Methodology · Credit cards · Updated November 9, 2026

How We Rate Credit Cards

Our credit card rating methodology scores each card out of 5 from five inputs: net rewards value at three spending profiles (50%), the annual fee (15%), the purchase interest rate (10%), insurance (15%) and the income requirement (10%). Every input is a figure the issuer publishes, checked on October 28, 2026. This page prints the whole model: the formula and scales, the spending profiles, every adjustment, how points are valued, what is left out, a worked example and the result for all 56 cards. No payment from a card issuer changes a score. The CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite Card leads at 3.7 / 5.

Written by a CPASharad Gondaliya, CPA Ontario No. 61040184
CFA charterholder reviewerNeha Gupta, CFA reviews our investing and account pages; each page shows its review status
Figures checkedOctober 28, 2026
One published modelThe same rules for all 56 cards, with no paid placement

At a glance

What we rate. 56 personal credit cards from 16 issuers. The 34 cards with every figure the model needs get a score out of 5, shown to one decimal. The other 22 are compared on every verified figure but not rated, and the reason for each is printed on this page.

The formula. Overall score = (50 x rewards value + 15 x fees + 10 x interest + 15 x insurance + 10 x income access) / 100. Each sub-score runs from 0 to 5 and is rounded to two decimals before it is weighted; the overall score is then rounded to one decimal, half up, so 1.25 shows as 1.3.

Rewards value. Yearly rewards minus the annual fee at three spending profiles, $1,000, $2,500 and $5,000 a month, averaged. An average of $700 a year or more earns the full 5 points.

Points. Points count only at a fixed value the issuer publishes. For American Express Membership Rewards, MBNA Rewards and TD Rewards, that is the travel redemption value. Programs with no published fixed value, such as Aeroplan and Scene+, are never converted into dollars by us, so those cards are not rated.

What never counts. Welcome offers, first-year fee rebates, credits such as The Platinum Card’s travel and dining credits, lounge access and any payment from an issuer.

When figures were checked. The current scores use figures checked on October 28, 2026, and were recalculated on November 9, 2026 with the cards we rechecked that day, as set out under what changed on November 9, 2026. Every score is recalculated as soon as an input changes.

50%Weight of net rewards value in the overall score
3Spending profiles: $1,000, $2,500 and $5,000 a month
$700Average net yearly value that earns the full 5 points for value
34 of 56Cards with every figure needed for a score

1. Credit Card Rating Methodology: The Rules Behind Every Score

Published figures only. Every input is a figure the issuer publishes on its card page, its rates and fees disclosure, its benefits guide or its certificate of insurance. All of them were checked on October 28, 2026. We do not use estimates, figures recalled from earlier years, sales calls or another publisher’s summary.

One model for every card. All 56 cards run through the same three spending profiles and the same five scales. There are no hand adjustments to any card’s score, no editor’s picks and no bonus points. The modelling choices we do make, such as which Tangerine categories count as chosen, are listed in section 7 and apply to every card in the same position.

Unknowns are not guessed. If the annual fee or a dollar value for the rewards at any of the three profiles is not published, the card is not rated. If only the purchase rate or the income requirement is missing, that part of the score takes the median of the cards that publish it, so a gap neither helps nor hurts. An issuer can always change its result by publishing the missing figure.

The same engine as our calculator. Rewards are worked out with the same code that runs the credit card rewards calculator on our credit card comparison pages. Enter a profile’s seven monthly amounts and you get the same rewards and net value printed in our tables.

Issuer payments never count. WealthScale has no partner (affiliate) links today, and no issuer has paid for a place, a score or a position on any list. If labelled partner links are added later, payment will still never change which cards we include, their scores, their order or how their listing looks, as our page on how WealthScale makes money sets out. Our broker rating methodology follows the same rule.

2. The Five Factors, Their Weights and Scales

Why value carries half. What a card returns on your everyday spending, after its fee, is the reason most people choose one card over another, so net rewards value counts for 50%. The other half covers what you pay and what you get beyond rewards: the fee on its own (15%), the purchase rate (10%), insurance (15%) and how easy the card is to qualify for (10%).

The five factors in the WealthScale credit card score
FactorWeightScale (0 to 5)Examples
Rewards value50%5 x average net yearly value across the three profiles / $700, capped at 5 and floored at 0$513 average gives 3.66; $700 or more gives 5; a negative average gives 0
Fees15%5 x (1 – annual fee / $200), floored at 0$0 gives 5.00; $120 gives 2.00; $139 gives 1.53; $200 or more gives 0
Interest10%5 x (22.99% – purchase rate) / 10 points, kept between 0 and 521.99% gives 0.50; 20.99% gives 1.00; 12.99% or lower gives 5.00; 22.99% or higher gives 0
Insurance15%5 x coverage types included / 66 types give 5.00; 5 give 4.17; 3 give 2.50; none gives 0
Income access10%Personal income requirement: $15,000 or less 5; up to $60,000 3.5; up to $80,000 2.5; above $80,000 1.5$12,000 gives 5; $60,000 gives 3.5; $80,000 gives 2.5

The fee counts twice, on purpose. The annual fee is subtracted inside rewards value and also scored on its own. Rewards depend on how you spend, which no profile matches exactly, while the fee is certain and charged whatever you spend. Scoring it separately gives weight to that certainty, so a card that only beats a no-fee card at high spending does not rank as if every reader spends that much.

