February after the year. For 2026 that day is Sunday, February 28, 2027, so the deadline moves to Monday, March 1, 2027, our calculation from the CRA’s rules. Our Wealthsimple tax slips guide lists every slip and date.
Form T1135 for US stocks. Shares of non-resident corporations are specified foreign property. The CRA counts a fund, not its holdings, so US stocks owned through a Canadian fund are not counted. If the total cost amount of your specified foreign property, generally its adjusted cost base, is more than $100,000 at any time in the year, you must file Form T1135 with your return. Below $250,000 throughout the year, the simplified Part A is allowed; at $250,000 or more, Part B is required. Property held with a Canadian registered securities dealer may be reported in aggregate, country by country. The late-filing penalty is the greater of $100 or $25 a day, to a maximum of $2,500. Our T1135 guide has the details.
| Document | What it reports | Issued for 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| T5008 / RL-18 | Each sale: proceeds (box 21) and cost or book value (box 20) | March 2, 2026 |
| T5 / RL-3 | Dividends and interest of $50 or more | March 2, 2026 |
| T3 / RL-16 | Trust income, such as ETF distributions | March 31, 2026 |
| Foreign asset report | A Wealthsimple report of foreign assets held in the account | March 20, 2026 |
US dividend withholding. US dividends paid to a Canadian resident are capped at a 15% US tax under the Canada-US treaty, once the broker holds your Form W-8BEN. For a direct index in a non-registered account, the full dividend before US tax goes on your return. Form T2209 then gives a federal foreign tax credit for the smaller of the US tax withheld and the Canadian tax on that dividend, and outside Quebec Form T2036 covers the provincial part. Our foreign tax credit guide and W-8BEN guide explain both.
12. Is Wealthsimple Direct Indexing Safe? CIPF and Complaints
Where the stocks sit. A direct index is not a separate fund. The stocks are held in your own non-registered Trade account at Wealthsimple; in Wealthsimple’s words, “You’ll hold the individual stocks in the index instead of an ETF.”
CIPF. The Canadian Investor Protection Fund covers client property held by a member firm that becomes insolvent. It does not cover market losses. A non-registered cash or margin account falls in CIPF’s general group, which has one $1,000,000 limit for cash, margin, TFSA and FHSA accounts combined, separate from the $1,000,000 limit for retirement accounts and the $1,000,000 limit for RESPs. Wealthsimple’s own pages show “$1M CIPF” coverage. Our Is Wealthsimple safe? review and CIPF vs CDIC guide cover the rules.
Complaints. For investment accounts, Wealthsimple says it acknowledges a written complaint “typically within 5 business days” and normally gives a written decision within 90 days. If there is no decision within 90 days, or you disagree with it, you can go to the Ombudsman for Banking Services and Investments (OBSI) up to 180 days after the decision; OBSI can recommend compensation of up to $350,000. A regulatory complaint can also go to CIRO, and Quebec residents can use the AMF’s mediation service.
Getting help. Wealthsimple publishes one phone number, 1-855-255-9038, for all products, plus 24/7 chat in the app and on the web. Premium clients get priority phone support, and Generation clients priority phone and priority email. Our Wealthsimple customer service guide lists every channel.
Fraud safeguards. Wealthsimple says its employees will never call and ask for your password or your 6-digit two-factor code, and that it may add extra verification before money is withdrawn when activity looks unusual. Because a direct index holds hundreds of positions, please review your trade confirmations and monthly statements rather than relying on the app summary alone.
13. Wealthsimple Direct Indexing Pros and Cons
Pros
- 0.10% a year for U.S. Market and Canadian Market on the product page, with harvesting included
- Automatic tax-loss harvesting on deposits, withdrawals, 5% drops and monthly
- $0 commission on the many trades harvesting creates
- Can be added to an existing non-registered account without moving money
- $1,000 minimum per index on the product page
- Stocks held in your own account, covered by CIPF’s general limit
- Each stock keeps its own cost base, so losses can be captured stock by stock
Cons
- Wealthsimple’s own pages disagree on the fee, the minimum and the number of indexes
- No benchmark named, so tracking cannot be measured against a published index
- Personal non-registered accounts only: no TFSA, RRSP, FHSA, joint or corporate
- No published method for the superficial loss rule across your other accounts
- Many more T5008 lines to report than one ETF
- US stocks held directly count toward the $100,000 Form T1135 threshold
- Harvesting mostly defers tax rather than removing it
Weighing them. The pros are real for the right account: a low fee, automation and no commissions. The cons are mostly about what Wealthsimple has not yet published. None of them is hidden, but together they mean a buyer should read the reporting duties before the marketing.
