Fixed vs Variable Mortgage in Canada
The fixed vs variable mortgage choice in Canada comes down to who carries the rate risk during your term. A fixed rate holds your rate and payment steady until renewal. A variable rate floats: it is set at your lender’s prime plus or minus a spread, so each change in prime passes straight through. On October 29, 2026, big-bank prime went to 4.70% from 4.45%, after the Bank of Canada set its policy rate at 2.50%. On a $560,000 mortgage over 25 years, an example 5.15% fixed rate costs $3,304.97 a month and an example 4.40% variable rate starts at $3,068.39. This page works out five years of payments and interest if prime holds, rises or falls.
At a glance
The core difference. A fixed rate is set when you sign and does not change before renewal. A variable rate has two parts: a prime rate the lender can move whenever it chooses, and a spread that stays put for the term. Each time the lender changes prime, your rate follows.
Prime today. All six of the largest banks, plus Equitable Bank, took prime from 4.45% to 4.70% on October 29, 2026. TD’s variable mortgages float on its own base, the TD Mortgage Prime Rate, at 4.85%. The next policy rate announcement is December 9, 2026.
Today’s gap. At the five lenders that publish both a special 5-year fixed rate and a special 5-year variable rate, the variable rate is between 0.64 and 0.89 points lower, as checked November 7, 2026. Our examples use 5.15% fixed and 4.40% variable, a 0.75-point gap.
Five-year result. On $560,000 over 25 years, the example variable rate saves $20,155.06 of interest over five years if prime holds, saves $34,500.49 if prime falls 0.75 points, and costs $5,898.23 more if prime rises 1.50 points by year three. It breaks even if prime rises about 0.96 points at the start of year two and stays there.
Two kinds of variable. Adjustable-payment versions change the payment whenever the rate moves. Static-payment versions keep the payment where it is and shift the split between interest and principal; if the rate reaches the trigger rate, the payment covers only interest.
Penalties. Ending a closed fixed term early usually costs the larger of three months’ interest and the interest rate differential. Our penalty calculator shows three months’ interest for a variable rate, but the federal sample disclosure for variable rates words its penalty the same way as the fixed one, so your agreement decides.
| Feature | Fixed rate | Variable rate |
|---|---|---|
| How the rate is set | Agreed when you sign, for the whole term | Lender’s prime rate plus or minus a spread |
| When the rate changes | Not before the term ends | Each time the lender’s prime rate changes |
| Payment during the term | The same every month | Adjustable: moves with the rate. Static: stays the same |
| Starting rate | Usually higher | Usually below the fixed rate for the same term |
| RBC special 5-year rate, 25-year amortization or less | 5.140% | RBC Prime minus 0.300% (4.400%) |
| Example rate on this page | 5.15% | 4.40% (prime 4.70% minus an example 0.30%) |
| Example starting monthly payment | $3,304.97 | $3,068.39 |
| Interest over 5 years if prime holds | $135,100.91 | $114,945.85 |
| Balance after 5 years if prime holds | $496,802.66 | $490,842.28 |
| Effect of the October 29 prime rise | None on a term already signed | Rate up 0.25 points; adjustable payment up $76.96 a month in our example |
| Who carries rate risk during the term | The lender | You |
| Usual penalty to break the term | Greater of three months’ interest or the IRD | Set by your agreement; our calculator shows three months’ interest |
| Trigger rate | Does not apply | Applies to static-payment versions |
| Negative amortization possible | No | Yes, on a static payment past the trigger rate |
| Stress test qualifying rate in our example | 7.15% | 6.40% |
| Income needed to keep housing costs within 39% (example) | $139,826 | $131,912 |
| Compounding in the federal sample disclosure | Twice a year, charged monthly | Twice a year, charged monthly; RBC states monthly for its variable rates |
| Capped option | Not needed | Some lenders offer one, such as Desjardins’ protected variable at 4.95% with a 7.54% maximum |
| Open version, posted | 1-year open 9.95% at RBC, TD and BMO | 5-year variable open: RBC Prime plus 3.300%; CIBC 8.00% |
| Best fit | A budget that needs a known payment | A budget with room for higher payments or a longer payoff |
This calculator works out the payment for any rate you type in, along with what the term costs in interest and what you will still owe at renewal; try it at a fixed rate, then at a variable rate, to see the starting gap on your own numbers.
1. The Short Answer on Fixed vs Variable Mortgages
Neither wins by rule. A variable rate starts lower and wins whenever prime stays flat, falls or rises only a little. A fixed rate costs more at the start and wins when prime rises far enough, early enough. Nobody, including your lender, knows which path prime will take, so the useful question is which outcome your budget can live with.
What the numbers say. In our example, the variable rate starts $236.58 a month below the fixed rate ($3,304.97 – $3,068.39). Over five years it saves $20,155.06 of interest if prime holds at 4.70%. For the variable to cost as much interest as the fixed, prime would have to rise about 0.96 points at the start of year two and stay there for the rest of the term, or about 2.00 points if the rise came at the start of year four.