Why $700 and 22.99%. The $700 ceiling on value means only a card returning very high net value across all three profiles reaches 5; today one card does, the MBNA Rewards World Elite Mastercard at an average of $820. The interest scale runs from 22.99%, one point above the 21.99% charged by 28 of the 46 cards that publish a purchase rate, down to 12.99%, so each percentage point below 22.99% adds 0.5 and a low-rate card at 12.99% or less reaches the full 5.

How the sub-scores combine. Each sub-score is first rounded to two decimals, the figure our tables show. The five rounded sub-scores are then multiplied by their weights, added and divided by 100, and that result is rounded to one decimal, half up, for the overall score.

3. The Three Spending Profiles

Three patterns, not one. A card that wins at $5,000 a month can lose at $1,000, especially if it has a fee. We price every card at three round spending patterns and average the results, so the score rewards cards that hold their value across spending levels. The profiles are test patterns, not statistics about Canadian households.

The three spending profiles used in every credit card score (monthly spending by category)
CategoryLightTypicalHigh
Groceries$300$600$1,000
Gas and EV charging$150$250$400
Dining$100$250$600
Public transit$50$100$150
Recurring bills$100$300$500
Travel$0$200$800
Everything else$300$800$1,550
Total a month$1,000$2,500$5,000
Total a year (x 12)$12,000$30,000$60,000

What each category covers. Groceries are grocery store purchases; gas includes EV charging where the card pays the same rate; dining covers restaurants and food delivery where the card names them; transit is public transit and, where the issuer includes it, rideshare; recurring bills are pre-authorized payments and subscriptions; travel is flights, hotels and travel bookings; everything else is the rest. The Light profile has no travel spending, so a travel-only bonus adds nothing there.

From monthly to yearly. Each monthly amount is multiplied by 12. The Light profile is $12,000 of yearly spending, Typical $30,000 and High $60,000, and all three are run through the card’s caps as yearly limits.

Try your own numbers. The rewards calculator on our credit cards in Canada hub takes any seven monthly amounts, so you can see how the ranking changes for your own spending.

4. How Rewards Value Is Worked Out

Step 1: rewards in each category. Yearly spending in a category is multiplied by the card’s earn rate for it, expressed as a cash value (for points cards, the published value of the points earned per dollar). Where the card does not name a category, the card’s rate for everything else applies.

Step 2: caps. Spending above a yearly cap earns the rate the card pays after the cap. Where one cap covers several categories, it is shared in proportion to the spending in each. At the High profile, for example, the Simplii Financial Cash Back Visa Card’s 1.5% rate on groceries, gas and pre-authorized payments applies to $15,000 of the $22,800 spent in those categories ($12,000 + $4,800 + $6,000), so $225 is earned at 1.5% ($15,000 x 1.5%) and $39 at 0.5% ($7,800 x 0.5%), $264 in all. Monthly caps are applied as yearly totals: the Amex Cobalt’s $2,500 a month on eats and drinks becomes $30,000 a year.

Step 3: subtract the annual fee. Net value is total rewards minus the regular annual fee. A first-year rebate or waiver is not used, because it applies once.

Step 4: average and scale. The three net values are averaged, and the value sub-score is 5 x the average / $700, capped at 5 and floored at 0. A card needs a verified annual fee and a verified value at all three profiles to be rated.

Category matching. Issuers name categories in their own words, so each card’s rates are matched to our seven categories as follows. American Express “eats and drinks” covers groceries and dining at 5 points per $1 on the Cobalt; its 3-point streaming rate is not modelled, so recurring bills earn the 1-point base. MBNA’s 5-point digital media, membership and household utility categories are used for recurring bills. Travel uses the rate the card data records for travel: 2% on the CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite and 1% on the CIBC Dividend Visa cards, which CIBC pays on travel booked through CIBC by Expedia, and the 2-point base on the TD First Class card rather than its 8 points through Expedia For TD. On the Scotia Momentum Visa Infinite, restaurants earn 1% because Scotiabank’s 2% food category is food delivery.

How caps change rewards at the High profile ($5,000 a month): three examples
Card and categoryYearly spendCapRewards
BMO CashBack World Elite, groceries$12,0005% on $500 per statement period, applied as $6,000 a year$360 ($6,000 x 5% + $6,000 x 1%)
BMO CashBack World Elite, gas$4,8003% on $300 per statement period, applied as $3,600 a year$120 ($3,600 x 3% + $1,200 x 1%)
Simplii Cash Back Visa, dining$7,2004% on $5,000 a year, then 0.5%$211 ($5,000 x 4% + $2,200 x 0.5%)

5. How Points Are Valued

Only a published fixed value. A points card is rated only when its issuer publishes a fixed dollar value for its points. For American Express Membership Rewards, MBNA Rewards and TD Rewards, the value we use is the travel redemption value in our card data. Where an issuer publishes a lower value for some other use, such as Amazon.ca redemptions at 1,000 Membership Rewards points for $7 or MBNA cash at 120 points per $1, we do not use the lower figure, and we never use a higher value an issuer or anyone else estimates.