14. How Wealthsimple Direct Indexing Compares, and Who It Suits
Four ways to own an index at Wealthsimple. You can buy an index ETF yourself in Trade, use a stand-alone direct index, use Automated Investing, or use Managed Investing. The table compares their published costs and features as of November 9, 2026. Fund MERs are left as “fund MERs” because they depend on the funds held.
| Feature | Index ETF in Trade | Direct index | Automated Investing | Managed Investing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wealthsimple fee | $0 commission on listed securities | 0.10% or 0.15% a year | 0.25% a year, capped at $250 per account once the balance reaches $100,000 | 0.5% Core; 0.4% Premium; 0.4% at $500,000 falling to 0.2% at $10,000,000 on Generation |
| Fund costs | The ETF’s MER | None on stocks; Global Markets adds its ETFs’ MERs | Fund MERs on any ETFs held | Fund MERs |
| Tax-loss harvesting | Do it yourself | Automatic | Only within direct indexing in non-registered accounts | Premium and Generation; not Core |
| Accounts | All Trade accounts | Personal non-registered only | TFSA, RRSP, spousal RRSP, FHSA, LIRA, LIF, RRIF, non-registered, joint non-registered, business | TFSA, RRSP, spousal RRSP, non-registered, FHSA, RESP, RRIF, LIRA, and LIF per its help article |
| Who places trades | You | Wealthsimple | Wealthsimple | Wealthsimple |
| Our score | Wealthsimple broker score 4.2 / 5 | Not scored | Not scored | Wealthsimple Managed Investing 4.2 / 5 |
Against a do-it-yourself ETF. Holding a low-cost index ETF in a Wealthsimple TFSA or RRSP costs only the fund’s MER and needs no harvesting, because gains there are not taxed each year. Direct indexing competes only for money that is already in, or must go into, a non-registered account. Our best brokers for ETFs list ranks the platforms for that route.
Against managed portfolios. Wealthsimple Managed Investing scores 4.2 / 5 in our robo-advisor ranking and includes tax-loss harvesting from the Premium tier. It costs more than a direct index but works in registered accounts too. Our Wealthsimple Managed Investing review, best robo-advisors list and Wealthsimple vs Questwealth comparison cover those options.
Who it suits. Wealthsimple direct indexing may suit an investor with a non-registered balance of meaningful size who realizes capital gains most years, is comfortable reconciling many T5008 lines, and expects to hold for a long time. It is built for people who have already filled their TFSA and are using taxable space.
Who should look elsewhere. It is a weaker fit for investors whose money fits in a TFSA, RRSP or FHSA, couples who invest through a joint account, holding companies, investors who want to leave out particular companies today, and anyone with US holdings near the $100,000 Form T1135 threshold who would rather not file it. Our which account to fill first guide covers the order of accounts.
What You Need and What You Get With Wealthsimple Direct Indexing
What you need
- A Wealthsimple account with a personal non-registered self-directed (Trade) account
- At least $1,000 for each direct index, or $3,000 for Global Markets if that minimum applies to you
- Your adjusted cost base for any ETF you plan to convert
- A record of capital gains you expect to realize this year and any losses carried forward
- A list of the same companies held in your other accounts and your spouse’s accounts
- Form W-8BEN on file if you will hold US stocks
- Time at tax season to reconcile T5008 lines on Schedule 3
What you get
- The individual stocks of the index you choose, held in your account
- A yearly fee of 0.10% or 0.15% on the product page, calculated daily and paid monthly
- Automatic tax-loss harvesting and rebalancing
- $0 commission on the trades it places
- Capital losses you can claim against gains this year, three years back or in any later year
- Coverage under CIPF’s general account limit
- T5008 and T5 slips each spring for the account
How to Set Up a Wealthsimple Direct Index
- Confirm the account. Direct indexing works only in a personal non-registered Trade account. Open one first if you only have a TFSA, RRSP or FHSA.
- Choose an index and check its terms. Note the fee and minimum for that index; where Wealthsimple’s pages disagree, please ask Wealthsimple which applies before you fund it.
- Decide between new money and a conversion. Work out the gain or loss on any ETF you would convert, using its adjusted cost base, before you tap convert.
- Fund the index. Add at least the minimum. Wealthsimple places the trades and holds every stock in the index for now.
- Protect the harvested losses. Turn off pre-authorized purchases and dividend reinvestment of the same companies in your other accounts, and tell your spouse which companies the index holds.
- Keep records through the year. Keep your trade confirmations and monthly statements, and your ACB for any shares of the same companies held elsewhere.
