Retirement · Workplace pensions

Pension or Lump Sum: Taking the Commuted Value in Canada

Pension or lump sum is the choice between a monthly income for life from a defined benefit pension plan and its commuted value, the lump sum the plan says that pension is worth today. Only part of a large commuted value can move to a registered account without tax: the limit is your yearly pension times a factor for your age, 12.4 at 64 or 65, so a $3,000-a-month pension can move up to $446,400. Anything above that is paid to you and taxed in the year, unless unused RRSP room absorbs it. The pension removes investment and longevity risk. The lump sum gives you control and something to leave behind.

Written by a CPASharad Gondaliya, CPA Ontario No. 61040184
CFA charterholder reviewerNeha Gupta, CFA reviews our investing and account pages; each page shows its review status
Figures checkedOctober 28, 2026
Transfer factors from the regulationEvery limit on this page uses the Income Tax Regulations’ age factors, computed exactly

At a glance

The choice. When you leave a defined benefit pension plan, or retire from one, the plan may let you keep a monthly pension or take its commuted value instead. The commuted value is the lump sum the plan’s actuary says your pension is worth today. You give up the pension for good once the lump sum is paid.

The tax-free transfer limit. The Income Tax Regulations cap how much of a commuted value can move tax-deferred to an RRSP, a RRIF or a money purchase plan: the yearly lifetime pension given up times a present value factor for your age. The factor is 9.0 under 50, peaks at 12.4 at ages 64 and 65, and falls to 3.0 from age 96.

The taxable portion. Any part of the commuted value above that limit has to be paid to you and is included in your income for the year. You can contribute it to an RRSP and deduct it only within your unused room. Contributions more than $2,000 over your limit are taxed at 1% a month.

Where the money goes. Pension standards law, not tax law, decides whether the tax-deferred part must stay locked in, for example in a LIRA (locked-in retirement account) that later becomes a LIF or buys a life annuity.

What decides it. Your health and family history, whether the pension rises with inflation, the survivor pension your spouse would get, the strength of the plan and employer, interest rates on the day the value is set, and whether you want control or a guaranteed income.

A tax difference people miss. Life annuity payments from a pension plan can be split with a spouse at any age. LIF and RRIF payments built from a commuted value can be split only from 65.

12.4Highest transfer factor, at ages 64 and 65
$446,400Tax-free limit for a $3,000-a-month pension at 64 or 65
9.0Factor for anyone under 50
$2,000RRSP over-contribution cushion before the 1% monthly tax

To test a lump sum against your pension, enter the commuted value as the portfolio and your yearly pension as the withdrawal. The calculator shows how many years the money would last at the return you choose, what is left after a set number of years, and how a run of bad years early on changes the result.

1. Pension or Lump Sum: The Short Answer

The decision rule. Keeping the pension tends to suit people who value a guaranteed income for life over control, whose pension rises with inflation, whose family tends to live long, and whose employer and plan look sound. Taking the commuted value tends to suit people with reason to expect a shorter retirement, people who want to leave money to heirs, members of a weak plan, and people who are confident they can invest a large sum and draw it down with discipline. This is a general rule, not personal advice.

What the pension gives you. A defined benefit pension pays a set amount every month for as long as you live, and often a reduced amount to a surviving spouse afterward. The plan carries the investment risk and the risk that you live to 100. You cannot outlive it, you make no investment decisions, and a market crash in your first year of retirement does not change your cheque.

What the lump sum gives you. The commuted value moves the money, and every risk that came with it, to you. You choose the investments, how fast to draw the money and who inherits what is left. In return you take on market risk, the risk of outliving the money and the cost of investment fees. On a large commuted value, part of the money may also be taxed in the year you receive it.

The ratio that frames the choice. Divide the commuted value by the yearly pension. For a $3,000-a-month pension ($36,000 a year) and a hypothetical $520,000 commuted value, the ratio is $520,000 / $36,000 = 14.4. Section 4 shows what return that lump sum would need to keep paying $36,000 a year: 5.48% a year to age 90 and 6.22% to age 95, before fees, even in the best case where all of it stays tax-sheltered.