Point values used in the scores (October 28, 2026; BMO eclipse and RBC Avion Visa Infinite Privilege November 9, 2026)
ProgramPublished value we useValue per pointExample: earn rate as a cash value
American Express Membership Rewards1,000 points = $10 travel credit$0.01Cobalt: 5 points per $1 = 5%
MBNA Rewards100 points = $1 for travel$0.015 points per $1 = 5%
TD Rewards200 points = $1 through Expedia For TD$0.005First Class Travel: 6 points per $1 = 3%
Avion Rewards (RBC)100 points = $1 for hotels, car rentals and other redemptions$0.011.25 points per $1 on travel = 1.25% (on every purchase on the RBC Avion Visa Infinite Privilege)
BMO Rewards (BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Privilege only)150 points = $1 on travel bookings for this cardAbout $0.00675 points per $1 = about 3.33%
WestJet Rewards100 WestJet points = $1 toward base fares or WestJet Vacations$0.012 points per $1 = 2%
BMO Blue Rewards1,500 Blue Points = $10 in store or toward eGift CardsAbout $0.00672 points per $1 = about 1.33%
Brim points1 point = $0.01$0.011 point per $1 = 1%
Desjardins BONUSDOLLARS1 BONUSDOLLARS = $1$1Earned as a % of spending: 3% on groceries = 3%

Programs with no fixed value. Aeroplan, Scene+, CIBC Aventura and National Bank’s À la carte Rewards publish no single value per point, and neither does BMO Rewards on the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite and BMO Ascend World Elite; what a point buys depends on the redemption. Scotiabank’s own Scene+ examples show the spread: 1,000 points for $10 off Cineplex tickets is 1 cent a point, while 3,000 points for a $20 account credit is about 0.67 cents. National Bank’s examples run from about 0.69 cents ($50 gift card for 7,250 points) to 0.4 cents ($100 off the balance for 25,000 points). Picking one of those values would be our guess, so these cards show their earn multipliers and are not rated. The PC Optimum cards are not rated for a different reason: their earn rates could not be verified.

Transfers and estimates. Transfers of points to airline or hotel programs, and any issuer estimate of what points are “worth” on a typical redemption, are not used. TD’s Aeroplan card page, for example, cites an estimated value per point based on how its cardholders redeem; that is an estimate, not a fixed value, so it does not enter the model.

See the scores applied: compare all 56 cards side by side, or rank them for your own spending.

6. Fees, Interest, Insurance and Income Access

Fees. The fee sub-score uses the regular annual fee for the primary card. A $0 card scores 5.00, a $120 card 2.00, a $139 card 1.53 and any fee of $200 or more scores 0, so the American Express Cobalt Card ($191.88 a year, charged as $15.99 a month outside Quebec) scores 0.20 and The Platinum Card ($799) scores 0. Additional cardholder fees are not part of this factor. For the Desjardins Odyssey Visa Infinite Privilege we use the $395 fee for non-members ($295 for Desjardins members).

Interest. The purchase rate is the rate on regular purchases. A card at 22.99% or more scores 0 and each percentage point below 22.99% adds 0.5, so 21.99% scores 0.50, 20.99% scores 1.00, 19.99% scores 1.50 and 13.99% scores 4.50. For The Platinum Card we use the 21.99% that applies to its Flexible Payment Option balance; the American Express Aeroplan Card’s 30% on balances not paid in full scores 0. Cash advance and balance transfer rates are not scored.

Insurance. We count six coverage types: purchase protection, extended warranty, mobile device, emergency medical, trip cancellation and rental car. A type counts when the issuer lists it for the card; a type the issuer lists as not included, or as an optional purchase, does not. We count types rather than limits, because coverage amounts, day counts and age bands differ in ways that do not reduce to one number. Eighteen cards include all six types and score 5.00.

Income access. The access sub-score uses the personal income requirement the issuer publishes: $15,000 or less scores 5, up to $60,000 scores 3.5, up to $80,000 scores 2.5 and above $80,000 scores 1.5. Household income and asset alternatives are not used, so every card is measured on the same personal figure. 26 of the 56 cards publish a personal income figure.

The median rule. Where a card does not publish its purchase rate, the interest part of its score takes the median of the cards that publish one (0.50; 46 cards publish a purchase rate). Where a card does not publish an income requirement, the access part is set at 3.50, the median of the cards in our October 28, 2026 ratings; cards added since then do not change this value until the methodology is next reviewed. Among rated cards, four take the interest median (the CIBC Dividend Visa Card for Students, the CIBC Select Visa, the Neo World Elite and the Brim World Elite), and 19 take the access median, including cards with no stated minimum, such as the three rated American Express cards, the BMO CashBack Mastercard and the CIBC Dividend Visa Card for Students.

7. Every Adjustment We Make

Why adjustments exist. Some card terms do not fit a fixed spending profile without a choice on our part. Each choice below is written down, applied the same way to every card it affects and visible in the results. These are all the adjustments in the current model.