What a variable rate asks of you. On an adjustable payment, a 0.25-point rise in prime from today’s level adds $77.93 a month on this mortgage ($3,146.32 at 4.65% against $3,068.39 at 4.40%), and a 1.50-point rise adds $455.26 a month by year three in our rising path. On a static payment the monthly amount does not move, but less principal gets paid, and the balance at renewal is higher. Either way, the cost of a rise lands on you during the term.
What a fixed rate asks of you. You pay for certainty up front: $20,155.06 of extra interest over five years in our flat-prime path, or $34,500.49 if prime falls. You also face a larger potential penalty if you break the mortgage early, because the interest rate differential can apply.
A decision rule, not a forecast. If a higher payment of several hundred dollars a month, or a larger balance at renewal, would cause real strain, the certainty of a fixed rate has value. If you have room in your budget and savings, a variable rate’s lower start counts for more. If you might sell or refinance before the term ends, compare how each agreement works out its penalty (section 5). Section 9 turns this into ordered steps.
2. How Each Mortgage Works
Fixed rate. The rate in your agreement holds from the first payment to the last day of the term, whatever the Bank of Canada does. Your payment is worked out on the full amortization at that rate and stays the same. The lender carries the risk that rates rise during the term, and prices that risk into a higher starting rate. At renewal, the rate resets to whatever is offered then.
Variable rate. The federal consumer agency’s model disclosure writes a variable rate as prime plus an adjustment factor; the rate then changes by itself whenever the lender changes its prime. The spread is set for the term. RBC, for example, publishes its special 5-year variable as RBC Prime minus 0.300%, and TD publishes its special as the TD Mortgage Prime Rate of 4.85% minus 0.31%, or 4.54%. When prime moves, the rate moves by the same amount on the same day.
Adjustable payments. With adjustable payments, the payment amount changes when the rate changes, so the mortgage stays on its original amortization. A rise shows up at once in your bank account; a fall lowers the payment. This is the version our three-path table calls “adjustable”.
Static payments. With fixed payments on a variable rate, the payment stays the same and the split shifts: when rates rise, more of each payment automatically goes to interest and less to principal. The federal consumer agency warns this setup can be riskier than people expect: a rise shows up as a slower paydown, not as a bigger payment.
The trigger rate. On a static payment, the trigger rate is the level at which each regular payment goes entirely to interest. On our $560,000 example with a $3,068.39 payment, it sits at about 6.67% at the start of the term and about 6.99% after two years on schedule, as the balance falls. Past it, the interest your payment misses generally joins the balance, which grows instead of shrinking; that is negative amortization. The bank may then ask for a bigger payment, an extra payment or a move to a fixed rate, or lengthen the amortization where the maximum allows.
| Mortgage type | Monthly payment | Interest in the first month | Principal in the first month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed at 5.15% | $3,304.97, unchanged | Unchanged | Unchanged |
| Variable, adjustable, before the rise (4.15%) | $2,991.43 | $1,920.13 | $1,071.30 |
| Variable, adjustable, after the rise (4.40%) | $3,068.39 | $2,034.76 | $1,033.63 |
| Variable, static payment, after the rise (4.40%) | $2,991.43, unchanged | $2,034.76 | $956.67 |
3. Variable Rate Mortgage Prime: Where Prime Is Now
The October 28 decision. The Bank of Canada raised its overnight rate target by a quarter point on October 28, 2026, from 2.25% to 2.50%, alongside a 2.75% Bank Rate and a 2.45% deposit rate. The new target applied from October 29. That ended a long pause. The target had sat at 2.25% since the last cut took effect on October 29, 2025, through seven straight decisions ending September 2, 2026.
Prime followed the same day. All six of the largest banks, plus Equitable Bank, announced on October 28 that their prime rate would go from 4.45% to 4.70% the next day. Tangerine lists the same 4.70% from October 29, and Desjardins and Manulife Bank also show 4.70%, undated. The Bank of Canada’s weekly six-bank prime figure moved to 4.70% for the week of November 4, and no lender showed a further change on November 7. Our prime rate page tracks each change, and our Bank of Canada rate page keeps the policy rate history.
TD’s separate base. TD is the exception: its variable mortgages float on a TD Mortgage Prime Rate of 4.85%, which sits 0.15 points above TD Prime at 4.70%. Its special 5-year variable is 4.54%, that base less 0.31%. When you set a TD variable offer against another bank’s, compare the final rates rather than the spreads, because the spreads sit on different bases.