The part that is not negotiable. Whatever you decide, the tax rules decide how much of the lump sum keeps its shelter. At 64 or 65, that is 12.4 times your yearly pension. If your commuted value is higher, the rest is taxable income in a single year, and that tax is part of the price of the lump sum. Our defined benefit vs defined contribution guide explains how the two kinds of plan differ before this choice arrives.

2. 2026 Figures: Transfer Factors and Limits

The rules that set your numbers. The table gathers every rule and figure this page relies on. The transfer factors come from section 8517 of the Income Tax Regulations. They are fixed in the regulation and are not indexed, so they do not change from year to year the way tax brackets do.

Commuted value transfer rules and 2026 figures
Rule or figureWhat it is
Maximum tax-deferred transferYearly lifetime pension given up x the present value factor for your age at the transfer
Where the tax-deferred part can goAn RRSP, a RRIF or a money purchase pension plan, by direct transfer
Factor for anyone under 509.0
Highest factor12.4, at 64 and at 65
Factor at 96 or over3.0
Floor when your whole entitlement is transferredThe greater of the factor amount and your net contribution account balance
Commuted value above the limitPaid to you and included in your income for the year
Excess contributed to an RRSPNormal RRSP rules: deductible within your unused room
RRSP over-contribution tax1% a month on contributions more than $2,000 above your deduction limit
Form for the direct transferForm T2151; no T4A slip and no tax withheld on the amount transferred directly
Defined benefit limit, 2026$3,932.22 of yearly pension per year of service
Money purchase limit, 2026$35,390
Pension credit for a defined benefit plan9 x the benefit earned in the year, minus $600
Pension income splittingUp to 50%: pension plan life annuity payments at any age; LIF and RRIF payments from 65
OAS recovery threshold, 2026 income year$95,323 of net income; 15% of the amount above it

Regulation 8517 transfer factors by age

How to read it. Find your age on the day of the transfer and multiply its factor by the yearly pension you are giving up. The factors rise from 9.4 at 50 to 12.4 at 64 and 65, because a pension that starts soon is worth more today than one that starts in 15 years. After 65 they fall, because fewer payments remain to be expected.

Present value factors, Income Tax Regulations s. 8517(1)
AgeFactorAgeFactorAgeFactor
Under 509.06512.4817.0
509.46612.0826.7
519.66711.7836.4
529.86811.3846.1
5310.06911.0855.8
5410.27010.6865.5
5510.47110.3875.2
5610.67210.1884.9
5710.8739.8894.7
5811.0749.4904.4
5911.3759.1914.2
6011.5768.7923.9
6111.7778.4933.7
6212.0788.0943.5
6312.2797.7953.2
6412.4807.396 or over3.0

The limit in dollars. The next table applies the factors to a $3,000-a-month pension ($36,000 a year). The same pension has a tax-free limit $108,000 higher at 64 than at 50 ($446,400 – $338,400).

Tax-free transfer limit for a $36,000-a-year pension, by age at the transfer
Age at the transferFactorMaximum tax-deferred transfer
Under 509.0$324,000
509.4$338,400
5510.4$374,400
5811.0$396,000
6011.5$414,000
6212.0$432,000
6412.4$446,400
6512.4$446,400
6711.7$421,200
7010.6$381,600

3. How a Commuted Value Pension Transfer Works

What a commuted value pension is

The lump sum behind the promise. A defined benefit plan promises a pension based on a formula, often your years of service times a percentage of your earnings. The commuted value is the amount the plan calculates it would need to set aside today to pay that promise for the rest of your life. The plan’s actuary uses interest rates and life expectancy assumptions to get there, so the same pension can have a different commuted value from one month to the next.

When it is offered. Plans often offer the choice when you leave an employer before retirement age, and some offer it at retirement as well. Your plan text and the pension law that governs the plan decide whether you have the option and how long you have to choose. The options statement the administrator sends you shows the commuted value, the pension you would give up and the deadline.

The transfer limit: A x B

The formula. The most you can move tax-deferred is A x B. A is the yearly lifetime pension you are giving up, measured as if it were payable from 65 with no reduction for age or service. B is the present value factor for your age at the time of the transfer. A member giving up a $24,000-a-year pension at 58 can move $24,000 x 11.0 = $264,000 without tax.

Ages between birthdays. Where the next age has a higher factor, your administrator interpolates for the fraction of a year. At 60 and a half, the factor sits halfway between 11.5 and 11.7, so 11.6. From 65 on, the factors fall each year, so the factor for your attained age applies.