  1. Rogers Red World Elite and Rogers Red Mastercard are left out: their card facts could not be verified on October 28, 2026.
  2. Tangerine cards: 2% is earned only in the categories you choose (2, or 3 with a Tangerine Savings Account). We model groceries and recurring bills as the two chosen categories and 0.5% on everything else.
  3. Where a card does not name public transit as a category, transit is valued at the card’s base rate. On the Desjardins Odyssey Visa Infinite Privilege, gas and recurring bills are not named categories and are valued at its 1.5% rate on all other purchases, and alternative transportation (4%) is valued as transit.
  4. Low-interest and secured cards with no rewards program are valued at $0 of rewards.
  5. BMO CashBack caps are per statement period; we convert them to yearly limits (12 statement periods). BMO Blue Rewards’ $5,000 maximum per category and $10,000 maximum on other eligible purchases have no stated period; we apply both yearly and value purchases above the $10,000 maximum at $0, which lowers its value.
  6. Monthly limits are applied as 12 times the monthly amount, which matches them when spending is even across the year: Amex Cobalt’s 5 points per $1 on the first $2,500 of combined eats and drinks purchases a month ($30,000 a year), and Neo World Elite’s $1,000 a month on gas, $1,000 a month on groceries and $500 a month on recurring payments ($12,000, $12,000 and $6,000 a year), with 1% above them.
  7. Simplii Cash Back Visa: purchases above its caps are valued at 0.5%, its rate on all other purchases.
  8. Where a card does not publish its purchase rate, the interest part of its score takes the median of the cards that publish one (0.50). Where a card does not publish an income requirement, the access part is set at 3.50, the median of the cards in our October 28, 2026 ratings; cards added since then do not change this value until the methodology is next reviewed.

Which cards each adjustment touches. Transit at the base rate affects the American Express Gold Rewards Card, The Platinum Card and the RBC Avion Visa Infinite. The $0 rewards rule covers the TD Low Rate, MBNA True Line, RBC Visa Classic Low Rate Option, BMO Preferred Rate, Scotiabank Value, CIBC Select and Home Trust Secured cards, and Capital One’s secured card, which is not rated because its fee is not published. On the BMO CashBack World Elite Mastercard, $500 of groceries per statement period becomes $6,000 a year, $300 of transit and of gas become $3,600 each, and $500 of recurring bills becomes $6,000. On the BMO Blue Rewards World Elite Mastercard, the $5,000 maximums apply to groceries and to gas, and the $10,000 maximum to dining, transit, recurring bills, travel and everything else combined.

8. What We Do Not Score

Welcome offers and first-year rebates. An offer pays once and can change or end before you apply, so it never enters a score. The same goes for a first-year fee rebate or waiver: value uses the regular annual fee. Our card pages still show live offers, but only those that end after the page’s publish date or have no end date published.

Credits, perks and lounges. Statement credits and perks are worth something only if you use them, so we leave them out: The Platinum Card’s $200 annual travel credit, $200 annual dining credit and up to $100 in NEXUS credits, the American Express Gold Rewards Card’s $100 annual travel credit, National Bank World Elite’s travel expense refund of up to $150 a year, the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite’s $50 annual lifestyle credit and the WestJet RBC World Elite’s annual companion voucher. Airport lounge visits, concierge services and Visa Infinite programs are left out for the same reason.

Other rates and fees. Cash advance and balance transfer rates, transfer fees, promotional rates and additional cardholder fees are shown on our card pages but not scored. A promotional rate ends, and the other charges apply only to some cardholders.

Insurance limits. We count coverage types, not amounts. A card with emergency medical cover of $2 million for 10 days and one with $5 million for 15 days both count one type. Our credit cards with travel insurance page compares the limits themselves.

Payments from issuers. No issuer payment of any kind affects inclusion, a score or a rank. WealthScale has no partner links today, and if labelled partner links are added later, the model on this page stays the same.

9. Which Rule Orders Each List

Most lists follow the overall score. A best-of list includes the rated cards of its type and ranks them by the overall score, with the tie rules in section 12. Three lists answer a narrower question and are sorted by the figure that answers it: purchase rate for low-interest cards, annual fee for secured cards and coverage types for travel insurance. The grocery list ranks by rewards on grocery spending alone.

What each credit card list includes and how it is ordered (November 9, 2026)
ListCards includedOrder
Best Credit Cards in CanadaAll 34 rated cardsOverall score
Best Cash Back Credit Cards in Canada14 rated cash back cardsOverall score
Best No-Fee Credit Cards in Canada9 rated cards with a $0 fee that pay rewardsOverall score
Best Travel Credit Cards in Canada13 rated points cards, with 16 more shown as compared but not ratedOverall score
Best Credit Cards for Groceries in Canada27 rated cards that earn rewards on groceriesYearly rewards on $800 a month of groceries, then overall score
Best Low-Interest Credit Cards in CanadaAll 46 cards that publish a purchase ratePurchase rate, then annual fee, then name
Best Visa Infinite Cards in Canada5 rated Visa Infinite cardsOverall score
Best Student Credit Cards in Canada2 rated student cards, then 7 other rated no-fee cardsOverall score within each group
Best Secured Credit Cards in Canada3 secured cardsAnnual fee, then purchase rate, then name; unpublished figures sort last
Best Credit Cards with Travel Insurance in Canada47 cards with at least one of the six coverage typesCoverage types included, then overall score, then name

Why some lists use a single figure. Someone choosing a low-interest card is choosing on the rate, and someone choosing a secured card is mostly choosing on cost, so those lists sort by the figure that answers the question, not by a blend. Cards on those lists still show their overall score where they have one. On lists ordered by overall score, cards that are not rated never appear in the ranking; they go in a separate “Also compared (not rated)” table with the reason. The low-interest list includes every card that publishes a purchase rate, rated or not, the secured list includes all three secured cards, and the travel insurance list includes every card with at least one of the six coverage types.