Posted rates sit far above specials. Each week the Bank of Canada publishes a conventional 5-year rate built from the six biggest banks’ posted rates, taking the figure most of them post; for the week of November 4, 2026 it read 6.19%. Special 5-year fixed rates at the same banks are between 5.14% and 5.39%. The gap matters when you break a fixed mortgage, because some penalty methods start from posted rates (section 5).
| Lender | Posted 5-year fixed | Special 5-year fixed | 5-year variable, posted | Special 5-year variable |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RBC | 6.190% | 5.140% (amortization 25 years or less); 5.240% (over 25 years) | RBC Prime plus 0.000% | RBC Prime minus 0.300% (4.400%); minus 0.200% (4.500%) over 25 years |
| TD | 6.14% | 5.39% | TD Mortgage Prime Rate (4.85%) | 4.54% (TD Mortgage Prime Rate minus 0.31%) |
| BMO | 6.090% | 5.14% (Smart Fixed, under 25 years) | 4.700% | 4.35% (under 25 years); 4.45% (over 25 years) |
| Scotiabank | 6.190% | None published | Scotia Flex Value 5-year closed 5.15% | None published separately |
| CIBC | 6.49% | 5.34% | 4.70% (Variable Flex) | 4.45% (Variable Flex) |
| National Bank | Not published | 4.69% (high-ratio only) | Not published | Not published |
| Desjardins | 6.29% | 4.99% | 4.70% (reduced variable) | 4.35% (reduced variable) |
| Bank of Canada benchmark | 6.19% (six-bank posted mode) | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable |
Special rates are for new mortgages and can carry conditions; RBC’s specials end December 31, 2026, and the TD, BMO, CIBC and National Bank specials have no end date published. Most lenders publish no as-of date; Scotiabank’s posted rates are headed effective November 9, 2026. Rates change; we checked these on November 7, 2026. Our mortgage rates, 5-year fixed mortgage rates, 3-year fixed mortgage rates and variable mortgage rates pages carry the full tables. No lender pays to appear; how WealthScale makes money explains our funding.
What each prime level means for an adjustable payment. The table holds the example spread at prime minus 0.30% and shows the payment on the full $560,000 over 25 years, as at the start of a new term.
| Prime rate | Example variable rate | Monthly payment | Change from today’s prime |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3.95% | 3.65% | $2,840.43 | $227.96 lower |
| 4.20% | 3.90% | $2,915.43 | $152.96 lower |
| 4.45% (before October 29) | 4.15% | $2,991.43 | $76.96 lower |
| 4.70% (now) | 4.40% | $3,068.39 | No change |
| 4.95% | 4.65% | $3,146.32 | $77.93 higher |
| 5.20% | 4.90% | $3,225.18 | $156.79 higher |
| 5.70% | 5.40% | $3,385.67 | $317.28 higher |
| 6.20% | 5.90% | $3,549.70 | $481.31 higher |
The October 29 change in dollars. For a borrower whose variable rate went from 4.15% to 4.40%, the adjustable payment on $560,000 over 25 years rose from $2,991.43 to $3,068.39, or $76.96 a month and $923.52 a year. Per $100,000 borrowed it went from $534.18 to $547.93, up $13.75. On a static payment, the $2,991.43 stayed the same, but first-month interest rose from $1,920.13 to $2,034.76, so $114.63 less went to principal.
Dates to watch. The Bank of Canada makes its last 2026 rate call on Wednesday, December 9, at 9:45 a.m. ET. Eight decisions are scheduled for 2027, the first on January 27 and the last on December 8; our Bank of Canada rate page lists every one.
4. Payment and Interest Over Five Years Under Three Rate Paths
The setup. We borrow $560,000, amortize it over 25 years, pay monthly and sign a five-year term. The fixed rate is an example 5.15% for all five years. The variable rate is prime minus an example 0.30%, starting at 4.40%. Prime changes at most once a year, on the first day of the year shown. Adjustable payments are reset at each change to keep the 25-year schedule; static payments stay at $3,068.39. Every figure uses semi-annual compounding, the same engine as our mortgage payment calculator and mortgage renewal calculator. These are illustrations, not forecasts; our editorial standards explain how we build and check them.