The floor for a full transfer. If the transfer settles your whole entitlement, the limit is never less than your net contribution account balance, the balance of your own contributions as the plan records it. Only the defined benefit entitlement itself can move this way; any share of plan surplus cannot.

When everything moves tax-free. If the limit is greater than the lump sum, the whole commuted value can be transferred without tax. That tends to happen for younger members, because a pension that starts decades from now has a modest value today, and when interest rates are high, which lowers commuted values.

Pension transfer to a LIRA

Tax law and pension law are separate. Tax law lets the tax-deferred part go to an RRSP, a RRIF or a money purchase plan. Pension standards law decides whether that money must stay locked in. Where it must, the administrator transfers it only to the locked-in account its law allows, such as a LIRA or a locked-in RRSP, which later converts to a LIF or buys a life annuity. Our RRIF vs LIF comparison shows how locked-in withdrawals differ, and the best LIRA accounts list compares where to hold one.

How the money moves. The administrator transfers the tax-deferred part directly to the receiving institution, and can use Form T2151 to record it. On a direct transfer like this, the administrator issues no T4A slip and withholds no tax. If the money is paid to you first instead, it is a payment to you, not a transfer.

The taxable portion of commuted value

The excess is income. Any part of the value above the limit has to be paid to you and is included in your income in the year it is paid. If an administrator sends an excess to a registered plan anyway, the rules treat it as paid to you and include it in your income. You can still contribute the cash to your RRSP and claim a deduction, but only within your unused room. Section 6 works out the tax.

4. Pension or Lump Sum: Worked Numbers for a $3,000-a-Month Pension

The assumptions. This example is hypothetical. Diane is 64, lives in Ontario and is retiring this year after earning $40,000 of salary in the months before she leaves. Her plan offers a pension of $3,000 a month ($36,000 a year) for life, starting now, with no inflation increases, or a commuted value of $520,000. The returns below are assumptions for illustration, not forecasts, and are before investment fees. Withdrawals come out at the start of each year, the way our withdrawal calculator works.

Step 1: How much of the lump sum keeps its shelter

Diane’s commuted value, split by the transfer limit (hypothetical)
ItemAmountArithmetic
Commuted value offered$520,000From her options statement
Factor at 6412.4Regulation 8517(1)
Maximum tax-deferred transfer$446,400$36,000 x 12.4
Taxable excess paid to her$73,600$520,000 minus $446,400
Extra 2026 Ontario tax if the excess is kept as cash$20,903.25Tax on $113,600 minus tax on $40,000
Excess left after that tax$52,696.75$73,600 minus $20,903.25

Step 2: How long the lump sum pays $36,000 a year

Two versions of the lump sum. The first column is the best case: all $520,000 stays sheltered, as it would if Diane had enough RRSP room for the whole excess. The second uses only the $446,400 that transfers tax-free, with the after-tax excess set aside for other uses. Either way, every dollar she draws later is taxable, just as the pension would be, so the comparison is before tax on both sides.

Years each lump sum lasts paying $36,000 a year from age 64 (hypothetical returns)
Yearly return$520,000: years it lasts$520,000: runs out at about age$446,400: years it lasts$446,400: runs out at about age
3%18.5 years8215.2 years79
5%23.9 years8718.3 years82
7%42.9 years10624.6 years88

Reading the table. At 3%, the full $520,000 runs dry around 82, while the pension keeps paying. At 7%, it outlasts almost any lifespan and still holds $374,406 at the start of age 90 and $303,605 at the start of age 95. The sheltered $446,400 alone never reaches 90 at any of the three returns. The answer turns on the return you can actually earn after fees, and on how long you live.

Step 3: The return the lump sum must earn

Yearly return needed to pay $36,000 a year from 64 up to each age (hypothetical)
Lump sumTo age 85To age 90To age 95
$520,000 (all sheltered)4.12%5.48%6.22%
$446,400 (tax-free part only)6.08%7.25%7.87%

What this means. A return of 5.48% after fees, every year for 26 years, only matches the pension to 90, and only if all $520,000 stays sheltered. A bad market early in retirement makes it harder still, which the calculator above shows in its sequence-of-returns table. Our safe withdrawal rate guide explains why: $36,000 a year from $520,000 is a 6.92% withdrawal rate ($36,000 / $520,000), higher than any rate in the calculator’s 3% to 6% comparison table.