Every list page summarizes the rules. Each of our credit card list pages states the weights in a sentence or two, notes the adjustments that affect its cards and links back to this page.

10. Worked Scoring Example: TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card

Why this card. The TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card publishes every input the model uses, so its score can be rebuilt from start to finish without the median rule. The figures below were computed with the same rewards engine as our calculator, and they reproduce the card’s published score of 3.1 / 5 exactly. Our TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card review covers the card itself.

TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card: yearly rewards at each spending profile, worked out with the same engine as our rewards calculator
CategoryRateLight: yearly spendLight: rewardsTypical: yearly spendTypical: rewardsHigh: yearly spendHigh: rewards
Groceries3%$3,600$108$7,200$216$12,000$360
Gas and EV charging3%$1,800$54$3,000$90$4,800$144
Dining1%$1,200$12$3,000$30$7,200$72
Public transit3%$600$18$1,200$36$1,800$54
Recurring bills3%$1,200$36$3,600$108$6,000$180
Travel1%$0$0$2,400$24$9,600$96
Everything else1%$3,600$36$9,600$96$18,600$186
Total$12,000$264$30,000$600$60,000$1,092
Minus the annual fee-$139-$139-$139
Net yearly value$125$461$953

This example is hypothetical in one respect only: the three spending profiles are test patterns, not a real cardholder’s spending. Every card figure is TD’s own, checked on October 28, 2026: a $139 annual fee, a 21.99% purchase rate, a $60,000 personal income requirement, 3% on groceries, gas and EV charging, public transit and recurring bills on the first $15,000 a year in each, and 1% on everything else.

  1. Light profile, $12,000 a year: $108 on groceries ($3,600 x 3%), $54 on gas ($1,800 x 3%), $12 on dining ($1,200 x 1%), $18 on transit ($600 x 3%), $36 on recurring bills ($1,200 x 3%), $0 on travel and $36 on everything else ($3,600 x 1%), a total of $264. Net value: $125 ($264 – $139).
  2. Typical profile, $30,000 a year: $216 + $90 + $30 + $36 + $108 + $24 + $96 = $600. Net value: $461 ($600 – $139).
  3. High profile, $60,000 a year: $360 + $144 + $72 + $54 + $180 + $96 + $186 = $1,092. Net value: $953 ($1,092 – $139). No category reaches the $15,000 cap; the largest is groceries at $12,000.
  4. Average net value: $513 (($125 + $461 + $953) / 3). Rewards value sub-score: 3.66 (5 x $513 / $700 = 3.6643, rounded to two decimals).
  5. Fees: 1.53 (5 x (1 – $139 / $200) = 1.525, rounded to two decimals). Interest: 0.50 (5 x (22.99 – 21.99) / 10).
  6. Insurance: 4.17 (5 x 5 / 6 = 4.1667, rounded to two decimals). TD includes purchase security, extended warranty, mobile device cover of up to $1,000, emergency medical of up to $2 million and rental car cover; trip cancellation is an optional purchase, so it does not count.
  7. Income access: 3.50, because $60,000 falls in the “up to $60,000” band.
  8. Weighted total: 183.00 (50 x 3.66) + 22.95 (15 x 1.53) + 5.00 (10 x 0.50) + 62.55 (15 x 4.17) + 35.00 (10 x 3.50) = 308.50. Divided by 100: 3.085, which rounds to 3.1 / 5.
  9. Rank: the TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite Card and the Tangerine Money-Back Credit Card also score 3.1 / 5. Average net value breaks the tie: TD Cash Back $513, TD First Class $489, Tangerine Money-Back $338, so the TD Cash Back Visa Infinite ranks sixth on our overall list.

What would change the result. A lower fee lifts two sub-scores at once: at $120, the fee sub-score would be 2.00 and the average net value $19 higher. A 3% rate on dining would lift value, and trip cancellation cover included as standard would lift insurance to 5.00. A first-year rebate, which TD offers with its current welcome offer, changes nothing, because the model uses the regular annual fee.

11. Current Credit Card Scores

All 34 rated cards. The table lists every rated card in overall order, with its five sub-scores and average net yearly value at the three profiles. “Median” marks a purchase rate or income figure the issuer does not publish, filled by the median rule. The same order appears on our best credit cards in Canada list.