| Path | Year 1 | Year 2 | Year 3 | Year 4 | Year 5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prime holds | 4.70% (4.40%) | 4.70% (4.40%) | 4.70% (4.40%) | 4.70% (4.40%) | 4.70% (4.40%) |
| Prime rises 1.50 points | 4.70% (4.40%) | 5.20% (4.90%) | 6.20% (5.90%) | 6.20% (5.90%) | 6.20% (5.90%) |
| Prime falls 0.75 points | 4.70% (4.40%) | 4.20% (3.90%) | 3.95% (3.65%) | 3.95% (3.65%) | 3.95% (3.65%) |
| Prime path | Mortgage | Payment each month | Five-year interest | Owing at the end of year 5 | Interest compared with fixed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Any path | Fixed 5.15% | $3,304.97 all term | $135,100.91 | $496,802.66 | Base case |
| Holds | Variable, adjustable | $3,068.39 all term | $114,945.85 | $490,842.28 | $20,155.06 less |
| Holds | Variable, static | $3,068.39 all term | $114,945.85 | $490,842.28 | $20,155.06 less |
| Rises | Variable, adjustable | Year 1 $3,068.39; year 2 $3,220.14; years 3 to 5 $3,523.65 | $140,999.14 | $498,685.38 | $5,898.23 more |
| Rises | Variable, static | $3,068.39 all term | $142,868.03 | $518,764.47 | $7,767.12 more |
| Falls | Variable, adjustable | Year 1 $3,068.39; year 2 $2,920.26; years 3 to 5 $2,850.09 | $100,600.42 | $486,133.41 | $34,500.49 less |
| Falls | Variable, static | $3,068.39 all term | $99,931.42 | $475,827.85 | $35,169.49 less |
If prime holds. The variable rate saves $20,155.06 of interest over the term and finishes with $5,960.38 less owing ($496,802.66 – $490,842.28). In cash flow, the lower payment keeps $14,194.80 in your account over 60 months ($236.58 x 60).
If prime rises 1.50 points. The adjustable payment climbs to $3,523.65 from year three, $218.68 a month above the fixed payment ($3,523.65 – $3,304.97). Over five years it pays $5,898.23 more interest than the fixed rate and ends with $1,882.72 more owing. The static version never shows a higher payment, but it pays $7,767.12 more interest and renews owing $518,764.47, which is $21,961.81 more than the fixed borrower and $20,079.09 more than the adjustable borrower. That larger balance then has to be repaid over the 20 years left, so the payment at renewal jumps. Interest in the worst month of this path is $2,607.61, still below the $3,068.39 payment, so the trigger rate is never reached.
If prime falls 0.75 points. The adjustable payment falls to $2,850.09 and five-year interest is $34,500.49 lower than fixed. The static payer keeps paying $3,068.39, so every saving goes to principal: the balance after five years is $475,827.85, $20,974.81 below the fixed borrower’s.
| Rise starts | Prime rise needed, held to the end of year 5 | Prime at that level | Example variable rate at that level |
|---|---|---|---|
| Start of year 2 | 0.96 points | 5.66% | 5.36% |
| Start of year 3 | 1.30 points | 6.00% | 5.70% |
| Start of year 4 | 2.00 points | 6.70% | 6.40% |
| Start of year 5 | 4.10 points | 8.80% | 8.50% |
Reading the breakeven. The later a rise comes, the bigger it has to be to wipe out the savings the variable rate has already banked. A rise that starts in the final year would have to exceed 4 points. That is why the size of the starting gap between fixed and variable matters so much: with a smaller gap, every breakeven in the table would be lower.
This renewal calculator compares two offers on the same balance: enter a fixed rate as offer A and a variable rate as offer B to see both payments side by side, with each offer’s term interest and closing balance. It holds each rate steady, so treat the variable column as the prime-holds case.
Run your own balance through both rate types before you sign.
5. Fixed vs Variable Penalty: Three Months’ Interest or the IRD
The usual rule. Federal consumer guidance sets out the usual approach: you pay whichever of two charges is bigger, the interest rate differential (IRD) or three months’ interest on the outstanding balance. Expect the IRD to come into play when today’s rate for the remaining term is below yours and your contract is under five years old. The IRD sets the interest still owing for the term at your rate against the same balance at the current rate, and the difference is the charge.
The fixed example. Two years into the term, the fixed mortgage owes $536,630.34 with 36 months left. Three months’ interest is $6,909.12 ($536,630.34 x 5.15% x 3 / 12). If the comparison rate for the time left has fallen to 4.40%, the IRD is $12,074.18 ($536,630.34 x 0.75% x 36 / 12) and becomes the penalty. If rates have risen and the comparison rate is 5.90%, there is no IRD and the penalty is the three months’ interest.
The variable example. Two years in on the flat path, the variable balance is $534,128.09, so three months’ interest at 4.40% comes to $5,875.41, the figure our penalty calculator gives for a variable rate. Treat that as the low case. Federal guidance on penalties makes no distinction between the two rate types, and the federal sample variable-rate disclosure words its penalty as three months’ interest or an IRD, whichever is greater. The prepayment clause you sign is what counts, so please read it before relying on the smaller number.
| Case | Balance | Three months’ interest | IRD | Likely penalty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed 5.15%, comparison rate 4.40% | $536,630.34 | $6,909.12 | $12,074.18 | $12,074.18 |
| Fixed 5.15%, comparison rate 5.90% | $536,630.34 | $6,909.12 | $0.00 | $6,909.12 |
| Variable 4.40%, three months’ interest method | $534,128.09 | $5,875.41 | Not used | $5,875.41 |
Posted rates and discounts. When a lender’s IRD uses its posted rate minus the discount you received, the comparison rate can be far below any rate you would be offered today, because posted 5-year rates such as the 6.19% benchmark sit well above the specials. Our mortgage penalty calculator page explains that method and works through it.