If the pension were indexed. If Diane’s pension rose with inflation, the fair test uses returns after inflation. At 1%, 3% and 5% after inflation, the full $520,000 would pay a rising $36,000 for 15.5, 18.5 and 23.9 years. Indexing makes the pension much harder to match.

Run your own commuted value against your monthly pension, then check how much of it the tax rules let you shelter.

5. What Changes the Answer

Health and longevity. A pension pays more in total the longer you live, and a lump sum is worth most to people who will not live long enough to collect many payments. Your own health, your parents’ and grandparents’ ages at death and any serious diagnosis matter more here than averages. A member in good health at 64 has a real chance of reaching 90, which is where the lump sum in section 4 starts to struggle.

Indexing. Check whether your pension rises with inflation in full, in part, only when the plan can afford it, or not at all. A fully indexed pension is the hardest to replace with a lump sum, because the lump sum has to fund rising payments. Section 4 shows how much shorter the same $520,000 lasts when the payments rise with prices.

Survivor options. A pension can continue to a surviving spouse, usually at a reduced amount, and choosing a larger survivor pension usually lowers your own payment. Pension standards law sets your spouse’s survivor rights and any waiver form. With a lump sum, what is left at your death goes to your beneficiary or your estate, subject to the tax rules at death. The CPP pays its own survivor benefit either way; our CPP survivor benefit guide has the 2026 maximums.

The plan and the employer. A pension is only as safe as the plan that pays it. Your plan’s statements report its funded position. If a plan winds up while underfunded, pension law decides what members receive, and benefits can be reduced. If your plan has bought annuities from an insurer to pay retirees, Assuris protects each pensioner’s monthly income up to $5,000 a month or 90% of the promised amount, whichever is higher.

Interest rates. Commuted values move opposite to interest rates: when rates fall, the lump sum needed to fund the same pension rises. The table shows a simple present value of $36,000 a year for 26 years, paid at the start of each year, at three discount rates. It is not your plan’s method, which uses its own actuarial assumptions, but it shows the size of the effect.

Present value of $36,000 a year for 26 years, paid at the start of each year (illustration)
Discount ratePresent valueChange from the 4% figure
3%$662,873$64,478 higher
4%$598,395None
5%$543,382$55,013 lower

Other income and OAS. If you are 65 or older and receive OAS, a taxable excess counts toward your net income for the year. For the 2026 income year, OAS is reduced by 15% of net income above $95,323, so a large excess can cost OAS as well as income tax. Our OAS clawback guide shows the recovery at each income, and our OAS deferral guide covers delaying OAS in a year like this.

Your habits with money. A lump sum needs a plan for investing it, a withdrawal rate you stick to and a way to keep fees low. If you would be tempted to spend it early or would sell in a falling market, the pension’s discipline has real value.

To see how a lump sum fits with your CPP and OAS, enter the commuted value as your savings and your planned retirement age. The calculator shows a level yearly income from the savings to the age you choose, beside CPP and OAS at your start ages.

6. Tax on the Taxable Portion of the Commuted Value

How the excess is taxed. The excess is added to your other income for the year and taxed at your marginal rates, so a large excess lands in high brackets. The table shows the extra 2026 Ontario tax on excess amounts for someone with $40,000 of other income, counting basic personal amounts, the Ontario Health Premium and Ontario’s tax reduction, and no other credits.

Ontario: extra 2026 tax on a taxable excess, with $40,000 of other income
Taxable excessExtra taxShare of the excess lost to taxLeft after tax
$25,000$5,788.9723.16%$19,211.03
$50,000$13,351.4726.70%$36,648.53
$73,600$20,903.2528.40%$52,696.75
$100,000$32,173.9132.17%$67,826.09
$150,000$54,784.7536.52%$95,215.25

Using RRSP room. If Diane from section 4 has $25,000 of unused RRSP room, she can contribute $25,000 of her $73,600 excess and deduct it. Her extra Ontario tax falls from $20,903.25 to $12,936.37, a saving of $7,966.88, and $25,000 stays sheltered. Contributions you make but do not deduct can be deducted in a later year, but the deduction is usually worth most in the year the excess pushes your income up. Your room is on your latest notice of assessment; our unused RRSP room guide explains how it carries forward.