- Report at tax time. Reconcile each T5008 line with your ACB on Schedule 3, claim any foreign tax credit, and check whether Form T1135 applies.
10 Wealthsimple Direct Indexing Strategies
1. Match losses to gains
Harvested losses save tax right away only when you have taxable capital gains to offset. If you plan to sell a winning holding this year, a direct index running beside it can soften the bill in the same year.
2. Fill registered room first
A TFSA, RRSP or FHSA shelters growth without any harvesting. Direct indexing competes only for money that is already taxable, so many investors fill registered room before they fund one.
3. Plan around the higher fee
Wealthsimple’s pages show 0.10% and 0.15%. Budgeting at 0.15% means any confirmation of the lower product-page fee only improves the result.
4. Convert part of a position
Tax uses the average cost of all your units of an ETF, so lots bought at different prices do not change the gain per unit. Converting only part of a position, or only ETFs that sit near their cost, keeps the realized gain small.
5. Spread a big conversion
Splitting a large conversion between December and January puts the gain in two tax years, which can keep more of it out of a higher bracket.
6. Watch every account for the 30-day rule
The superficial loss rule counts your other accounts and your spouse’s. Pausing automatic purchases of the same companies elsewhere protects the losses the index harvests.
7. Track the T1135 threshold
US shares held directly count toward the $100,000 cost threshold at any time in the year. Adding new money mid-year can push you over it, so check before large deposits.
8. Use carried-forward losses wisely
Net capital losses can be carried forward with no time limit. Keep a running total so a later gain, such as an ETF conversion, can be offset against it.
9. Donate appreciated shares
Gifting listed shares with large gains to a qualified donee carries a zero inclusion rate on the gain, which can turn a harvesting deferral into a permanent saving.
10. Compare returns once a year
Set your account’s yearly return beside a broad ETF on the same market. A direct index that lags by more than its fee without producing losses is not paying its way.
Illustrative Example: A First Year of Wealthsimple Direct Indexing in Alberta
This example is hypothetical. Sam, 45, lives in Alberta and has $95,000 of taxable salary in 2026. Sam’s TFSA and RRSP are full. In January, Sam puts $100,000 of new money into the U.S. Market direct index in a personal non-registered Trade account, then adds $5,000 in June. Fees are as published on November 9, 2026, tax is at 2026 rates from our shared tax engine, and investment returns are ignored.
- Fee: on the product page, U.S. Market costs 0.10% a year, so once both deposits are in, the fee runs at ($105,000 x 0.10% = $105) a year before any growth. At the help article’s 0.15% it would be ($105,000 x 0.15% = $157.50) a year. The 2026 fee is a little lower, because the $5,000 was invested only from June.
- Harvesting realizes $4,000 of capital losses during 2026. Sam also sells shares held elsewhere for an $8,000 capital gain.
- Without the losses, the taxable gain is ($8,000 x 50% = $4,000) and adds $1,220.00 of tax. With them, the taxable gain is (($8,000 − $4,000) x 50% = $2,000) and adds $610.00. The saving is ($1,220.00 − $610.00 = $610.00).
- Foreign property: the June deposit lifted the cost of Sam’s US shares to ($100,000 + $5,000 = $105,000), more than $100,000. Even though harvesting later lowered the cost to about ($105,000 − $4,000 = $101,000), the test is “at any time in the year,” so Sam files Form T1135 for 2026, using Part A because the cost stayed under $250,000.
- Slips: Sam receives a T5008 listing each harvesting sale and a T5 for the dividends, and reconciles each sale with its adjusted cost base on Schedule 3.
The $610.00 saved in 2026 is mostly a deferral: the replacement stocks carry about $4,000 less cost base, so a later sale at a recovered price would bring that tax back. Sam’s fee of about $105 a year is the price of the automation; whether it pays depends on how often losses can be harvested and on Sam’s tax rate when the replacements are eventually sold.
Wealthsimple Direct Indexing FAQ
What is Wealthsimple direct indexing?
Wealthsimple direct indexing holds the individual stocks of an index in your personal non-registered Trade account instead of one ETF. It went live on November 5, 2026. Wealthsimple sells stocks that fall to realize capital losses and buys similar stocks, so market exposure stays about the same. The product page lists four indexes: U.S. Market, Canadian Market, U.S. Innovation and Global Markets.
How much does Wealthsimple direct indexing cost?
Wealthsimple’s product page lists 0.10% a year for the U.S. Market and Canadian Market indexes and 0.15% a year for U.S. Innovation and Global Markets, with tax-loss harvesting included. The fee is calculated daily and paid monthly. An older help article still says 0.15% for all. Global Markets also holds ETFs that charge their own MERs. Trades carry $0 commission.