Current credit card scores as of November 9, 2026, figures checked October 28, 2026 and, for the cards we rechecked, November 9, 2026 (sub-scores out of 5; “median” marks a value filled by the median rule)
RankCardRewards value (50%)Fees (15%)Interest (10%)Insurance (15%)Income access (10%)Average net value a yearOverall
1CIBC Dividend Visa Infinite Card4.792.000.504.173.50$670.003.7 / 5
2Scotia Momentum Visa Infinite Card4.292.001.005.003.50 (median)$600.003.6 / 5
3MBNA Rewards World Elite Mastercard5.002.000.502.502.50$820.003.5 / 5
4Neo World Elite Mastercard4.761.270.50 (median)3.332.50$667.003.4 / 5
5American Express Cobalt Card4.630.200.504.173.50 (median)$648.123.4 / 5
6TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card3.661.530.504.173.50$513.003.1 / 5
7TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite Card3.491.530.505.003.50$489.003.1 / 5
8Tangerine Money-Back Credit Card2.415.001.023.335.00$338.003.1 / 5
9Desjardins Odyssey World Elite Mastercard3.351.751.045.002.50$468.673.0 / 5
10WestJet RBC World Elite Mastercard3.081.531.005.002.50$431.002.9 / 5
11Desjardins Odyssey Visa Infinite Privilege Card2.960.005.005.001.50$414.002.9 / 5
12Tangerine Money-Back World Mastercard2.415.001.023.333.50$338.002.9 / 5
13BMO CashBack World Elite Mastercard3.841.530.502.502.50$537.002.8 / 5
14Simplii Financial Cash Back Visa Card2.825.000.501.673.50 (median)$395.332.8 / 5
15CIBC Dividend Visa Card2.595.000.501.673.50 (median)$363.002.7 / 5
16CIBC Dividend Visa Card for Students2.595.000.50 (median)1.673.50 (median)$363.002.7 / 5
17BMO CashBack Mastercard2.275.000.501.673.50 (median)$318.002.5 / 5
18Student BMO CashBack Mastercard2.275.000.501.673.50 (median)$318.002.5 / 5
19Brim World Elite Mastercard1.792.770.50 (median)5.003.50 (median)$251.002.5 / 5
20RBC Avion Visa Infinite1.642.001.005.003.50$230.002.3 / 5
21TD Cash Back Visa Card1.655.000.501.673.50 (median)$231.002.2 / 5
22Scotia Momentum No-Fee Visa Card1.665.001.000.003.50 (median)$232.002.0 / 5
23American Express Gold Rewards Card1.700.000.504.173.50 (median)$238.001.9 / 5
24RBC Visa Classic Low Rate Option0.004.505.001.673.50 (median)-$20.001.8 / 5
25TD Low Rate Visa Card0.004.385.001.673.50 (median)-$25.001.8 / 5
26BMO Preferred Rate Mastercard0.004.284.501.673.50 (median)-$29.001.7 / 5
27MBNA True Line Mastercard0.005.005.000.003.50 (median)$0.001.6 / 5
28BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Privilege Card0.880.000.505.001.50$123.671.4 / 5
29Scotiabank Value Visa Card0.004.284.500.003.50 (median)-$29.001.4 / 5
30Home Trust Secured Visa0.005.001.500.003.50 (median)$0.001.3 / 5
31BMO Blue Rewards World Elite Mastercard0.231.250.503.332.50$32.671.1 / 5
32RBC Avion Visa Infinite Privilege0.190.001.005.001.50$26.001.1 / 5
33CIBC Select Visa Card0.004.280.50 (median)0.003.50 (median)-$29.001.0 / 5
34The Platinum Card0.000.000.504.173.50 (median)-$381.001.0 / 5

Reading the bottom of the table. The low-interest cards score 0 for value, because they pay no rewards, so their net value is zero or, with a fee, below zero, but they score 4.50 or 5.00 for interest; their real ranking is on the low-interest credit cards list. The Platinum Card’s net value is negative at all three profiles because its $799 fee is larger than the rewards, and its credits and lounge access are not scored.

Cards compared but not rated. These 22 cards appear in our comparison table with every verified figure. The third column shows the sub-scores we can still calculate; without a rewards value or an annual fee, no overall score is given.