Why pension members often have little room. Each year a defined benefit plan reports a pension adjustment that cuts next year’s RRSP room. For a defined benefit plan it is 9 x the benefit earned, minus $600. A member earning $80,000 in a plan that builds 1.5% of pay a year earns a $1,200 benefit ($80,000 x 1.5%), for a pension adjustment of $10,200 (9 x $1,200 – $600). Against 18% room of $14,400 ($80,000 x 18%), only $4,200 of new room is left. See our RRSP contribution limit page for the 2026 dollar limit.

Do not overshoot. RRSP contributions more than $2,000 above your deduction limit are taxed at 1% a month for as long as they stay in. Putting $5,000 more than your room into an RRSP leaves $3,000 above the cushion, which costs $30 a month ($3,000 x 1%). Our RRSP over-contribution guide explains how to fix one.

The same excess in every province

Province matters. The table takes Diane’s $73,600 excess on top of $40,000 of other income and works out the extra 2026 tax in each province and territory, with basic personal amounts and the engine’s provincial reductions only.

Extra 2026 tax on a $73,600 taxable excess with $40,000 of other income
Province or territoryExtra taxShare of the excessLeft after tax
Alberta$20,820.0128.29%$52,779.99
British Columbia$19,870.2927.00%$53,729.71
Manitoba$23,763.9132.29%$49,836.09
New Brunswick$23,799.3732.34%$49,800.63
Newfoundland and Labrador$24,599.8833.42%$49,000.12
Northwest Territories$20,135.8027.36%$53,464.20
Nova Scotia$25,909.2035.20%$47,690.80
Nunavut$18,601.9425.27%$54,998.06
Ontario$20,903.2528.40%$52,696.75
Prince Edward Island$25,361.8834.46%$48,238.12
Quebec$25,105.8934.11%$48,494.11
Saskatchewan$22,793.3730.97%$50,806.63
Yukon$20,026.4127.21%$53,573.59

Splitting: the pension’s tax edge before 65

The rule. The taxable part of life annuity payments from a pension plan can be split with a spouse or common-law partner at any age. RRIF and LIF payments qualify only once the spouse transferring them is 65 or older at the end of the year. A member who retires at 58 and keeps the pension can start splitting at once; one who takes the commuted value and draws a LIF must wait seven years.

A computed case. This example is hypothetical. Sophie and Daniel are both 58 and live in Ontario. Sophie has $36,000 a year, either as her pension or as LIF withdrawals; Daniel has $10,000 of other income. Figures are 2026 Ontario tax with basic personal amounts only.

Sophie and Daniel at 58: tax with the pension split, 2026 Ontario (hypothetical)
Share of Sophie’s pension moved to DanielAmount movedSophie’s taxDaniel’s taxCombined
0% (also the LIF result before 65)$0$4,198.78$0.00$4,198.78
20%$7,200$2,827.18$104.72$2,931.90
25% (lowest total)$9,000$2,484.28$363.83$2,848.11
30%$10,800$2,141.38$845.63$2,987.01
50%$18,000$216.72$2,674.78$2,891.50

What it is worth. The best split saves $1,350.67 a year ($4,198.78 – $2,848.11), or $9,454.69 over the seven years from 58 to 64 ($1,350.67 x 7), before indexing. The pension also qualifies for the federal pension income amount before 65, worth up to $280 a year ($2,000 x 14%); LIF payments do not qualify until 65. Our pension income splitting guide covers Form T1032.

The after-tax excess. Whatever cash survives the tax can be deposited in a TFSA up to your available room; growth there is never taxed, and taking it out later does not raise the income OAS is tested on. The 2026 TFSA limit is $7,000, and someone 18 or older and resident every year since 2009 who never contributed has $109,000 of room.

7. Should I Take the Commuted Value? A Step-by-Step Plan

Give yourself the full window. Options statements come with a deadline, and missing it usually leaves you with the default the plan sets. Please read the statement the day it arrives and mark the date.