Long fixed terms have a legal exit. Where a mortgage runs for more than five years, the Interest Act (section 10) lets the borrower repay it once five years have passed by paying three months’ further interest in lieu of notice. Leaving a 7-year or 10-year fixed term after year five therefore costs no more than three months’ interest.
Open mortgages. Open terms can be paid off with no prepayment penalty; closed terms normally carry one, and FCAC notes it can run to thousands of dollars. Openness is priced in: RBC’s 5-year variable open is RBC Prime plus 3.300%, CIBC’s 5-year variable open is 8.00%, Scotia Flex Value 5-year open is 7.90%, and 1-year open fixed terms are 9.95% at RBC, TD and BMO.
Disclosure helps. A lender has to explain its penalty method in clear terms, including the elements that go into it. Banks that follow the industry code also send a yearly note of the amount you may prepay with no charge, provide an online tool to estimate the charge plus a toll-free number, and put the charge in writing when you ask. An administration fee may still come on top.
Enter the balance, your rate, the months remaining and a comparison rate, and this calculator estimates both three months’ interest and the IRD, for a fixed or a variable mortgage.
6. Qualifying: The Stress Test for Each Rate Type
Same rule, different starting point. Banks and other federally regulated lenders add a 2-point buffer to your contract rate and use 5.25% as a floor, and the insurance rules use the same buffer and floor. CMHC applies the test to fixed, adjustable and variable rate mortgages, standard or capped, and qualifies each part of a multi-rate mortgage separately. Because the variable contract rate is lower, its qualifying rate is lower too.
| Rate type | Example contract rate | Qualifying rate | Monthly payment at the qualifying rate | Income needed to keep housing costs at 39% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed | 5.15% | 7.15% | $3,974.33 | $139,826 |
| Variable | 4.40% | 6.40% | $3,717.13 | $131,912 |
Reading it. The same buyer needs $7,914 less gross household income to qualify on the variable rate ($139,826 – $131,912), using the federal consumer agency’s guide that housing costs shouldn’t be more than 39% of gross income. But the variable’s qualifying payment, $3,717.13, is exactly what its payment would be if prime rose 2 points at the start of the term. The test assumes you could carry that; the variable rate makes it a real possibility rather than a hypothetical.
At renewal. From November 21, 2024, OSFI stopped expecting a stress test on uninsured straight switches at renewal, and under the Canadian Mortgage Charter insured borrowers can also move lenders at renewal without requalifying. That means you can usually move between fixed and variable at a new lender at renewal without requalifying, as long as the switch is a straight one. Our switching mortgage lenders guide covers what counts. For a purchase, a mortgage pre-approval can hold a rate for between 60 and 130 days while you decide; the length is set by each lender.
Credit unions. Provincially regulated lenders can differ. FSRA’s guidance for Ontario credit unions names no qualifying rate; it expects cautious GDS and TDS calculations backed by stress testing the credit union judges suitable. Our mortgage stress test guide and mortgage affordability calculator show the test with your own numbers.
7. Special Cases: Trigger Rates, Caps, Compounding and Insured Rates
Catching up. A static-payment variable that has slipped behind its original amortization does not get to stay there: in the federal sample disclosure, the borrower must make a lump-sum payment no later than renewal to restore the schedule. The trigger point is a different line, the stage at which the balance has grown past the ratio the lender will accept. Our mortgage renewal guide explains the options at that stage.
Capped and annually adjustable variables. Some lenders sell middle-ground products. Desjardins publishes a 5-year closed protected variable at 4.95% with a maximum of 7.54%, so the rate floats with prime but cannot pass the cap. It also publishes a 5-year annually adjustable rate of 5.79%, reset every year at the 1-year closed fixed rate less a spread. The protection costs 0.25 points against its 4.70% reduced variable.
How variable interest compounds. The federal consumer agency’s sample fixed and variable disclosures both state that interest compounds semi-annually and is charged monthly, and our calculators follow that convention. RBC states that its variable rates are compounded monthly. On our $560,000 example at 4.40% over 25 years, monthly compounding gives a payment of $3,080.96, $12.57 more than the $3,068.39 under semi-annual compounding, so please confirm the compounding in any variable offer.