Cards we compare but do not rate, and why (November 9, 2026)
CardWhy it is not ratedSub-scores we can still work out
American Express Aeroplan CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any of the seven categories: Aeroplan points have no published fixed valueFees 2.00; interest 0.00; insurance 2.50
American Express Aeroplan Reserve CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aeroplan points have no published fixed valueFees 0.00; interest 0.50; insurance 4.17
BMO Ascend World Elite MastercardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: BMO Rewards points have no published fixed valueFees 1.25; interest 0.50; insurance 4.17; income access 2.50
BMO eclipse Visa Infinite CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: BMO Rewards points have no published fixed valueFees 2.00; interest 0.50; insurance 4.17; income access 3.50
Capital One Guaranteed Secured MastercardAnnual fee not publishedInsurance 0.00
CIBC Aeroplan Visa Infinite CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aeroplan points have no published fixed valueFees 1.53; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 3.50
CIBC Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aeroplan points have no published fixed valueFees 0.00; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 1.50
CIBC Aventura Visa Infinite CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aventura points have no published fixed valueFees 1.53; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 3.50
CIBC Aventura Visa Infinite Privilege CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aventura points have no published fixed valueFees 0.00; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 1.50
National Bank mycredit MastercardAnnual fee not publishedInsurance 2.50
National Bank World Elite MastercardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: À la carte Rewards points have no published fixed valueFees 1.25; insurance 5.00; income access 2.50
Neo Secured MastercardAnnual fee not published, and no earn rate published in any categoryInsurance 0.00
PC MastercardEarn rate not published in any category: PC Optimum earn rates could not be verifiedFees 5.00; interest 0.50; insurance 0.00
PC World Elite MastercardEarn rate not published in any category: PC Optimum earn rates could not be verifiedFees 5.00; interest 0.50; insurance 0.00
RBC Cash Back MastercardConflict: RBC states unlimited cash back on the card page but $6,000 tiers in its termsFees 5.00; interest 0.50; insurance 1.67
Scotiabank Gold American Express CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Scene+ points have no published fixed valueFees 2.00; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 5.00
Scotiabank Passport Visa Infinite CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Scene+ points have no published fixed valueFees 1.25; interest 1.00; insurance 4.17
Scotiabank Platinum American Express CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Scene+ points have no published fixed valueFees 0.00; interest 5.00; insurance 5.00; income access 5.00
SimplyCash Card from American ExpressAnnual fee not publishedInsurance 1.67
SimplyCash Preferred Card from American ExpressAnnual fee not publishedInsurance 4.17
TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aeroplan points have no published fixed valueFees 1.53; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 3.50
TD Aeroplan Visa Infinite Privilege CardEarn rate not published as a dollar value in any category: Aeroplan points have no published fixed valueFees 0.00; interest 0.50; insurance 5.00; income access 1.50

Cards not covered. The Rogers Red World Elite Mastercard and Rogers Red Mastercard are not in the comparison at all, because their figures could not be verified on October 28, 2026. HSBC credit cards are excluded because their current availability could not be confirmed.

12. Ties, Updates and How to Challenge a Score

How ties are broken. Scores are shown to one decimal. When two cards show the same score, the one with the higher average net yearly value across the three profiles ranks first; if that is equal too, the cards are ordered by name. The BMO CashBack Mastercard and the Student BMO CashBack Mastercard both score 2.5 / 5 with an average of $318, so they are ordered by name, and the CIBC Dividend Visa Card ranks ahead of the CIBC Dividend Visa Card for Students the same way.

When figures were checked. Following our editorial standards, every input behind the current scores, from interest rates and fees to earn rates, caps, point values, insurance and income requirements, was checked on October 28, 2026. On November 9, 2026 we rechecked 37 of those cards, added eight Visa Infinite Privilege and premium cards, and recalculated every score. A score is recalculated as soon as an issuer changes an input, and a change to one card can move others up or down a list without any change to their own scores.

Offers and dates. Because welcome offers are not scored, an offer ending does not change a score. Offers shown on our card pages are checked against each page’s publish date: an offer appears only if it ends after that date or has no end date published.

How to challenge a score. If you think a figure is wrong, please write to us through our contact page with the card, the figure and where the issuer publishes the correct one. We check it against the issuer’s own published terms. If it has changed, we update the input, recalculate every affected score and list, and change the checked date. Issuers use the same route and get the same treatment as readers.

What Changed on November 9, 2026

Income median held. As of November 9, 2026, where a card does not publish an income requirement, the access part of its score is set at 3.50, the median of the cards in our October 28, 2026 ratings. Cards added since then do not change this value until the methodology is next reviewed. The interest median stays at 0.50, the median of the cards that publish a purchase rate.

Business cards in their own list. Business credit cards are listed and valued in their own list, with their net yearly value at three business spending profiles, but they have no WealthScale score and are kept off the all-cards ranking. Our best business credit cards page sets out how they are valued.

Scores that moved. The Neo World Elite Mastercard rises from 3.1 to 3.4 / 5, because Neo now lists emergency medical and rental car cover, and the Tangerine Money-Back Credit Card from 2.9 to 3.1 / 5, because Tangerine now lists rental car cover. The BMO CashBack Mastercard is now rated at 2.5 / 5, because its $0 annual fee is confirmed. Three new cards are rated: the Desjardins Odyssey Visa Infinite Privilege at 2.9 / 5, the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Privilege at 1.4 / 5 and the RBC Avion Visa Infinite Privilege at 1.1 / 5. Five more new cards are compared but not rated, because their points have no published fixed value.

Changes to the model. If we change a weight, a scale, a profile or an adjustment, we publish the new rule on this page and recalculate every card at once, so no card is scored under old rules while another is scored under new ones.

Credit Card Rating Methodology FAQ

How does WealthScale rate credit cards?

Each card gets a score out of 5 from five factors: net rewards value at three spending profiles (50%), the annual fee (15%), the purchase rate (10%), insurance (15%) and the income requirement (10%). Every input is a figure the issuer publishes, checked on October 28, 2026 and, for the cards we rechecked, November 9, 2026, and the same rules apply to all 56 cards we compare.

Why does rewards value carry half of the score?