  1. Read the options statement: the monthly pension, its start date, the indexing, the survivor forms, the commuted value and the deadline.
  2. Work out your transfer limit: yearly pension x the factor for your age, and the taxable excess above it.
  3. Check your unused RRSP room on your notice of assessment, and estimate the tax on any excess for that year.
  4. Run the lump sum through the withdrawal calculator at three returns you consider realistic after fees.
  5. Ask the administrator about the plan’s funded position and what pension law requires for locking in and spousal consent.
  6. Line up the receiving accounts: a LIRA or locked-in RRSP for the tax-deferred part, and an RRSP or TFSA for the excess.
  7. Sign the forms well before the deadline and confirm the transfer is direct, so nothing is withheld on the sheltered part.

What you need to decide

  • Your plan’s options or termination statement
  • The plan’s latest funded position
  • Your date of birth on the transfer date, for the factor
  • Your unused RRSP room from your notice of assessment
  • Your expected income in the year of the transfer
  • Your spouse’s age and income, for survivor and splitting choices
  • Your CPP and OAS estimates
  • A realistic return after fees for the lump sum
  • A LIRA or locked-in RRSP ready to receive the transfer

What you get from each path

  • Pension: income for life, whatever markets do
  • Pension: splitting with a spouse at any age
  • Pension: no investment decisions or fees to manage
  • Pension: survivor income for a spouse, if elected
  • Lump sum: control of the investments and withdrawals
  • Lump sum: a balance that can pass to heirs
  • Lump sum: freedom from the plan’s future funding
  • Lump sum: the risk of running out, which you carry

8. Special Situations

Leaving a job in your 30s, 40s or 50s. A deferred pension that starts at 65 is worth less now than one starting soon, so its commuted value is more likely to fit under the limit. Under 50 the factor is 9.0 whatever your age, so a 41-year-old giving up a $10,000-a-year deferred pension can move $90,000 ($10,000 x 9.0) tax-deferred. If you expect to work for many more years, the choice is between a fixed future pension and money you invest yourself for two decades or more.

Retiring before 65. Early retirees face two tax points. The pension, if kept, qualifies for splitting and the pension income amount right away. A commuted value in a LIF does not qualify for either until 65. Our retire at 55 and retire at 60 guides show how early income is built around CPP and OAS start dates.

Taking the value after 65. The factor falls each year after 65, so the tax-free share of the same commuted value shrinks. At 70 the factor is 10.6, so a $36,000 pension can move $381,600, compared with $446,400 at 65. A larger excess also arrives in a year when OAS recovery can apply.

Separation and divorce. Family law and pension law decide how a pension is divided on a breakdown of a marriage or common-law relationship, and the division can be paid as a transfer from the plan. Please get advice on your plan’s rules before you sign a separation agreement.

Death before you choose. If a member dies before retirement, the plan text sets the death benefit for a spouse or beneficiary. Keep the plan’s beneficiary information current while you decide.

Quebec. Quebec-regulated plans follow Quebec’s pension law, which sets its own locked-in accounts and rules. The tax limit and factors on this page come from the federal Income Tax Regulations and apply for federal tax wherever you live; Quebec residents also file a Quebec return under Quebec’s own rules.

Living outside Canada. If you are or will become a non-resident, the tax on any excess and on later withdrawals changes. For RRSP withdrawals, non-residents have 25% withheld unless a tax treaty reduces it. Ask the administrator before you sign.

Defined contribution plans. A defined contribution plan already holds an account balance, not a promised pension, so there is no commuted value to calculate and the factor limit on this page does not apply to it. Our defined benefit vs defined contribution page covers the difference.

Before you sign, see what your other savings, CPP and OAS add up to with or without the pension.

9. Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Comparing the lump sum with the wrong number. People compare the commuted value with what they paid into the plan, or with the total of a few years of payments. Fix: compare it with the return it would need to match the pension for as long as you might live, as section 4 does.

Forgetting the taxable excess. A $520,000 commuted value is not $520,000 of sheltered money if the limit is $446,400. Fix: work out A x B first, then the tax on the excess, before you compare.

Over-contributing to shelter the excess. Putting the whole excess into an RRSP without the room to deduct it can trigger the 1% monthly tax. Fix: check the room on your notice of assessment, and keep any contribution above it within the $2,000 cushion.