Insured (high-ratio) rates. With less than 20% down, your mortgage is insured, and several lenders publish lower insured rates for both types. On November 7, 2026, RBC’s high-ratio 5-year fixed special was 4.840% and its high-ratio variable was RBC Prime minus 0.600% (4.100%). Our CMHC insurance calculator works out the premium that comes with an insured loan.
| Lender | High-ratio 5-year fixed | High-ratio 5-year variable |
|---|---|---|
| RBC | 4.840% | RBC Prime minus 0.600% (4.100%) |
| TD | 5.39% | Not published |
| BMO | 4.99% (Smart Fixed, default insured) | Not published |
| CIBC | 4.99% | 4.30% (Variable Flex) |
| National Bank | 4.69% | Not published |
First-time buyers. Insured borrowers who are buying for the first time, or buying a newly built home, have been able to amortize over as long as 30 years since December 15, 2024. A longer amortization lowers the payment on either rate type, but on a static-payment variable it also lowers the trigger rate, because a smaller share of each payment goes to principal. Our first-time home buyer programs guide covers the rest of the support available, including the FHSA.
Quebec. Desjardins publishes its full grid: a posted 5-year closed fixed of 6.29% with a 4.99% special, a reduced variable of 4.70% with a 4.35% special, the protected variable above and open variable terms of 5.95%. It describes its variable rates as its prime rate plus or minus a spread guaranteed for the term.
8. Using Both: Hybrid Mortgages and a HELOC Beside a Fixed Mortgage
Hybrid mortgages. A hybrid, or combination, mortgage splits the loan into a fixed-rate part and a variable-rate part. Federal guidance warns that this kind of mortgage can be harder to move to a new lender later. Each part is stress-tested on its own rate. The table splits our $560,000 evenly, $280,000 at the example 5.15% fixed and $280,000 at the example variable with adjustable payments.
| Prime path | Monthly payment, year 1 | Monthly payment, year 3 | Interest over 5 years | All fixed, for comparison | All variable, for comparison |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Holds | $3,186.69 | $3,186.69 | $125,023.38 | $135,100.91 | $114,945.85 |
| Rises 1.50 points | $3,186.69 | $3,414.31 | $138,050.03 | $135,100.91 | $140,999.14 |
| Falls 0.75 points | $3,186.69 | $3,077.53 | $117,850.67 | $135,100.91 | $100,600.42 |
What the split buys. The hybrid lands between the two in every path. Its payment rises $227.62 a month in the rising path ($3,414.31 – $3,186.69), against $455.26 for an all-variable mortgage, and it keeps about half of the variable’s savings when prime holds or falls. It is a way to cap how much a rate shock can move your budget without paying the full price of certainty.
A fixed mortgage with a prime-based line. A readvanceable plan pairs a mortgage, which can be fixed, with a home equity line priced at prime plus a spread. Your mortgage payment stays fixed, but anything you draw on the line carries variable-rate risk. Our HELOC guide explains the 65% and 80% limits and what a line costs.
Splitting across time. Another way to use both is to choose differently at each renewal. If your lender is federally regulated, the renewal statement must reach you three weeks or more before your term is up, and under the Canadian Mortgage Charter lenders are expected to raise your options 4 to 6 months ahead. That window is the time to rerun the comparison at the rates then on offer, using our mortgage renewal rates.
9. Should I Get a Fixed or Variable Mortgage? A Rule-Based Order
A general order, not personal advice. Work through these in order. The first one that clearly points one way usually settles the question; the later ones refine it. Our other side-by-side comparisons follow the same approach: rules and computed numbers first, then the trade-offs.
- Price the bad case. Work out your payment at your variable rate plus 2 points. On $560,000 at 6.40% over 25 years, that is $3,717.13, the same payment the stress test used. If that payment would strain your budget, a fixed rate’s certainty is worth paying for.
- Count your cushion. Savings that could cover several months of higher payments make a variable rate’s risk easier to carry. Our emergency fund calculator sizes it.
- Measure today’s gap. Compare the special fixed and variable rates offered for the same term at your lender, or through a broker; our mortgage broker vs bank comparison explains the difference. The wider the gap, the more prime has to rise before fixed wins.
- Match the term to your plans. If you may sell, move or refinance before the term ends, compare how each agreement works out its penalty; the IRD on a fixed rate can be the largest single cost of breaking early.
- Choose adjustable or static. If you take a variable rate, decide whether you want the payment to move with prime or the amortization to absorb it, and find out your trigger rate.
- Read the clauses. Check the penalty method, the prepayment privileges and the compounding in each offer.
- Diary the review. Recheck the decision at each renewal, starting 4 to 6 months before your term ends.
A fixed rate may suit you if
- Your budget needs a known payment for the whole term
- A payment several hundred dollars higher would cause strain
- You have little savings to absorb rate increases
- You plan to keep the mortgage to the end of the term
- You would rather not watch Bank of Canada decisions
- The gap between fixed and variable specials is narrow
A variable rate may suit you if
- Your budget can absorb a higher payment, such as at prime plus 2 points
- You hold savings outside the mortgage
- You may sell or refinance before the term ends
- You want the lower starting rate and payment
- You understand trigger rates on a static payment
- The gap between fixed and variable specials is wide
10. Fixed vs Variable Mistakes to Avoid
Comparing spreads across banks. A TD spread sits on the 4.85% TD Mortgage Prime Rate; other banks’ spreads sit on 4.70%. Compare the final rates.