Net rewards, what a card pays back on everyday spending after its annual fee, is the main reason to choose one card over another. We measure it at $1,000, $2,500 and $5,000 a month and average the three results, so a card must hold its value across spending levels. An average of $700 a year or more earns the full 5 points.

What spending profiles do you use?

Light is $1,000 a month: $300 on groceries, $150 on gas, $100 on dining, $50 on transit, $100 on recurring bills, nothing on travel and $300 on everything else. Typical is $2,500 a month and High is $5,000, with every category set out in our profiles table. Each monthly amount is multiplied by 12 and run through the card’s caps.

How do you value credit card points?

Only at a fixed value the issuer publishes, such as 100 MBNA points for $1 of travel or 200 TD Rewards points for $1 through Expedia For TD. For American Express Membership Rewards, MBNA Rewards and TD Rewards, we use the travel redemption value. We never use estimates, transfer values or a value we choose ourselves.

Why are Aeroplan and Scene+ cards not rated?

Aeroplan, Scene+, CIBC Aventura and National Bank’s À la carte Rewards publish no fixed value per point, and neither does BMO Rewards outside the BMO eclipse Visa Infinite Privilege. Scotiabank’s own examples put a Scene+ point at 1 cent for Cineplex tickets but about 0.67 cents as an account credit. Any single value would be our guess, so these cards appear with their earn rates but no score.

Do welcome offers affect a card’s score?

No. A welcome offer pays once and can change or end before you apply, so scores use only what a card is worth every year: rewards at three spending profiles minus the regular annual fee. First-year fee rebates are left out too. Our card pages show live offers separately, with their end dates or a note that none is published.

Do card issuers pay for higher scores?

No. The model has no input for payments: a card’s score comes only from its published fee, purchase rate, rewards, insurance and income figures. WealthScale has no partner or affiliate links today, and if labelled partner links are added later, the weights, scores and list order on this page stay as they are. Our page on how WealthScale makes money gives the full policy.

What happens when an issuer does not publish a figure?

It depends on the figure. Without a verified annual fee or a dollar value for the rewards at all three profiles, the card is not rated. A missing purchase rate takes the median of the cards that publish one (0.50), and a missing personal income requirement takes 3.50, the median of the cards in our October 28, 2026 ratings, so the gap neither helps nor hurts the card.

How are ties between credit cards broken?

Scores are shown to one decimal. When two cards show the same score, the one with the higher average net yearly value across the three profiles ranks first; if that is equal too, they are ordered by name. The TD Cash Back Visa Infinite ($513), TD First Class Travel Visa Infinite ($489) and Tangerine Money-Back Credit Card ($338) all score 3.1 / 5 and rank in that order.

When are credit card scores updated?

Following our editorial standards, a score is recalculated whenever an issuer changes an input. The current scores use figures checked on October 28, 2026 and were recalculated on November 9, 2026 with the cards we rechecked that day. Welcome offers are checked against each page’s publish date but never change a score.

Can I check a card’s score myself?

Yes. Enter each profile’s seven monthly amounts into our credit card rewards calculator to get the card’s yearly rewards and net value, average the three net values, then apply the five scales and weights on this page. Our worked example for the TD Cash Back Visa Infinite Card shows every step, ending at 3.085, which rounds to 3.1 / 5.

Put the model to work: compare all 56 cards, or start with the ranked list of rated cards.

Figures on this page were checked against each card issuer’s published card pages, rates and fees disclosures, benefits guides and certificates of insurance on October 28, 2026. We update this page when a figure changes.

Meet the Experts Behind WealthScale

Sharad Gondaliya, CPA
Sharad Gondaliya, CPAWriter and tax reviewerCPA Ontario No. 61040184

Sharad is a CPA Ontario member (No. 61040184) and a Certified Public Accountant licensed in Washington and Montana, with more than 15 years in accounting and tax, a Diploma in Banking and Finance and a Certificate in Small Business Finance. He checks WealthScale content against primary sources. WealthScale is independent of his firm, Gondaliya CPA Professional Corporation, and provides general information only, not personal financial, investment, tax or legal advice.

  • Chartered Professional Accountant, CPA Ontario
  • Certified Public Accountant, Washington (No. 57629) and Montana (No. PAC-CPAP-LIC-033176)
  • Writing on tax and registered accounts since 2021
  • Reader’s Choice Award 2025 Winner, Best Accountant (Toronto)

Read Sharad’s profile and verify his credentials

Neha Gupta, CFA, Financial Reviewer at WealthScale
Neha Gupta, CFAFinancial ReviewerCFA charterholder

Neha Gupta is a CFA charterholder based in Winnipeg who has worked in financial markets since December 2005. She has published more than 2,600 investment articles and is Head of Operations and Finance at Whiteland Real Estate. She reviews WealthScale’s investing pages for accuracy.

  • CFA charter, CFA Institute (awarded 2023)
  • Post Graduate Diploma in Business Administration (Finance), 2008
  • In financial markets since December 2005
  • More than 2,600 published investment articles

Read Neha’s profile and verify her credentials

General information only. Not financial, investment, tax or legal advice. WealthScale is independent and is published by WealthScale Media Inc., 55 Queen St E, Suite 1205, Toronto, ON M5C 1R6. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.