Ignoring indexing and survivor value. An indexed pension with a survivor benefit is worth far more than a flat single-life pension of the same starting amount. Fix: list what the pension includes before you decide it is worth less than the lump sum.

Assuming you can move locked-in money anywhere. The tax-deferred part usually has to go where pension law allows. Fix: open the account type named on your options statement before the deadline.

Planning on high returns. A lump sum plan that works only at 7% a year after fees is fragile. Fix: test 3%, 5% and 7%, and look at the bad-years-first result in the withdrawal calculator.

10. Planning Strategies for a Commuted Value

1. Time the transfer near 64 or 65

The factor peaks at 12.4 at ages 64 and 65. If your plan lets you choose the date, a transfer at those ages shelters the largest share of the same pension.

2. Deduct the excess in the high year

An RRSP deduction is worth most in the year the excess lifts your income. Diane’s $25,000 deduction saves $7,966.88 that year.

3. Build room before you leave

If you know a large excess is coming, keep unused RRSP room rather than filling it, so it can absorb the taxable part.

4. Leave in a low-income year

If you can choose when the excess is paid, a year with little other income keeps more of it in lower brackets.

5. Keep the pension for the floor

A guaranteed pension plus CPP and OAS can cover fixed costs for life, so the rest of your savings can stay invested for growth.

6. Consider a life annuity later

Locked-in money can buy a life annuity. Our annuities guide explains how annuities work if you want income for life without the plan.

7. Value the splitting years

If you retire before 65 with a lower-income spouse, the pension’s splitting can be worth thousands. Sophie and Daniel’s best split saves $1,350.67 a year.

8. Put the after-tax cash in a TFSA

The after-tax excess can go into a TFSA within your room, where growth is tax-free and withdrawals do not affect OAS.

9. Plan the drawdown order

Decide which accounts to draw first so the LIF, RRSP and TFSA work together. See our retirement withdrawal order guide.

10. Keep fees low

On a lump sum, every 1% a year in fees adds 1% to the return the investments must earn before fees. Compare accounts on our best RRSP accounts list.

Illustrative Example: Two Members, Two Ages

This example is hypothetical. Both members live in Ontario. Tax uses 2026 rules with basic personal amounts only.

  1. Marcus, 52, leaving his employer. He has a deferred pension of $24,000 a year payable from 65 and is offered a commuted value of $260,000. His limit is $24,000 x 9.8 = $235,200, so $24,800 is taxable ($260,000 – $235,200). He has $30,000 of unused RRSP room, so he contributes the $24,800 and deducts it: the income and the deduction cancel, and all $260,000 stays sheltered, with $5,200 of room left ($30,000 – $24,800). Without the room, the excess would add $7,674.45 to his tax on an $85,000 salary.
  2. Lena, 60 and a half, retiring. Her pension would be $2,500 a month ($30,000 a year), and the commuted value is $410,000. Her factor is 11.6, halfway between 11.5 at 60 and 11.7 at 61, so her limit is $30,000 x 11.6 = $348,000 and her excess is $62,000 ($410,000 – $348,000). With $45,000 of other income that year, the excess adds $17,660.88 of tax. She has $8,000 of RRSP room: contributing and deducting it cuts the extra tax to $15,142.48, a saving of $2,518.40, and leaves $38,857.52 of cash after tax ($62,000 – $8,000 – $15,142.48).
  3. What each faces next. Marcus has 13 years for his $260,000 to grow before 65, and he gives up a fixed pension that does not grow. Lena has to make $348,000 plus her savings last from 60, without the splitting her pension would have allowed before 65.

The lesson. The same rules can leave one member fully sheltered and the other paying over $15,000 in tax. Age, RRSP room and the size of the commuted value against the pension decide how much of the lump sum you really keep.

Pension or Lump Sum FAQ

Is it better to take a pension or a lump sum?

It depends on your health, whether the pension is indexed, your spouse’s survivor needs, the plan’s strength and your ability to invest. A pension guarantees income for life. A lump sum gives control and an estate but carries market and longevity risk. In our hypothetical case, a $520,000 lump sum needs 5.48% a year to match a $36,000 pension to age 90.

What is the commuted value of a pension?

It is the lump sum a defined benefit plan says your pension is worth today: the amount it would need to set aside now to pay your pension for life. The plan’s actuary sets it using interest rates and life expectancy assumptions, so it can change from month to month. Lower interest rates produce higher commuted values for the same pension.