Assuming a variable penalty is always three months’ interest. No federal rule says so, and the federal sample disclosure uses greater-of wording. Your agreement decides.
Taking a static payment without knowing the trigger rate. On our example it starts near 6.67% and rises as the balance falls. Ask your lender for the figure in writing.
Judging by the first payment alone. The starting payment shows only year one. The three-path table shows that interest and the balance at renewal tell the fuller story.
Forgetting the balance at renewal. A static payment that hides a rate rise leaves a larger balance, and the renewal payment has to catch up.
Leaving prepayment privileges unused. Prepayment privileges let you pay extra without a penalty. Using them shortens the mortgage on either rate type and lowers the balance an IRD is worked out on. For how an extra payment stacks up against a contribution, see RRSP vs paying down your mortgage.
Reacting to a single decision. One 0.25-point move is $76.96 a month on our example. A choice made for a five-year term should rest on what you could carry over five years, not on one announcement.
Treating examples as forecasts. Our paths are illustrations. Nobody can say which one prime will follow, so plan for the one that would hurt most.
10 Fixed vs Variable Strategies That Lower Your Risk or Your Cost
1. Pay the fixed payment on a variable rate
If your prepayment privileges allow it, paying $3,304.97 a month on the 4.40% variable instead of $3,068.39 leaves $475,013.44 owing after five years if prime holds, $21,789.22 less than the fixed mortgage and $15,828.84 less than the variable minimum.
2. Learn your trigger rate
On a static payment, ask for the trigger rate at the start and again each year. Knowing that ours starts near 6.67% tells you how much room you have before the payment covers only interest.
3. Compare final rates, not spreads
Write each offer as a single number for the same term and amortization. Spreads only compare cleanly when they sit on the same prime rate, which TD’s mortgage base does not.
4. Read the penalty clause first
Before you sign, find the method for both three months’ interest and any IRD, and whether posted rates are used. That clause can matter more than a 0.10-point difference in rate.
5. Use prepayment privileges every year
Lump sums and payment increases within your privileges cut interest on either rate type, and a lower balance means a smaller penalty if you ever break the term.
6. Match the term to your plans
If a move or sale is likely within a few years, a shorter term or a variable rate with a three-months’-interest penalty clause can cost less than a 5-year fixed with an IRD.
7. Split the risk with a hybrid
Putting half the balance on each rate type halves the payment shock in a rising path: $227.62 a month in our example instead of $455.26.
8. Keep a cash cushion
Savings that could cover several months of higher payments are what make a variable rate a choice rather than a gamble. A high-interest savings account keeps that cushion earning while you wait.
9. Check the compounding
Semi-annual and monthly compounding at the same quoted rate give different payments: $12.57 a month on our example. Ask which applies.
10. Review after each rate decision
After December 9, 2026 and each 2027 announcement, recheck your payment, your trigger rate and how far you are from the breakeven in the table above.
Illustrative Example: Choosing Between Fixed and Variable on $420,000
This example is hypothetical. Maya and Sam are taking a $420,000 mortgage over 25 years with monthly payments and a 5-year term. Their lender offers an example 5.15% fixed and an example variable at prime minus 0.30%, or 4.40% today. Rates are example rates, not offers.
- Starting payments. Fixed: $2,478.73 a month. Variable, adjustable: $2,301.29. The variable starts $177.44 a month lower ($2,478.73 – $2,301.29).
- Qualifying. With an example $380 of property tax and $110 of heating a month, the fixed qualifies at 7.15% with a payment of $2,980.75 and needs $106,792 of household income to keep housing costs at 39%. The variable qualifies at 6.40%, a payment of $2,787.85, and needs $100,857.
- If prime holds for five years. Interest: $101,325.68 fixed against $86,209.38 variable, a saving of $15,116.30.
- If prime rises 1.50 points by year three. The variable payment rises to $2,415.11 in year two and $2,642.74 from year three, $164.01 above the fixed payment ($2,642.74 – $2,478.73). Five-year interest is $105,749.36, $4,423.68 more than fixed.
- If prime falls 0.75 points. The variable payment falls to $2,137.57 from year three, and five-year interest is $75,450.32, a saving of $25,875.36.
- If they sell after three years. With 24 months left, the fixed mortgage owes $393,017.62. Three months’ interest is $5,060.10; at an example comparison rate of 4.65% the IRD is $3,930.18, so the penalty is the $5,060.10. The variable mortgage, on the flat path, owes $390,242.03, and three months’ interest is $4,292.66, if their agreement uses that method.
- Their test. They ask whether they could carry $2,787.85 a month, the variable payment at 6.40%. They could, with savings covering six months of the difference, so the variable rate is an option for them; a couple without that room would weigh the fixed rate more heavily.