What is the minimum for a Wealthsimple direct index?
The product page says $1,000 for each direct index. Wealthsimple’s Automated Investing help article says $1,000 per direct index and $3,000 for the Global Markets index. Because the two pages differ, please confirm the Global Markets minimum with Wealthsimple before you fund it. No tier rule is published, and nothing on the direct indexing page limits it to Premium or Generation clients.
Can I use Wealthsimple direct indexing in a TFSA or RRSP?
Not yet. Wealthsimple says direct indexing works in personal non-registered Trade accounts only and that TFSAs, RRSPs, FHSAs, joint and corporate accounts are not supported yet. No date has been given. In a TFSA, gains are generally tax-free, so the main benefit of direct indexing, harvesting deductible capital losses, would not apply there anyway.
How does Wealthsimple tax-loss harvesting work?
When a stock in the index falls below its cost, Wealthsimple sells it to realize the capital loss and buys a similar stock. Its help article says harvesting and rebalancing run on deposits or withdrawals, when the account loses 5% or more of its value, and otherwise monthly. Half of each loss is an allowable capital loss that offsets taxable capital gains.
Does Wealthsimple direct indexing avoid the superficial loss rule?
Wealthsimple has not published how it applies the rule. Its harvesting buys a similar stock, not the same one. The rule also counts purchases of identical property by you or an affiliated person, including your spouse, within 30 days before or after the sale, in other accounts the automation cannot see. Pausing automatic purchases of the same companies elsewhere protects the losses.
Is converting an ETF to a direct index taxable?
It can be. Wealthsimple has not published how conversion works. If your ETF units are sold to buy the stocks, the sale is a disposition in a non-registered account, and a sale above your adjusted cost base is a capital gain, half of it taxable. On an $18,000 gain with $85,000 of other income, our engine shows $2,668.50 of Ontario and federal tax.
Is Wealthsimple’s up to 0.5% after-tax estimate guaranteed?
No. Wealthsimple says direct indexing can boost after-tax returns by up to 0.5% a year in a non-registered account, and adds that results depend on your tax situation and market conditions and are not guaranteed. It is Wealthsimple’s own best-case estimate, which WealthScale has not verified. Harvesting mostly defers tax, because replacement stocks carry a lower cost base.
Which index does each Wealthsimple direct index track?
Wealthsimple’s product page names no benchmark for its U.S. Market, Canadian Market, U.S. Innovation and Global Markets indexes. An older help article named benchmarks for two indexes, but the newer page does not repeat them. Until Wealthsimple publishes a benchmark, we name none, and tracking can only be judged against a broad ETF covering the same market.
What tax slips will I get from a direct index?
A T5008 lists each sale, including every harvesting and rebalancing trade, with proceeds and cost or book value; you adjust the cost to your adjusted cost base on Schedule 3. Dividends of $50 or more arrive on a T5. For the 2025 tax year both went out on March 2, 2026. Wealthsimple has not yet published its 2026 dates.
Do I need to file Form T1135 for a US direct index?
You may. US shares held directly are specified foreign property. If their total cost amount is more than $100,000 at any time in the year, Form T1135 is due with your return. The simplified Part A is allowed while the total stays under $250,000. Units of a Canadian fund holding US stocks do not count, because the CRA counts the fund.
Is direct indexing better than an index ETF?
It depends on the account and your gains. In a TFSA or RRSP, an ETF needs no harvesting and costs only its MER. In a non-registered account, a direct index can create deductible losses, but costs 0.10% or 0.15% a year, adds reporting, and may trigger Form T1135 for US shares. Over 25 years at a 6% example return, 0.10% instead of an example 0.05% costs $5,451 on $100,000.
Does WealthScale rate Wealthsimple direct indexing?
No. We have not built a score for direct indexing products, so this review carries no rating. Wealthsimple’s broker score, which covers the Trade platform direct indexing runs on, is 4.2 / 5, rank 5 of 13 online brokers as of November 9, 2026, and Wealthsimple Managed Investing scores 4.2 / 5 among robo-advisors.
Before you move taxable money into a direct index, compare it with the other ways to invest at Wealthsimple.
Figures on this page were checked against Wealthsimple’s published product, pricing and help pages and Canada Revenue Agency publications on November 9, 2026. We update this page when a figure changes.
Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.
- Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
- Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
- Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
- Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.
- CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
- Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
- In financial markets since December 2005
- More than 2,600 published investment articles
General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.