How much of my commuted value can I transfer tax-free?

The limit is your yearly lifetime pension times a present value factor for your age, from the Income Tax Regulations. The factor is 9.0 under 50, 11.5 at 60 and 12.4 at 64 and 65. A $36,000-a-year pension at 64 can move $446,400 tax-deferred. Anything above the limit is paid to you and taxed.

What is the taxable portion of a commuted value?

It is the part of the commuted value above the tax-free transfer limit. It must be paid to you and is included in your income for the year. You can contribute it to an RRSP and deduct it within your unused room. On a $73,600 excess with $40,000 of other income, the extra 2026 Ontario tax is $20,903.25.

Can I put the taxable excess into my RRSP?

Yes, but only your unused RRSP room makes it deductible. The excess is still included in your income, and the RRSP deduction offsets it. Contributions more than $2,000 above your deduction limit are taxed at 1% a month. Please check your room on your latest notice of assessment before you contribute.

Does a pension transfer to a LIRA get taxed?

No, not when the tax-deferred part moves directly from the plan to a LIRA or locked-in RRSP. The administrator issues no T4A slip and withholds no tax on a direct transfer, and it can use Form T2151 to record it. Tax applies later, when you draw money out of the LIF or annuity the LIRA becomes.

Why is the transfer factor highest at 64 and 65?

The factor reflects the value today of a pension that starts at 65. At younger ages, payments are further away, so the factor is lower: 9.4 at 50 and 11.5 at 60. After 65, fewer payments remain to be expected, so it falls: 10.6 at 70 and 7.3 at 80. It reaches 3.0 at 96 or over.

Should I take the commuted value if I am in poor health?

Poor health is one of the strongest reasons people consider the lump sum, because a pension pays less in total to someone who dies early. Check the survivor options first: if your spouse would receive a survivor pension, the pension may still be worth more to your household. The commuted value then goes to your beneficiaries, subject to tax at death.

Can I split my pension with my spouse before 65?

Yes, if you keep it as a pension. A pension plan’s life annuity payments qualify for splitting whatever your age, on up to 50% of the taxable part. If you take the commuted value and draw a LIF or RRIF, those payments qualify for splitting only from 65. For Sophie and Daniel, both 58, splitting saves $1,350.67 a year.

How do interest rates affect my commuted value?

They move it in the opposite direction. A plan needs a bigger lump sum to fund the same pension when rates are low. In a simple illustration, $36,000 a year for 26 years is worth $662,873 at 3%, $598,395 at 4% and $543,382 at 5%. Your plan uses its own actuarial assumptions, but the direction is the same.

Is my pension protected if my employer goes bankrupt?

It depends on the plan’s funding and the pension law that governs it. If a plan winds up while underfunded, benefits can be reduced. If your plan has bought annuities from an insurer for retirees, Assuris protects each pensioner’s monthly income up to $5,000 a month or 90% of the promised amount, whichever is higher.

Does a commuted value affect my OAS?

Only the taxable excess does, if you are 65 or older and receive OAS. It counts toward net income, and for the 2026 income year OAS is reduced by 15% of net income above $95,323. The part transferred directly to a LIRA is not income that year, so it does not count until you withdraw it.

Pension or lump sum is a one-time choice: work out your limit, your tax and the return you would need before the deadline.

Our editorial standards explain how we check every figure, and each example on this page was computed with the same 2026 tax engine our calculators use. For the next stage, see our RRIF withdrawal strategy guide, the RRIF guide, the retirement checklist and the income tax calculator.

Figures on this page were checked against the Income Tax Regulations, Canada Revenue Agency publications, Service Canada publications and Assuris on October 28, 2026. We update this page when a figure changes.

Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad Gondaliya, CPA
Sharad Gondaliya, CPAWriter and tax reviewerCPA Ontario No. 61040184

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

  • Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
  • Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
  • Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
  • Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Read Sharad’s profile and verify his credentials

Neha Gupta, CFA, Financial Reviewer at WealthScale
Neha Gupta, CFAFinancial ReviewerCFA charterholder

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.

  • CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
  • Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
  • In financial markets since December 2005
  • More than 2,600 published investment articles

Read Neha’s profile and verify her credentials

General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.