The lesson: the choice turned on step 7, their ability to carry the bad case, not on a view of where prime is going.
Fixed vs Variable Mortgage FAQ
Is a fixed or variable mortgage better in Canada right now?
Neither is better by rule. On November 7, 2026, special 5-year variable rates at five major lenders were between 0.64 and 0.89 points below their special 5-year fixed rates. A variable rate wins if prime holds, falls or rises only a little; a fixed rate wins if prime rises far enough, early enough. The deciding question is whether your budget could carry a higher payment.
How does a variable rate mortgage work with prime?
Your rate equals the lender’s prime, adjusted up or down by a spread that stays fixed for the term. When the lender changes prime, your rate changes by the same amount. RBC’s special 5-year variable, for example, is RBC Prime minus 0.300%, or 4.400% with prime at 4.70%. TD uses a separate TD Mortgage Prime Rate of 4.85% for its variable mortgages.
What is the prime rate in Canada now?
Prime at the big banks has been 4.70% since October 29, 2026. The six largest banks and Equitable Bank lifted it from 4.45% the day after the Bank of Canada took its policy rate to 2.50% on October 28. TD’s separate mortgage base, the TD Mortgage Prime Rate, is 4.85%. The Bank of Canada’s next decision is due December 9, 2026.
How much did the October 29 prime increase add to variable payments?
On an adjustable-payment variable mortgage, a 0.25-point rise adds $13.75 a month per $100,000 over 25 years at our example rates. On $560,000, the payment went from $2,991.43 to $3,068.39, or $76.96 a month. On a static payment the amount stayed the same, but $114.63 less went to principal in the first month.
What is the difference between an adjustable and a static variable payment?
With adjustable payments, your payment changes whenever the rate changes, so the mortgage stays on its original schedule. With static, or fixed, payments the amount stays the same and the split shifts: more goes to interest when rates rise. The federal consumer agency cautions that static payments can be riskier than they look, since a rise surfaces as a bigger balance at renewal.
What is a trigger rate?
It is the level at which each regular payment goes entirely to interest. It applies to variable mortgages with static payments. On our $560,000 example with a $3,068.39 payment, it starts near 6.67% and rises as the balance falls. Beyond it, interest the payment does not cover is generally added to the balance, and the bank may want a larger or extra payment or a move to a fixed rate.
How much more does a fixed rate cost over five years?
It depends on what prime does. On $560,000 over 25 years, an example 5.15% fixed costs $135,100.91 of interest over five years. An example variable at prime minus 0.30% costs $114,945.85 if prime holds at 4.70%, $100,600.42 if prime falls 0.75 points and $140,999.14 if prime rises 1.50 points by year three.
How far would rates have to rise for a variable mortgage to cost more?
In our example, with a 0.75-point starting gap, prime would have to rise about 0.96 points at the start of year two and stay there for the variable to cost as much interest as the fixed rate. If the rise came at the start of year three it would need about 1.30 points, and at the start of year four about 2.00 points.
Is the penalty lower on a variable mortgage?
It can be, but not by rule. A fixed mortgage usually pays whichever is larger of three months’ interest and the interest rate differential, and the IRD can be much larger. Our calculator shows three months’ interest for a variable rate, but no federal rule limits it to that, and the federal consumer agency’s sample variable disclosure uses greater-of wording. Your agreement’s prepayment clause decides.
Which is easier to qualify for under the stress test?
A variable rate, because its contract rate is lower. Lenders test you at the contract rate plus 2 points, or 5.25% if that is higher. On $560,000 over 25 years, an example 4.40% variable qualifies at 6.40% and needs $131,912 of income in our example, against $139,826 for a 5.15% fixed qualified at 7.15%.
What is a hybrid mortgage?
A hybrid, or combination, mortgage splits the loan into a fixed-rate part and a variable-rate part, and each part is stress-tested on its own rate. In our 50/50 example on $560,000, the payment rises $227.62 a month in the rising path instead of $455.26 for an all-variable mortgage. Federal guidance adds that a hybrid can be harder to move to a different lender.
Should I choose fixed or variable at renewal?
Run the same comparison with the rates offered at renewal, your balance and your remaining amortization. Moving to a new lender at renewal as a straight switch skips the stress test, which makes it easier to change rate type then. At a federally regulated lender, the renewal statement must come at least 21 days before the term ends, but beginning 4 to 6 months early leaves room to compare.
See the full picture for your own mortgage: payment, penalty and renewal balance under each rate type.
Rates on this page were checked against each lender’s published rates and Bank of Canada data on November 7, 2026, and the mortgage rules against OSFI, Financial Consumer Agency of Canada, CMHC and Interest Act publications in October 2026. We update this page when a figure changes.
Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.
- Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
- Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
- Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
- Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.
- CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
- Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
- In financial markets since December 2005
- More than 2,600 published investment articles
General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.